anyway,
because it's been a while since we played a game together
AntB, I'm pretty sure it's just how people read the sentence. I don't see how that warrants a vote.AntB wrote:Very poorly... seems like a complete cover-up.brokenscraps wrote:I never said CN confirmed 2nd, just that he is the confirmed 2nd scum, I may have phrased that poorly.
UNVOTE: JesseSheffield
VOTE: brokenscraps
Nachomamma8 wrote:RE: ROLEFISHING:
I have played with AntB before. He's not a complete failure of a player, and he is smart enough to read through the game, which means that he would read the votecount before he would read my "Ant is at L-1" post. If he was a PR, I'm doubly sure he would question the fact and read the votecount. As town, he wouldn't claim ANYTHING after that post. And thanks to AntB being a little prone to OMGUS at times, I'm pretty sure he would've called me scum based off it.
These two seem a bit contradictory to me. If you say you can only conclude he's not a terrible player, how can you conclude how he will react to being at L-1?Nachomamma8 wrote:The only things I used to conclude from your meta is that you're not a fucking terrible player, and that you're prone to OMGUS. Since you just confirmed the second and I'm hoping that you don't think you're a fucking terrible player, I'm pretty sure both of those conclusions are true.
I wanted to reexamine the wagons, and look at each, to see which one I found more scummy. shotty popped out to me because he seemed to be playing a bit differently than usual, and added slMagnvox because I could not remember him at all.farside22 wrote: @sotSpost98 why are you only looking at those that either are not posting or are typical flakers (from what I read from others)
At the time, I was in the mentality that one of nacho or antb was scummy, and I would reread to find out which. I had seen the points about them and at the time they made sense, but I hadn't had all that much time to put into the game. So I said I would reread them. I didn't vote either because I wasn't sure which one was scummier, and i didn't think the two of them were scum together. so i dropped down to my next read, shotty.lord_hur wrote:1. How do you explain that drmyshottyizsik is NEAR the top of your list, while the other two names that you talk about have suddenly become "townish"? Who is at the top of your list, and why didn't you vote for him/her?smashbro_of_the_SSS wrote:vote: shotty, and when i come on in the next couple days, I'll probably move to either nacho or antB. Still, shotty is near the top of my list.
2. Why did you announce that you will switch your vote to someone you find townish?
Make that answer really good...
lord_hur wrote:1. This can be viewed as fencesitting as its best. And you did NOT say you would reread the thread back then, just that you would throw your vote around, as if reasons were not at the center of your thoughts at the moment, but you were rather just annoyed because you didn't know which lynch will be most promising and still wanted to appear as scum-hunting.smashbro_of_the_SSS wrote:At the time, I was in the mentality that one of nacho or antb was scummy, and I would reread to find out which. I had seen the points about them and at the time they made sense, but I hadn't had all that much time to put into the game. So I said I would reread them. I didn't vote either because I wasn't sure which one was scummier, and i didn't think the two of them were scum together. so i dropped down to my next read, shotty.
2. In my mind, you are also guilty of weak voting : you freely say that both were scummier at the time, yet you did not vote for any of them? You don't know which one is scummier of the two, so you vote for a THIRD, less scummy one? What kind of reasoning is that, seriously?
which isn't outright saying i'm going to read, but said I'll have to. anyway, i meant to say i would read though.smashbro_of_the_SSS wrote: In the meantime, I'm not sure between Nacho and antB, I'll have to read through again. It seems pretty weird that Nacho called for a claim, because it really did seem to be rolefishing.
I'm surprised that this didn't come up earlier. I had just forgotten that it was the day of the deadline and didn't have much time online, so I didn't look at the thread at all. The only thing I can say in my defense is that if i were scum, I would be paying more attention to the thread, and would have kept checking and jumped to vote Batt right after the counterclaim. BUt pretty much I screwed up.lord_hur wrote:Explain this.Nachomamma8 wrote:Smash I just saw you down there where's your Batt vote?
Vote : smashbro_of_the_SSS
smashbro_of_the_SSS last week wrote:I have a midterm coming up next week, so I don't have much time on this weekend. After Tuesday I can put more time in, but I need to do a reread before I vote anyone.
I just thought I had posted. I know I had time to at least look at games, and I knew I didn't look at this one. Thought I had posted somewhere else, but I guess not.lord_hur wrote:I call bullshit on this! You did not correct me when I said you were playing another game, and I know you were not, since you did not post anything at all at the time Nachomamma8 caught you!smashbro_of_the_SSS wrote:2) I just forgot that it was deadline that day, and so didn't look at it.
No, I don't think posting now will "solidify me as scum". Not really sure why it would. I'm going to keep posting, possibly more than before to prove I'm innocent. See my first quote above for why I haven't been online.Looker wrote:
- sotS, putting aside that you claim you forgot the deadline and didn't post because you didn't want to look scummy or be questioned, do you believe that posting now will solidify you as scum? If this is why you're not posting, it shouldn't be, because posting will only help your case. I for one do not think you are scum and would like to hear your justification for your actions.
this is the only thing Batt has to say about antb, and im pretty sure someone had to ask him. on the other side of things, ant doesn't mention Batt pretty much anywhere, aside from replying about the town neighbors thing.Battousai wrote:Concerning AntB- My only experience with him was the last game I played, he was lynched D1. The reason being seemed to be that he was more strict with his vote which appeared like fence sitting. (looking back, I find it humourous that he called the town/town neighbors the scum team before he was lynched ) This game he seems to vote more freely. I will have to read some more games on him before I would be tempted to vote him.