Scummies 2011 Nominations

[populartajo]

Magna's play wasn't good enough because he lost. His play was poor because you want him to give him Best Performance in a Losing Cause (and re-introduce the award for him) rather than giving him a good scum award.

If his early play was better than you wouldn't be nominating him for Losing Cause. Therefore he's getting nominated for the award based on his early play being poor. Theregore its an award for poor play.

Any player can play an absolutely brilliant game but still lose. And any player can play a craptastic game and win. Chesskid in Liten is an example of the later. To use an analogy Micheal Jordan played for subpar Chicago Bulls teams for several years until he got a good supporting cast (and I am not comparing myself to him … this is just an example). Because his teams didn’t win in the play-offs does not mean he played poorly.

If your objection is the reintroduction of the award that is one argument. But trying to say that in a team game by eventually losing it means you must have played poorly is just stupid.

oh i want that award so badddddd

[populartajo]

Empking, you're conflating "good play" with "good enough play to win". Not the same thing.

Kerrigan, you're arguing with Empking. That was your first mistake.

fcking contradictions! how do they work?

[populartajo]

EMPKING YOU WERE BETTER WITH THE LURKING AND ALL

[populartajo]

itt noobs nominating noobs

[populartajo]

Nominate Faraday for Most Improved Player.

I remember him being as really easy to catch as scum in my first games with him.

His last play on Court of Gods showed healthy improvement. His reads were reallly really accurate and his play was remarkably good, while also being entertaining to play with.

[populartajo]

Also third Ruffig for that game where he fooled a strong town.

And finally Mishmash for RC's EPYC.

[populartajo]

I think he meant QUADZ to be specific.

Stop wasting our time.

[populartajo]

Listening is not the same as reading.

Pay attention noob.

[populartajo]

"I'll consider reading your posts."

Done.

[populartajo]

-Up against a competent playerlist

[/b]

Tour Guide

, [/color]

NPC Tour Guide

,

Torn to Shreds and Shot Night 0/Pre-Game!

8. SnakePlissken

,

Vanilla Townie

,

Put to Death Day 1!

1. Nero Cain

,

Town Seer

,

Shot in the Chest Night 1!

14. Nobody Special

,

Town Voyeur

,

Choked to Death Night 1!

21. Thor665 (who replaced Seraphim)

,

Town Jailkeeper

,

Slashed Across the Face and Eaten Night 1!

22. RaudhrGarm (who replaced [Moonstruck])

,

Bulletproof Serial Killer

,

Put to Death Day 2!

9. quadz08 (who replaced Lucresia)

,

Vanilla Townie

,

Shot in the Chest Night 2!

6. Eldritch Lord (who replaced MaxKojote)

,

Town Neighbor

,

Slashed Across the Face and Eaten Night 2!

13. Pine

,

Vanilla Townie

,

Put to Death Day 3!

16. Kise

,

Vanilla Townie

,

Shot in the Chest Night 3!

12. Nachomamma8

,

East Side Mafia Goon

,

Slashed Across the Face and Eaten Night 3!

11. T-Bone

,

East Side Mafia Tracker

,

Put to Death Day 4!

19. C-Worl

,

Vanilla Townie

,

Throat Bitten Open Night 4!

18. implosion

,

Vanilla Townie

,

Shot in the Face Night 4!

4. Charlie (who replaced kr0b)

,

Vanilla Townie

,

Shot in the Face Night 5!

5. mastin2 (who replaced Lowell)

,

East Side Mafia Doctor

,

Put to Death Day 6!

23. Slaxx (who replaced tclawren)

,

Town Neighbor

,

Slashed Across the Face and Eaten Night 6!

20. MrZepher

,

Vanilla Townie

,

Slashed Across the Face and Eaten Night 7!

2. ConSpiracy

,

Vanilla Townie

,

Put to Death Day 8!

17. singersigner (who replaced Shift)

,

1-shot Friendly Neighbor

,

Endgamed Day 8!

7. dramonic (who replaced Reckamonic, the person who replaced RayFrost)

,

Vengeful Townie

,

Endgamed Day 8!

lolno

[populartajo]

nth amrun

[populartajo]

Almost certainly not an alt for reasons I won't go in to, but yeah.

said the alt

[populartajo]

I suggest not accepting nominee suggestions from a cheater.