Scummies 2010 Nominations

[gandalf5166]

Thirded! ? Person Closed Setup #8

[gandalf5166]

Just FYI, these people are all doing this for my game. Which was awesome.

That was literally the most I've laughed in my entire life.

[gandalf5166]

To prevent me from being banned, I had to do that. It was part of my win condition: Insult every post in the game. So it's not my fault. I'm not sure if language gets you banned from this site or not. >.<

[gandalf5166]

Nomininating Mr. Flay for the "Name should be in Orange" award for tireless behind the scenes work involving PHP coding, the Wiki and generally everything else that happens on this site.

Seconded.

[gandalf5166]

Nomininating Mr. Flay for the "Name should be in Orange" award for tireless behind the scenes work involving PHP coding, the Wiki and generally everything else that happens on this site.

That's too easy.

Nominate: "Name Should Be In Orange" Award to be retitled the "Mr. Flay" Award

SECONDED!!!!!!!

[gandalf5166]

Nomininating Mr. Flay for the "Name should be in Orange" award for tireless behind the scenes work involving PHP coding, the Wiki and generally everything else that happens on this site.

That's too easy.

Nominate: "Name Should Be In Orange" Award to be retitled the "Mr. Flay" Award

Declined.

See, he's even humble about it!

[gandalf5166]

Nth SpyreX for funniest player

, simply because I don't think I should win an award like that for one post. Also, I discovered that it wasn't actually my WC to insult every post. It was a post restriction, it was just such a daunting task that my mind interpreted it as a WC.

[gandalf5166]

ReaperCharlie should not get an award or even considered for one.

That's not bery nice. And I just realized. Why has FATE not been nominated for Most Outstanding Newbie? I remember hearing somewhere that he might be an alt, is that why? If not,

Nom Fate for Most Outstanding Newbie

[gandalf5166]

Fate is an alt. Or at least, that's what I've seen him say before. And I can't link where I saw him say this because I'd get a face full of modkill for it.

Ongoing? Lame.

[gandalf5166]

Oh..... you probably shouldn't even have said that much, actually.

[gandalf5166]

Nominate Cross Edge Bastard Mod for most Enjoyable Game

There was a bit of end game crap that happened, but it was Caffwagon's fault, not any of the players/mod's. It was a lot of fun.

[gandalf5166]

nth nominatation for LynchMePls for Best Newbie.

I've played a few games with him and he always played very, very well. Look at Mini 1008: Mega Man 1 Mafia, he manage to own the town. His town games are also great.

Hey, I pegged him as scum >.> But no one else would listen >.>

[gandalf5166]

Finding scum is only part of good town play. It doesn't matter if you find every one of them in RVS if you can't get them lynched.

That's exactly what happened. I called them both out in RVS, but I thought shotty was the third scum and lynched him because he was an easier case. Then when he flipped town, I kind of lost trust in my reads.....

[gandalf5166]

He's only a jerk in his scum games.

[gandalf5166]

I refuse to nominate SSBM because my role was forced to suicide.

[gandalf5166]

I DONT SUPPORT IT. YOU ANT WIN A SCUMMY IF YOU ALMOST GET TO LYLO. YOU DIDNT REALLY PLAY THAT AWESOME. BY THE WAY, I AM NOT ONE BIT BITTER.

[gandalf5166]

TRUE, BUT THIS WAS NOT ONE OF THOSE CASES. THE BC LYNCH WAS HORRID.

[gandalf5166]

The only reason for the early game scum lynches going through was me bussing so hard. And FTR, I really did think Myst was an SK. I didn't kill him for the first few nights cause I assumed he was kill-immune.

[gandalf5166]

And not to mention, I so wouldn't have been lynched if not for that stupid setup thing.

[gandalf5166]

Jester is the easiest role to win with ever created. That said, I do think MoI did an incredible job. The way he goaded me onto the wagon was quite interesting.

Second MoI for Best TP Performance

[gandalf5166]

I can't really say, as I was vigged N1. But it sure was an interesting read. That dead QT is awesome.

[gandalf5166]

Actually, there should be an award for best Dead QT.

[gandalf5166]

I would nom Nero, but that would be an offense to MoI's genius play in Personal Agenda.

[gandalf5166]

The thing where it was an item and a player was confusing, and the only reason we weren't able to figure out the setup in the Dead QT.

[gandalf5166]

I still think the strangest thing was the ring being strangled O_o

The ring wasn't strangled, the ring's doppelganger was.

[gandalf5166]

I still think the strangest thing was the ring being strangled O_o

The ring wasn't strangled, the ring's doppelganger was.

This. I tried to convey this in the flavor...

<3 Flay.
Had Mariyta been lynched, you would have appeared as The Balrog and you would have gotten your revenge. (Remember the sign-up thread? lol)

That's another award there should be. Best signup thread.

[gandalf5166]

Mega Man 1 Mafia.
He was wrong.

SECOND it anyways

[gandalf5166]

Nominate ReaperCharlie for Funniest Player

Numerous things, but mainly for his palantir antics in LOTR(along with other stuff from that game) and an ongoing game. Oh, and let's not forget his SI/Help forum posts.

[gandalf5166]

Nominate xRECKONERx for Best Mafia Catcher

for Fates Mafia

Basically, he called all 4 scum in post 52.
No wonder the game last 2 days .-.

Seconded, this was just fucking bizarre

[gandalf5166]

Nominate Snow_Bunny's SITMOA mafia for most enjoyable game

SECONDED

While there were some flaws in the setup, this game was a LOT of fun. Like, definitely more fun than any of the other games I've played recently.

[gandalf5166]

cuz of me bro

Yeah, I think pulling the wool over your eyes was much more satisfying than any of the other players.

[gandalf5166]

I'm sufficiently satisfied at the end though. Directly responsible for 3/4 scum deaths, and malthusis didn't get endgamed.

2/4. I technically didn't die.

[gandalf5166]

nuh-uh you most certainly did.

Your kill didn't work, remember?

[gandalf5166]

Oh. Did he add that later? And it doesn't really matter. I got caught in endgame. O NOZEZ!

[gandalf5166]

IF ANYTHING IS GOING TO WIN BEST SIGNUP THREAD IT WILL BE LOTR MAFIA

[gandalf5166]

Also, you can't nominate ongoing signup threads

[gandalf5166]

I've never played with Thor in a newbie game before, but I can imagine he'd be a great IC.

[gandalf5166]

I've never seen his IC games but he plays anything like how he played in that one mini game I played with him, he deserves it.
I can't second though because... I've never seen his IC games.

This, pretty much.