I'd like to nominate Empking for Best setup or best role (whatever seems to fit this the best) for his setup in mini 1097: simple mafia, or the role of the mafia don
This role allowed him to have a near vanilla nine player game, which balanced itself. With that I mean that if the town was doing well, they would have it a little bit more difficult then normal, and if they had trouble they would get it a bit easier. This, without actually making it the best play to mislynch (as they would still be better off if they tried to lynch succesfully). The game was perfectly balanced, and this all makes it a extra-ordinary mafia setup. The role that made it all possible, the mafia don which had a weak heart, was a brilliant idea.