Mini 1035 - Devil's Town - GAME OVER

[edmund.angles]

vote Untrod Tripod

for having a name that is unpronouncable

But let's get this show rolling, I'll begin with a declaration:
If I don't find anyone scummy at the end of the day I will try to lynch the one I feel have contributed the least (lurkers if any).

And a question:
What do you think is the best way for Town to lynch scum day 1?

[edmund.angles]

@Dr. Pepper: Why is the plan weird? I was afraid it was trivial. Scum have an interest in no discussion, if no discussion happens we lynch people who had the greatest responsibility for this. Sort of "Lynch lurkers if you have nothing better". It should at least force scum to chip in their (counterfeit) 2 cents.

@everyone: Post more, if you have nothing to say then try answering the questions:
How do you feel about "Lynch all lurkers"? and how do you lynch scum day 1?

[edmund.angles]

Zodiark13 posting a video is slightly scummy. I liked it, but it could serve to distract from the game.

I agree with Zodiark13 that Dr. Pepper's last three bullets were some pretty weak tea.

But Blaze has only posted a vote so far, so I'd like to put some pressure to do so:

Unvote vote Blaze

[edmund.angles]

@Dr. Pepper:
Why do you avoid the word scummy? It's certainly not true that you have not

implied

that somthing was scummy. An example:

Edmund's "plan"

* Lurkers get replaced, scum get lynched
* May be used to distance from future a lynch

about Nexus: I didn't like his "callousness with human life". Two votes came in pretty closely spaced and he didn't bother to count the total before voting.

about LynchMePis and Nexus: I find it scummy that they put so much weight on a random vote.

unvote vote Nexus

[edmund.angles]

about Zodiark13's scumbuddy speculation (Blaze,Dr. Pepper): I find scumbuddy speculation pretty useless, it is difficult enough to find one scum at a time, creating complicated theories about connections will only distract us.

@Nexus: It is pretty clear to me that you did not want to bring anyone to 'L-2'- your immediate retraction made that clear. However I consider it a scum tell not to read the thread carefully (scum know their enemies).

about Dr. Pepper: I dislike him avoiding to call things scummy, seems to me like he's not standing by his ideas. Secondly, he OMGUS'ed podium even though he complained about OMGUS. And generally, I find his arguments weird. On the plus side though, he is an active contributor.

about alleged chainsaw defense of Blaze by podium123456: I disagree, Dr. Pepper has done enough weird things to come under suspicion.

@Nexus, Untrod Tripod, Blaze, LynchMePIs and ABR: I would very much like to hear about your suspicions.

[edmund.angles]

clarification on my position on scumbuddy speculation(requested by LynchMe):
If player A is acting strange towards player B, then it's a scumtell on player A but not on B.
With B there's a potential to misinterpret both A's alignment and A's intentions and that's just too uncertain IMO.
But if A is confirmed scum, then I'll look closer at B and vice versa.

@ABR: Please give reasons for your vote.

@Untrod Tripod: Your vote for Nexus was random, please place a real vote. And also happy scumday
@Nexus: Please place your vote.

Our votes are the only thing that will get the scum on edge- use them.

Mod: A prod for Blaze, please

[edmund.angles]

Why do I need to place a vote?

IMO for two reasons. First of all, not having an active vote lets you coast through without really shoving your intentions. Secondly, votes are needed to make the discussion heated which leads to slips.

Let's just lynch him and save both the mod of the trouble finding a replacement and said replacement the trouble of defending from such a terribad position.

I think this smells a little of scum looking for an easy lynch. And Nexus agreed with the statement (@Nexus: That was what you did, right?).

Dr. Pepper comes of as bad town to me, not anti-town.

[edmund.angles]

@Zodiark: I don't find it scummy that you want to lynch Dr. Pepper. I do find it scummy that you want to do it without replacement and roleclaim.

[edmund.angles]

unvote vote: Albert B. Rampage

(L-2)
No matter if he's town or scum, he's a loose cannon.

@TDC: Could you give a breakdown on all the players? If you are lynched and flip town everyone will have a confirmed honest second opinion.

[edmund.angles]

Bah, go Town

[edmund.angles]

GG everyone, nice call TDC, my bet was on podium.