Around half of this game participated in this exact setup last time. We all ended up dead.Muthaa wrote:@Katsuki: Yes I have, I was just wondering if you're asking me to participate in random shit.
Just wondering: how familiar are you with each other?
So how are we supposed to find scum? Just intuition?JesseSheffield wrote:If I had to pick out players who I think are most likely to be scum I'd say you, Phaen.Town players don't normally seek out reasons for players to be scum.That's something scum do because they can't actually pick out other players to be scum, because they're the scum.
Just an willingness to appease. Scum want to blend in and avoid confrontation. It happens again below. My vote staysJesseSheffield wrote:What does this say about gandalf then? How does this make gandalf scum?Scott Brosius wrote:Actually, I think it's more telling that Gandalf obeyed this without question.
Unvote
Vote:gandalf5166
gandalf5166 wrote:I say wagon to mean "a viable lynch target". And sorry, I just assumed that the way you were acting, there must be a huge wagon. And I was on my Wii, so it would have taken me like, five full minutes to find a votecount.
shotty tends to be VIwarriormode wrote:
Gandalf, "He's SHOTTY" is not a valid defense to me. I haven't played with any of you before, I don't know how you play or shotty or anyone else plays. I can only use what I know about THIS game. So come up with a good defense to why you and shotty CAN'T be scumbuddies in THIS game. Got it? Cool.
drmyshottyizsik wrote:unvote
vote mutha
god i'm just not getting into this game, maybe a lynch will move it right along
drmyshottyizsik wrote:unvote
I need to ISO him, I really want to be sure about this
Vigs have to shoot, they have no choice. I guess a protection scheme isn't optimal at this point especially if we don't kill scum.smashbro_of_the_SSS wrote:
what's the point of this random math and night speculation? It's pretty much always better if we only have one vig shoot, and still keep the other one alive for confirmed town purposes. That being said, It might be best to, at the end of the day, set up pools of people, saying all of you protect vig #1, the rest of you protect vig #2. There will be a doctor in each setup, and if a vig does die, then anyone who was supposed to protect him was scum.
I need to get to class now, but I'll be back later with a post, will include who I suspect.
Antihero is another scum read of mine, promising content and not delivering. I'm leaning towards Jesse being town based on the accusations against him for not voting are lame and very easy for scum to jump on. Phaen and Katsuki I don't really have a read on either way, I guess it's more interesting in Katsuki's case since there are a lot more posts saying nothing.HackerHuck wrote:Wow, pretty hard to believe that with six doctors we weren't able to protect any of the three townies that died last night. Good news is no vig deaths, but I was really surprised that all three of those slots flipped town.
This is one case where I think that a massclaim is a really good idea. Given what happened yesterday, Katsuki should go first. Please claim when you post your analysis.
Anyone claiming vig needs to claim their target, but I don't think that the docs need to.
You are unsure about yourself? There is only 1 claimed doc left after everyone else even though you said "the other two". I think this is scum forgetting how many doctors there actually are.Phaen wrote:Sorry about being gone.
My top scum suspects are Scott, Katsuki, and Huck.
I get the sense Jesse is town. The other two I'm just unsure about.
Katsuki wrote:@Scott: Why phaen over hacker?
I find that tell pretty accurate, and it's clear she's following the thread, not commenting on anything though. Hacker is at least participating.Scott Brosius wrote:THe whole claiming a lack of interest in a game for whatever reason I find to be scummy. I find that people who really feel this way replace out, but nobody wants to replace out as scum. Hence people who claim this and stay in the game are usually scum.
But clearly your vote is not going to do anything today. It's going to be me or Phaen. A magical wagon of Hacker is not going to start this close to deadline.Katsuki wrote:I am quite content with my vote on you hacker, thanks.
I will respond to any other stuff that may need responding when I have the time.
Well that's not exactly true. Town doesn't have a majority in 3 town 3 mafia 1sk, but the game should continue.crywolf20084 wrote:It doesn't matter if you're confirm town or not. town cannot continue to play if there is not a majority of town players left.
