Open 228 - Mafia in KyleVille - Game Over!

[Muthaa]

Vote: PaltryExcuse

How about now?

[Muthaa]

VOTE: PaltryExcuse

What about now?

It's only karmic retribution if I've done something morally wrong. Like vote a member of town. Do you know something I don't?

Isn't it morally wrong to vote someone randomly?

[Muthaa]

While Karma's reasoning is erroneous, at least he's making the effort to provide reasoning. I see no similar attempts from you (or even posts, for that matter).

So as long as you provide reasoning (whether it's good or bad) you give off a town tell? And not giving any is scum tell? Is that really how you think when you switch votes: giving a crappy reason with it and it's alright? It's the kind of thing that gives off a scum tell.

Well, my vote was random so:

UNVOTE

[Muthaa]

1: No idea where the votes are at;
2: He only LOOKS scummy for the moment;
3: I don't just throw votes whenever I can.

[Muthaa]

@ Muthaa: Quite literally the only thing Empking has done is vote me for exactly the same reason Karma has. My point is even though Karma is flat-out wrong, at least he's making an effort. As far as I can tell, Empking is lurking while voting on someone else's (flawed) reasoning. Which one looks worse?

Also, I never said giving crappy reasoning was a town tell. Would you mind not putting words in my mouth, please? Thank you.

Empking voted for you at the first page and it was his first post and since it's the only thing he did I'd say it's a random vote. Also, I don't think we played long enough to say that someone is lurking.

Karma's vote was obviously a random one. You just started giving him/her minor tells that made that vote stay on you.

None actually look bad...

You said Karma's reasoning was bad and unvoted him, then you voted for Empking because he didn't give one. I put words into your actions not your mouth.

[Muthaa]

1. Empking didn't post during 1 day, I don't think that makes him a lurker.

2. You voted for Karma and then asked which was worse; I said neither.

3. I believe I know how to read.

at least he's making the effort to provide reasoning. I see no similar attempts from you

You did say he didn't provide reasoning. And later (after your vote) you said it's because of the piggyback ride. I wonder why it's only after...

4. Once again: actions, not your mouth.

Is that FoS because I make you look bad or because you think I'm trying to?
Also, that's an interesting change. Whenever you seemed to suspect anyone you voted him/her, why the FoS now?

[Muthaa]

2. Eh? What was this in response to?

What does this have to do with anything?

4.

OMG I didn't notice Empking even posted because of his lack of avatar. And it votes me -- for flipping. And nothing else has been said...

UNVOTE: Karma
VOTE: Empking

While Karma's reasoning is erroneous, at least he's making the effort to provide reasoning. I see no similar attempts from you (or even posts, for that matter).

--
...heh crappy post...

[Muthaa]

Lol. Never mind.

[Muthaa]

drunkpost?

No, but why is there a smiley face...?

I'm on board.

UNVOTE
VOTE: Robocopter

Let's talk, robo.

Getting out of RVS by acting scummy is a retardedly stupid excuse. Maybe this is my personal stance but the RVS is not something that people can just say "oh it was in the RVS so it's not scummy" or "I was trying to get us out of RVS" about.

You've done no scumhunting and you've been flat-out useless. Convince me you're town.

Your reasons being already given out by other people make it look like your a scum jumping on an easy wagon...

@Oopid: Why? There's someone I should be voting for?

[Muthaa]

@Oopid: Explain to me why I should hurry up and vote while there's still lot's of time left for that.

[Muthaa]

@Oopid: As I said before, I don't just throw votes when I can.

@ Muthaa: You seem to be agreeing with Karma's reasoning, and yet you aren't voting me for it.

You said earlier that Karma's reasoning was crappy, so why does it seem you now think it's good enough reasoning for me to vote you?

[Muthaa]

I don't believe that's enough for me to put a vote on. When I usually put a vote (except a random one) it's to stay so I'd rather take my time.

[Muthaa]

I am able to move it, I just don't want to because I feel like I don't have enough info. And whats "srs bsns"?
Does abandoned count as completed?

[Muthaa]

Why aren't people voting him? His arguments do not defend himself, he attacks easy targets, and his one attempt at moving the game forward didn't work and stalled the game even further.

Why are you so hasty about lynching him?

[Muthaa]

Well that was faster than expected... although it has a funny/interesting (w/e the way you people think) ending.

[Muthaa]

And funny (in my opinion at least) lol

[Muthaa]

Am I the only one to see the fail?

[Muthaa]

I see, I'll keep my comments to myself next time uh.

@Merk: What do you mean by that quote?
@Karma: "I always thought giving a pretty easy vote was a fairly valid scumtell."
@Hershey: "Sounds like scum that's trying to make a wagon on an easy vote."

[Muthaa]

VOTE: Karma
Your opportunistic votes. Specially because robo turned out to be town.
Your pushing the definition thing really looks like you're masking it.

[Muthaa]

@Karma: That's funny... no wait interesting -.-... because you voted on Robo day1 and used reasons already given out. If it's not bad when you're pushing someone at L-1 why would it be when I use something SIMILAR to put my vote on you?

@Merk: Were you serious about the "GOD DAMMIT I just started to believe him" (the part of your post after Oopid hammered Robo that looks kind of like what I just said)?

[Muthaa]

Well I got too many games for the time I give to this site and so I made a decision (with a coin). So yeah sorry for putting more work on your shoulders mod.
/request replacement

[Muthaa]

I'll play a little till you find a replacement though; special offer just for you!!

So with that thought:

@Oopid: what didn't you like about it?
@merk: Why not? What tell?

[Muthaa]

@oopid:

I'm a little confused. Muthaa's vote-post on Karma made sense to me. I didn't like Karma's reaction to it. Then Muthaa posted a reply to it that I didn't like, and Karma's reply to that was one that I liked.

Asked about that.

@merk:

@Muthaa: Yes, I believed him when I said that. I was going to unvote him in that post but Oopid crossposted me and hammered.

No, I will not reveal why I believed him then but I doubt that particular tell will come up again this game. Even still, I'm not taking that risk as it's easy to fake.

Asked about that.

Guess you couldn't have checked a page earlier uh.

[Muthaa]

It's not going fast. Btw you want empking dead because you believe he's not doing much or because you think he's scum?