Lost: Season Three (We Have to Go Back!)

[Primate]

Confirm.

[Primate]

I claim this island in name of the Queen and the British East India company.

vote CES

Filthy dutch.

[Primate]

Oh man faraday when you said you were easy to read
I had no idea you mean this easy

You're good people, chesskid.

[Primate]

Sorry, but im not going to guess anyone alignment or base a vote/lynch based on previous games actions.

^ scum maybe

Unvote Vote Chesskid

Why? because I want to base the reasons of my vote from *gasp* this game and not past games

I think you're a meta level off there.

[Primate]

Vote Faraday

I can go with that.

[Primate]

Drew as in past tense version of draw, as you have drawn a scum role.

[Primate]

Why Jason?

[Primate]

What don't you like about Jason?

[Primate]

But you can wagon Faraday with me!

Elaborate, dramonic.

when I die I flip like a goon would. What else do you want me to elaborate on?

Name?
Flavour?

What is your opinion of policy lynches on claimed millers?

[Primate]

I could have sworn there was a gimmick in S3 where kate + sawyer thought Jack had betrayed them for the cushy life with the others, mostly because that was what Ben was trying to get them to think.

Anyway. Mod admitted flavour means shit in this game in his second post, so it's not worth putting too much stock in that.

Not ecstatic about "dont feel like checking my pm". Kind of stuff I do as scum when I want wiggle room.

Because I'm going to treat him as a very townie townie right up until the point where he has to die, and it helps scumhunting to have a near-clear alive.

Why? This seems a bit kneejerk.

[Primate]

Personally never claimed fakeclaimed miller as scum. I've seen others do it in games I've played though.

Honestly, if it was miller, I'd probably agree (though I really don't know the meta anymore). Death miller doesn't feel the same though, imho, primarily because it's such an uncommon role in addition to how convinient it is.

Disagree though, I think I'd be more likely to do it as town, but it's more-so just bad play than scummy.

There's absolutely no downside to spending seconds checking your pm so you don't have make a statement saying you are unsure of your own claim in your post, especially when someone specifically asked you a question about that thing. I can completely see how town could do it, but it's unnecessarily sloppy at a point when CES asked for clarification on something specifically. I'd also hope that someone who honestly got a Death miller role wouldn't be laissez-faire about it, but hey, I'm not playing the role.

[Primate]

JasonT's claim is JasonT's claim, not productive talking about it.

Having trouble reading people. Jedo set of my scumdar, needs to see whether there's anything in that. I can see why SSS recieved stick after post #179, and my reaction was similar to chesskids in the sense I thought it was bit of an odd step. I don't know about Faraday, Bella, CEM, others. Liking what I'm seeing from Chesskid, Fate and vezok.

Hopefully I'll be a bit more on the ball tomorrow.

[Primate]

Jedo is making sense. His AGar case was pretty legitimate. There were a couple of points I thought weak but sensible, and it was OK overall. I'm relatively comfortable with him. Didn't like SSS's last post much. Now I've got a few more posts of Mockinjaye, I like him more. Like Faraday less. Still not enough to read from Bella. I think Agar is playing badly this game, but that's not a read and I don't have one there yet.

Primate I'm worried about and I would call scummy, and I'd like to see him get in here and do some more posting too.

I slack a bit midweek due to a couple of regular pub quizes. I'm also rarely active enough to make multiple posts a day during the week anyway (weekends I pick up).

[Primate]

hahahaha

[Primate]

Yep.

VOTE: bella

Funny thing is I was actually going to defend you until you started talking about having info on Agar.

[Primate]

I don't think jailkeeper's an unsalvagable claim, ces. I also thought she was rolling with the people attacking her too much. I am terrible at this game, though.

[Primate]

I think it's pretty surreal and surprising, but hey, not complaining about free scum.

The role itself has to be mod error (or, more likely, fictional) otherwise it's retarded, yeah.

[Primate]

That's 4 so I think we could probably do with a claim just to see whether he has anything obviously provably town or groundbreaking to say.

I'm a little dubious about Izzy rolling on an Agar scumbuddy, but I suppose if it is an fuckup on the part of the mod it would at least explain her laissez faire attitude towards being lynched.

Also lollin at Charlie being a martyr and Faraday needing him alive to win.

[Primate]

Boring like a fox.

[Primate]

I was mostly trying to hold off on it just in case he comes up something like investigative town and we look like idiots because we didn't get his results before he died. Anyway.

[Primate]

PRIMATE WHY DID YOU COST ME MY WIN ;_:

I suuuuuucked this game.

[Primate]

/Pre-in s4