Open 269: Multirole Mafia: Over. Town Win

[implosion]

/confirm.

are all the listed abilities in the game

This I'd like to know.

Can any of the abilities be scum or town

From what I understand, yes.

[implosion]

I've played with... almost half of the list. Never played with andrew, but I have heard things about him (see Consigliere's voting of him in open 260, a game where he wasn't a player).

[implosion]

VOTE: gandalf for clearly being active elsewhere yet failing to confirm here.

[implosion]

We could also revengelynch gandalf.
Decisions, decisions.

A false dichotomy already?

Unvote, vote: chesskid

[implosion]

Well chesskid is scum and Chaotic Neutrality is town, that much is figured out...

In other news, gandalf appears to have forgotten about this game, as he's posting frequently elsewhere.

Mod, could you give him a reminder?

[implosion]

vote: implosion

I feel you have been tunneling gandalf and keep bringing up the fact that he is posting elsewhere to throw mud on his name. It is christmas and he may only have enough time for the games he is currently playing in.

We're in a survivor game in mish mash, and gandalf was chosen by his tribe as "most active." He was posting in a mish mash thread once every hour.

So i'm trying to figure out if implosion is being aggressive to get reactions, or actually believes what he's saying.
Thoughts?

Why must it be only one of those?

[implosion]

Chevre voting Chesskid for making a pressure vote that doesn't pressure is weak...

especially

when there was already a wagon on chesskid. Just because he did something that doesn't achieve the purpose of pressuring, doesn't make him scum. Also, others have brought up how the vote still pressures the target (albeit not as much).

Unvote, vote: Chevre

.

Go go competing wagons!

[implosion]

Hm. This bandwagon is quite explosive. At any rate, chesskid needs to get in here and defend himself.

[This is not a hammer threat]

[implosion]

Sorry for low activity. I'd like to see SA post a bit more, and I'll look more at day one later.

[implosion]

Sorry, school is starting back up and I have a lot less free time. I'll make a post analyzing d1/what we have of d2 probably on Sunday, possibly Saturday night.

[implosion]

SA's analysis is interesting. I agree with most of it - I disagree with:

Vote: ThAdmiral

His avatar actually intimidates me. That's a first.

Town points to thad. This doesn't look like a post you'd make to your scumbuddy.

It's an RVS vote, so I don't really see how it gives townpoints since it could easily be distancing.

Also, I disagree that the scumteam could be chkflip/Smash/drmy, considering that we already have one dead scum.

Chkflip is being entirely too defensive of Andrew.

chesskid is being entirely too aggressive on Andrew.

The Bus Driver Organization looks the scummiest thus far.

'Chevre' looks entirely too much like 'chévere' which means 'great' or 'fantastic' in Spanish.

This post makes me think that one out of Chk/Chevre is scum, because this just seems like the kind of post where he'd mention

at least

one scumbuddy. Just psychologically, I doubt a scum member would feel comfortable just mentioning 3 town in a post like this. I'd also think it's likely that one of the two is town, because again psychologically it'd seem more likely not to mention both scumbuddies.

The other time when Chaotic mentions Chkflip has already been explained by SA and Akira, and I agree with that as well. So Chkflip today, Chevre if he flips town makes the most sense.

Not sure about Akira right now.

[implosion]

Whoops, forgot to VOTE: Chkflip

[implosion]

Eh, IMO Chevre having the hammer isn't ideal, but it isn't the end of the world.

[implosion]

Y'know, there's an easy remedy to that.

Chevre

, what do you think about the two leading bandwagons? If you were to vote one of them right now, which would you vote?

[implosion]

Do you have anything interesting to tell us akira?

Is this asking for a claim? If so, why so indirect? Also, shouldn't Akira wait for L-1 with a willing hammerer?

[implosion]

chkflip is likely town based on Chevre's flip. Shotty is probably town, as ThAd said. I am town. This leaves: andrew, ThAd, SA as most likely scum.

We most likely have 2 lynches and a vig shot left to find one scum, so we're in good shape.

[implosion]

Probably one of them. Not sure which.

[implosion]

Mod, assuming n=2, are roles paired randomly or in order (in order meaning investigation with protection, killing with roleblocking, tracking with being neighbor, and just neighbor)?

Pretty sure I answered this D1, but the role list was randomised prior to assignment.

[implosion]

Problem is, mafia may have investigation immunity.

[implosion]

If I'm the inspector, I have no living guilty report.

I highly doubt that there's an efficient breaking strategy. If it relies on investigations, there's always the possibility of investigation immunity. If it relies on killing, there's always the possibility of a bulletproof mafia (or a roleblocker who successfully roleblocks, and there would be no way to tell which). Best strategy IMO is to lynch, shoot, lynch. We will probably get 3 chances to kill the final scum.

[implosion]

Yeah. The inspector... why are we calling it that btw, it's either an alignment cop or a role cop, so cop, can claim. it isn't me.

[implosion]

It still has the word cop.

[implosion]

rolecop still has the word cop in it.

[/offtopic]

[implosion]

I am either not the cop or I do not have any guilty results.

Which one?

[implosion]

i do not have an inspector ability

next

It should be obvious by now but it's not me.

it isn't me

Yeah. The inspector... why are we calling it that btw, it's either an alignment cop or a role cop, so cop, can claim. it isn't me.

[implosion]

Those aren't as recent.

[implosion]

Why would we out the doc?

[implosion]

I'd be okay with lynching shotty or andrew today. Tomorrow we will most likely be massclaiming.

[implosion]

VOTE: drmyshottyizsik

[implosion]

First off implosion why would you be ok with my lynch? And why didn't you vote for me then? Why did you wait for mothrax to feed off of your lack of reason to vote for me?

I don't see chk as likely mafia and Thad is the cop's inno, and we're sure as hell not lynching the cop, which leaves you and andrew. IDK why I didn't vote one of you in that same post, I probably just forgot to.

[implosion]

scum may have investigation immunity.

[implosion]

I will be

V/LA Thursday-Sunday

for a debate trip.

Noted

[implosion]

someone vig morthax.

Why do you want the cop dead so badly? They could be mafia, but they're still a power role, and if he's town this would be a huge waste. And why shouldn't he RB anyone? He could stop the scumkill if he's real.

[implosion]

Since I'm going to be V/LA and it's almost deadline, I'll just claim. VT.

It's gonna be kind of sad if we mislynch three times and the vig gets all three scum.

[implosion]

Woo. I played

terribly

on that last day I was alive, lol.