Trouble in Minas Tirith! Game over!

[Mr_Gnome_It_All]

/Confirmed, Ready and Willing!

[Mr_Gnome_It_All]

Hmmm... Interesting... So much detail in the death scenes, but I do wish there was a little more detail as to what the now dead roles were able to do (it would just be nice to know what were really missing)

Way to early to vote yet. I'll wait and see what everyone else has to say!

[Mr_Gnome_It_All]

OK, then I guess we're agreed that we've got one evil guy down!

Since it was said that Aragorn was well suited to stalking in the shadows, I'm inclined to believe he might've been something like a vigilante.

And since I believe that nobody

HAS

to start random voting...

Vote Modargo

[Mr_Gnome_It_All]

Yeah, I'm stupid, I forgot to put the word random before my vote (It was an attempt at irony, but it failed miserably)

And Tigris, I'm hardly a youngster at 22! And are you suggesting that I should change my screen name just because you don't want to type it? To be honest, I have considered changing it, but I don't think it would be right to do so while in the middle of the game!

In any case, just so this post isn't a complete waste of space, I'll

Unvote Modargo

because the way everyone is random voting, it seems this day isn't going to get us anywhere

And Flying Dutchman can you tell us how you can confirm that?

[Mr_Gnome_It_All]

I really can't think of much more to say right now!

But since I'm curious to know what Flying Dutchman is thinking, I'll try to help lay a little pressure on him to talk (The same way the fiends of Mordor made Gollum talk in

The Fellowship of the Ring

hehehe)

Vote Flying Dutchman

[Mr_Gnome_It_All]

It would seem like its time to dust off the old thinking cap! Crap, I can't find it! Too early in the morning right now!

First of all,

Unvote: Flying Dutchman

! Your now ok in my book!

So if Zoneace, Thoth, and Tigris were all in the same place as Dragon Pheonix last night, at some time or another, that means one of them had to have kiled DP? I suppose that makes sense! Thoth claims to have targeted one of the people there, Zoneace denies even doing anything, and Tigris has yet to post!

Before I make any decisions as to who I think needs to be taken down, I'm going to wait for Tigris to possibly confirm if FD's info is accurate!

Until then

FOS: All Three Of You

, so don't think I won't be watching!

[Mr_Gnome_It_All]

Well, if this is all true, then there must

have

been a chain of night abilities involving all four of those people FD named, starting with one or more of them targeting Zoneace.

Although, I must admit, I'm still unsure about Zoneace, I've decided I'm going to set my sights on Tigris, until he comes forward with something!

Vote Tigris

I realize I'm not exactly saying anything new, but I was here and since I'd like to be considered an active player, I thought I should add my 1/2 cent (which is all I really have at the moment)

[Mr_Gnome_It_All]

No, I am not scum and find the argument that because 4 people entered one of the possible ways into an area that one must have killed the one that died. There are other ways into that area and the stone did not necessarily come from that area. So I find that particular argument to be crap logic as it ignores other possibilities.

Alright, I'm listening! What other possibilities are we "ignoring"?

I, personally, don't see any other purpose for the information FD recieved, except for what we've already speculated! But if you think you know something else, I'm open to theories!

[Mr_Gnome_It_All]

Well, this is probably going to earn me the title of stupidest idea/post in the game; but I'm just trying to figure out Zoneace's claims!

Maybe, Zoneace didn't have a night ability and instead his going through the gate was the result of a scum group recruiting him as some kind of traitor?

I think it's already been suggested that there might be 2 groups of scum! And if thats the case, one group could have killed, one recruited, serial killer killed, and the vigilante, maybe, WAS dumb enough to kill night one!

I told you it was a stupid theory! But in any case, it's a theory!

Stupid ideas aside, I'm just having trouble buying his story, so I've decided to

Unvote Tigris

and

Vote Zoneace

[Mr_Gnome_It_All]

Well, that wasn't a helpful night! But at least it's only two more dead and not three again!

The pillars must be Oliphants (is that how it's spelled?) and represent the Haradrim kills! The other kill must be the serial killer! So with that in mind I'm starting to think that the night one kills were probably by the Haradrim, Serial Killer, and Vigilante, and since there's only two dead this morning I'd say that either Aragorn was the Vigilante or the Vigilante just chose not to kill!

Anyone else have anything to add to that? Anything I'm missing?

[Mr_Gnome_It_All]

So, then Modargo was evil? I'm afraid I've never actually heard of Khand, since I've never actually read the books, and I can't recall it being mentioned in the first two movies (I'll be seeing the third soon)

[Mr_Gnome_It_All]

My best guess for what Galdalf probably did was role-blocker, although I'm not sure!

And as for the pillars being ents... could be, I guess... Did the ents play parts in these battles? I still don't know, I'll be going to see "Return Of The King" in about 17 hours from the time of this post!

[Mr_Gnome_It_All]

we have nothing to go on right now, and theres like nobody else posting in here, who else herte agrees with my lynching of leo today?

Well, I don't! I see no reason to lynch him! At least, not yet!

In fact I have half a mind to vote for you for being so eager to lynch someone without any real reason!

FOS: bigbenwd

[Mr_Gnome_It_All]

I have to say I'm now curious as to what both Leonidas AND Banana Bob are! Since it's not likely that either are a doctor I'm wondering what either of them were doing at that particular gate last night!

Well, I think I'll do this...

FOS: Banana Bob
Vote: Leonidas

[Mr_Gnome_It_All]

Wow, I wish I'd noticed that! Well, as long as

somebody

noticed it!

That sound like some pretty strong evidence! Strong enough (in my opinion) to change my vote!

Unvote Leonidas

and

Vote Riven

[Mr_Gnome_It_All]

I can assure you I never had (and still don't have) any connection with Zoneace. Ages was correct when he says I was just trying to explore the possibilities. The votes I had put up before voting for Zone were just trying to stir up some information.

And as for the crazy story before switching my vote to Zone, well, I said it was stupid. I just didn't want people to think I was jumping on a bandwagon for no reason (which has gotten me lynched in other games)

[Mr_Gnome_It_All]

No lynch, not an option? That's interesting!

Well, I have no idea who to vote for right now.

Hey, all you scum! Come out and confess your scuminess! You're sins shall be forgiven!

Maybe!

[Mr_Gnome_It_All]

I hate to be a kill-joy, but, Werebear, you do remember your dead, right?

[Mr_Gnome_It_All]

OK, I guess I just don't remember seeing anything that said you were replacing.

But since your back, how about some details on Gandalf. Was it just a normal protection role, and Who did you protect? (I guess the thought of someone coming in as a replacement when they could know something that no one else does, no matter how insignifigant, makes me a little nutzy)

[Mr_Gnome_It_All]

That quote above was indeed in reference to Riven, who I still think is innocent. Why do you continue your vote, MGIA?

I dunno, I just haven't gotten around to removing it yet! It's not like it's doing anything there, but if it makes you happy

Unvote Riven

[Mr_Gnome_It_All]

From what I see, so far there are 5 votes on Orbiting.

Oh, heck,

Vote orbiting

make that 6!

[Mr_Gnome_It_All]

Unvote Corsato

Seems like we're back to square one.

As always, I don know what to say or do now.

[Mr_Gnome_It_All]

Well, I don't like the idea of No Lynch. Does anyone have any thoughts on how many scum are left? I'm not sure but from what others have said it would seem like 2 Men from Khand and 1 more Haradrim, plus the SK? So 4/16 left are probably scum? If that's the case we have at least 2 days to find at least one scum, provided there are still three kiling groups out there. More if any of them kill each other at night (wouldn't that be nice).

I was just trying to figure out how good each sides chances are right now. If we continue the way we have been today, we're probably going to find ourselves lynching someone we really don't want to.

Personally, I'm starting to think one of the better choices at the moment might be bigbenwd, granted he claimed Denethor to be an inspector, but I really have a hard time believing that Denethor could really be trusted. After all, I believe there's a chance he could be the SK as well, but that's just a possibility. And I'm not sure.

[Mr_Gnome_It_All]

I was just trying to figure out how good each sides chances are right now. If we continue the way we have been today, we're probably going to find ourselves lynching someone we really don't want to.

So why not no lynch?

That's what I was trying to figure out!

[Mr_Gnome_It_All]

:walks into a strage looking room with a switch in the middle of the floor:

"Hey what does this lever do?" :Pulls the switch:

"Oh, I see, it throws in the final

Vote: Ages

"

:whistles as he walks away, pretending he didn't do it:

[Mr_Gnome_It_All]

OK, so lets figure this out. 2 dead Haradrim, 2 dead Men of Khand, 1 dead Orc, no dead SK.

So, if all groups were groups of three, left must be 1 Haradrim, 1Man of Khand, 2 Orcs, and a Serial Killer. Which would mean 5/9 left are probably evil. Unfortunatly that means the town is at an almost impossible disadvantage right now.

[Mr_Gnome_It_All]

I didn't kill anyone last night, either.

[Mr_Gnome_It_All]

Well, I for one doubt both of them. So far, all the pro-town roles have had actual names, and only the scum have had generalized names (Man of Khand; Man of the Haradrim; Random Orc)

Vote Scalebane

As DS said, if were wrong we can be pretty sure about UT tomorrow

[Mr_Gnome_It_All]

Well, hey! That was a pretty good night! And I have a feeling this day will turn out to be just as good!

More Later!

[Mr_Gnome_It_All]

Well, Phoebus. I do have some groundbreaking news and I just didn't have time last night to type it all out. AND, you're also correct about DS!

I am Angbor, Lord of Lamedon, and my only ability is that I can recognize just the leaders of the evil groups, if I can find them! Last night my selection was DS and he came back as one of them.

Vote: Dragon Slayer

[Mr_Gnome_It_All]

I don't know, Let's see!

The evil dead:
Fishbulb - Man of the Haradrim - Killed night 1
Zoneace - Man of the Haradrim - Lynched Day 1
Scalebane - Man of Harad - Lynched day 5
Modargo - Man of Khand - Killed Night 2
Tigris - Man of Khand - Killed ngiht 4
Thoth - Random Orc - Lynched Day 3
Coolbot - Orc - Killed night 5

Well, I guess it would depend on how big the evil groups are... If they were all groups of three, there's still two more to find (a man of Khand, and an orc) And I don't even want to think about the possibility of an SK right now!

[Mr_Gnome_It_All]

Well, judging from the way the roles are listed on the first page, I'm

guessing

that DS is the leader from Khand. Since Scalebale (the leader of the Harad) was listed in a different way from his lackeys ("Man of Harad" instead of "Man of the Haradrim"), which could mean that Coolbot was the leader of the orcs (and not just a "random orc" like Thoth)

This is what I think.

[Mr_Gnome_It_All]

Grr... Congrats Leonidas!

I have a question for everyone. What did you think of my claim of Angbor, Lord of Lamedon? I thought that was good. (maybe a little too good, since it got me killed)

Good Game All!

[Mr_Gnome_It_All]

Yeah, and we wasted three nights trying to kill you! I figured you had to go!