There Will Be Bloodshed (Game Over)

[IceyCupcake]

I believe that's L-2. I'm personally okay with an Anti hammer without anything else from him, especially as it seems unlikely he would even post again within a few days, but I also wouldn't mind a defense or a scumlist to use for information purposes from him. Up to the non-voters, I won't be taking our vote off Anti til he's hanged in all likelihood.

~Fugi

Information purposes:

Name: Antihero
Claim:
Scum: All y'all
Not scum: My buds, y'all

No hammers yet, leave at L-2

We need claims from the remaining three people, then some serious analysis on anti buddies.

[TwoHeadedBoy]

I'm okay with an Antihammer (insert joke here) as well, but we also have a massclaim to finish. And a week and two days till deadline.

~Pie

PEdit: ninja'd

[TwoHeadedBoy]

I like to WIFOM scum lists >:| It's not useless no matter what says. He won't just list buddies as town and town as scum.

I'm gonna talk to a few more people too to try to fill the two slots. Hopefully I can find someone. Most seem to really be turned off by 56 pages. :-/

~Fugi

[TwoHeadedBoy]

I've asked a grand total of 24 people if they were interested in replacing in. Let's see if we get someone.

~Pie

[Slaxx]

Thank you Pie. I have gotten no response in the replacements thread.

[silverbullet999]

Icey what are you quoting from in your information post 1375 or is that just you?

Catch-up will commence soon as I think I finally see it

[Hiraki]

Is anyone buying this as something other than scum?

After we kill Anti, I want you dead next. There's no way you're getting away with this.

[Antihero]

Ugh, well that blew up in my face, for some...reason.

Alright, I'll come clean. I'm a cop. I investigated Jerbs, EPM, and TBH and got innos on all of them (wasn't expecting them, though). I investigated TBH because of the less than great looking hammer and Jerbs and EPM because I thought they were scum and I would get a guilty and I could feel good about pushing their lynch the next day.

I lied and claimed hider because a) I wanted to avoid the RB and b) to avoid the NK and c) to protect what looks like the most powerful role here. Guess it's not going to matter now that Grey has completely clung to this lynch (for some odd reason) and everyone is going "herp-derp" and following.

[Pine]

Is anyone buying this as something other than scum?

After we kill Anti, I want you dead next. There's no way you're getting away with this.

I notice you've said practically nothing against me until I read Mastin's case against you, agree with it, and start voting for you. Your sudden and intense Pine-hatred is pure OMGUS and nervous scum speaking.

[diddin]

WE WAIT UNTIL COUNTERCLAIMS. If there is a CC, Anti is scum. Or just an AWFUL cop.

[Empking]

WE WAIT UNTIL COUNTERCLAIMS. If there is a CC, Anti is scum. Or just an AWFUL cop.

If Anti was a Cop I'd have expected him to be on the Pine wagon in order to keep his town results alive. (Plus its still ridiculously convenient.)

[IceyCupcake]

Ugh, well that blew up in my face, for some...reason.

Alright, I'll come clean. I'm a cop. I investigated Jerbs, EPM, and TBH and got innos on all of them (wasn't expecting them, though). I investigated TBH because of the less than great looking hammer and Jerbs and EPM because I thought they were scum and I would get a guilty and I could feel good about pushing their lynch the next day.

I lied and claimed hider because a) I wanted to avoid the RB and b) to avoid the NK and c) to protect what looks like the most powerful role here. Guess it's not going to matter now that Grey has completely clung to this lynch (for some odd reason) and everyone is going "herp-derp" and following.

BACK TO SAME PROBLEM

COULD HAVE WORKED HARD AND FOUND SOME SUSPECTS OR AT LEAST CREDIBLY DEFENDED THEM.

BTW: Jerbs is town.

This is true.

THIS IS THE SUM TOTAL YOU DID TO PREVENT A MISLYNCH ON A COP-INVESTIGATED INNOCENT

YOU DID LESS FOR EPM.

[Antihero]

WE WAIT UNTIL COUNTERCLAIMS. If there is a CC, Anti is scum. Or just an AWFUL cop.

If Anti was a Cop I'd have expected him to be on the Pine wagon in order to keep his town results alive. (Plus its still ridiculously convenient.)

^scum. I didn't think Pine was scum, so I'm wasn't jumping on his wagon. Plus, I was absent right after N2, so I couldn't exactly do much for EPM.

Grey: Yeah, well I haven't played cop before, so to dodge the NK, I censored myself. A lot. And I ended up lurking my ass off because I thought I would have a guilty by now I could bust out of the gate with. Sorry.

[Empking]

WE WAIT UNTIL COUNTERCLAIMS. If there is a CC, Anti is scum. Or just an AWFUL cop.

If Anti was a Cop I'd have expected him to be on the Pine wagon in order to keep his town results alive. (Plus its still ridiculously convenient.)

^scum. I didn't think Pine was scum, so I'm wasn't jumping on his wagon.

But you were OK with Jerb's lynch

[Antihero]

Well, no, but I couldn't make that big of a 180 without screaming "I HAVE EXTRA INFO!"

[Empking]

Well, no, but I couldn't make that big of a 180 without screaming "I HAVE EXTRA INFO!"

Not really.

[diddin]

The desire to doublehammer Anti is tempting the hell out of me right now...

[Hiraki]

2 Cops isn't making much sense to me.

Can we agree at least one of them is probable scum?

[TwoHeadedBoy]

I wanna take a second to break this down.

Ugh, well that blew up in my face, for some...reason.

"Ugh, I got caught"

Alright, I'll come clean. I'm a cop. I investigated Jerbs, EPM, and TBH and got innos on all of them (wasn't expecting them, though). I investigated TBH because of the less than great looking hammer and Jerbs and EPM because I thought they were scum and I would get a guilty and I could feel good about pushing their lynch the next day.

Why would you investigate us of all people? Surely if you're looking for scum you would have investigated Romanus or Empking or someone. The "hammer" reason seems forced and the reasons given for Jerbs and EPM (still both conveniently dead) are just kinda thrown out there without thought. Regardless, thanks for confirming us town.

I lied and claimed hider because a) I wanted to avoid the RB and b) to avoid the NK and c) to protect what looks like the most powerful role here. Guess it's not going to matter now that Grey has completely clung to this lynch (for some odd reason) and everyone is going "herp-derp" and following.

Everyone: Note reason b and reason c are exactly the same. He pretty much just reworded it to try to force out more reasons for a fake claim than there really were. To me, this is the most damning piece of evidence that he's actually scum who changed his claim, there's no reason for town to force fluff out for why they did something.

------------

Anti: No one is "herp-derp"ing with Grey and mindlessly bandwagoning, it's all for the same reason and you know very well what that reason is.

Question time:
1) Why would you need to claim hider if you can know with like 95% certainty that there is a protective role out there? Be it Wraith or someone unclaimed. The only dead members are VTs, so I'm not following this "I need to protect myself" logic at all.

2) Can I have a scum list?

The only way I read this post is "Oh shit I got caught time to try something different."

~Fugi

[Wraith]

Ugh, well that blew up in my face, for some...reason.

Alright, I'll come clean. I'm a cop. I investigated Jerbs, EPM, and TBH and got innos on all of them (wasn't expecting them, though). I investigated TBH because of the less than great looking hammer and Jerbs and EPM because I thought they were scum and I would get a guilty and I could feel good about pushing their lynch the next day.

I lied and claimed hider because a) I wanted to avoid the RB and b) to avoid the NK and c) to protect what looks like the most powerful role here. Guess it's not going to matter now that Grey has completely clung to this lynch (for some odd reason) and everyone is going "herp-derp" and following.

So you sat back and did nothing when Jerbs and EPM got lynched, because you "expected a godfather"? And you didn't investigate any of the claimed PRs either to figure out if they were lying? *clap clap clap*

[Empking]

2 Cops isn't making much sense to me.

Can we agree at least one of them is probable scum?

Who's the second Cop?

[Pine]

He's suggesting that Icey's Neighborizer role is in the 'Cop' genus.

[TwoHeadedBoy]

I'd be willing to bet he's mixing up games (again).

[TwoHeadedBoy]

EBWOP: If a post isn't signed it's likely Fugi, for what it's worth. Pie's freakishly good at remembering, even in quick little posts.

~Fugi

[Hiraki]

I'd be willing to bet he's mixing up games (again).

STUPID GREYICE.

GET OUT OF MY GAMES.

Is anyone buying this as something other than scum?

After we kill Anti, I want you dead next. There's no way you're getting away with this.

I notice you've said practically nothing against me until I read Mastin's case against you, agree with it, and start voting for you. Your sudden and intense Pine-hatred is pure OMGUS and nervous scum speaking.

You're dead.