Cthulhu Speed Mafia (Finished)

[tarsonisocelot]

Just got the message.
That's a lot of N0 deaths, more than I would expect from just scum or scum + SK. Could some of them have targeted a Paranoid Gun Owner?

No reads yet so VOTE: Ant_to_the_max.
Was there any particular reason that you thought posting first was dangerous? If yes, are there any other things we should be wary of?

[tarsonisocelot]

PEdit: POST IN THE DAMN HYDRA

I don't think that that really counts as an argument, seems like more of a facepalm.

[tarsonisocelot]

VOTE: Energetic Penguinscum Nacho logic wins.

Could you explain Nacho-logic to the unenlightened? Or is this just a D1 randomness thing?

[tarsonisocelot]

What is idugd?

Me smashing my keyboard in anger at Penguin's scumminess.

VOTE: Energetic Penguinscum Nacho logic wins.

Could you explain Nacho-logic to the unenlightened? Or is this just a D1 randomness thing?

Stels is town.
I am town.
I peg scum.
Stels helps me lynch them.

Logic ends there. If you want actual reasons, why I suppose it wouldn't hurt to ask...

What are your reasons? How do you know that Stels is town? Why should I believe that you are town?

I assumed that Nacho-logic referred to some kind of logic behind your suspicions not to some voting agreement.

[tarsonisocelot]

@lololololfunnypeople: Wow... Just wow. He caught scum, and a good enough reason. If you can't see it, you are blind. I like how you guys freak out at my first vote.

What an incredibly helpful and enlightening post...

[tarsonisocelot]

Also, love how quickly the wagon on me starts to build itself up..

YOOOUUU KNOOOOOOW

(to elaborate: says the person that blatantly sheeped an RVS wagon to L-1 roughly 14 hours/13 posts after the person they're sheeping voted)

Also yeah, vezok did the same thing. Got my eye on him too.

Anyways, how the fuck did we get another death exactly? Four deaths N0, okay, I can deal with that kinda. But wtf? He just voted C-Worl and went V/LA...

...

WAIT A SECOND

Unvote

until I can talk with Fugi.

Vote: Cobbler

for pseudo-placeholder (and other reasons previously stated)

~Pie

Did you get a vig-shot then? If yes, why target RaudhrGarm?

VOTE: C-Worl reasons others have stated plus calling a scum team on day 1.

[tarsonisocelot]

EBWOP: tars, how the fuck did you think we actually got a vigshot? Did you even read that post?

FoS tars

PEdit: god dammit bob

Apologies, it was more of a "THB asks repeatedly for vigshots+someone falls over dead->did THB get his wish/wtf???" than anything else. I didn't put enough thought into it.
Haven't played with day-killing scum before, but on reflection I don't think there's a town motive for shooting someone as inactive as them at this point when there are other people who look vaguely scummy around.

Sleep is a good thing.

PEdit: The vote count also reset so people would have a chance to realise and not quicklynch.

[tarsonisocelot]

Get over yourself.

I've never even gone to epicmafia. I don't lynch people for "why me" posts, but they certainly usually are indicative of a scum mindset.

Neither C-Worl or myself are mafia.

I'm also not useless (generally), though my play this game has been quite shit, but that's due to the combination of Easter and finals week. I have a life and that's just too bad. Games suffer sometimes. I've contributed more than several other players, so find a real reason or shut up.

Pro tip: making your font bigger and using more colorful language does not actually make your point more compelling.


I will move my vote back to bobsnox, who is still the overall scummiest player. I do need to see more from the players I mentioned before, though.

VOTE: bobsnox

Not disagreeing with you on bob being scummy.

You talk about C-Worl being town as though you know for certain. Is this true? If so do they know that you are town?


I've played with Amrun and Nacho.

[tarsonisocelot]

Okay, I fully realize that my play has been lame this game. I'm still town, though.

In fact, C-Worl, myself, and one other person I won't reveal yet are town masons together.

So your reasons aren't that good.

Sorry for claiming if you didn't want to, guys.

Wow, five masons in two teams, given the flavour probably a cult somewhere (can't have the tentacle dude without the devout supporters) and a scumteam.
UNVOTE:
When scum kills one of you tonight (assuming no doctors save you) then the other will at least be confirmed - assuming this is legit. I'm assuming it is because I can't imagine scum fake-claiming mason team after the deaths of 2 seeking masons on N0.

Thanks for the logic Nacho. I'm fine with a Penguin lynch, pending a claim.
EP: Claim on your next post or I will hammer.

[tarsonisocelot]

given the flavour probably a cult somewhere (can't have the tentacle dude without the devout supporters).

If Empking put a cult in here without telling us, I will rage. His "this may be considered a bastard game" doesn't cut it; it's common courtesy to announce if a setup has a cult.

I didn't know that. I'll rethink with scumteam plus two known mason teams.

[tarsonisocelot]

Erm, I don't think there are two mason teams.
I think "seeking masons" means that they're seeking other masons.

A five person team seems a bit large for this size of game, so I guessed that the two seeking masons unknown to the claimed masons might have been meant only to find each other.

What I liked best about your logic was that it existed and was more than "OBVSCUM FOUND!!!TROLOLOLO". Contentwise, it was the AtE part.

[tarsonisocelot]

Two more stiff bodies litter the floor. Two similasr looking stiff bodies.

bobsnox, Deputy was killed Night One
Ant_To_the_Max, Deputy, was killed Night One

o.O
6 PR deaths deaths in 2 night periods seems too good to be just lucky scum. Somehing's up with roles/game mechanics/both.

Amrun, is mason three still alive?

[tarsonisocelot]

Also a VT. Why couldn't I be bulletproof and psychic?
Asked Amrun because for whatever reason I didn't remember Mason would have shown in 3's flip and they seemed to be possibly still online so might have replied quickly.

Nacho?

[tarsonisocelot]

What?
No.
Nonononono.

Why?
I don't see where Stels has done anything particularly town-ish. Could you point out why you've decided that Stels is town. THB too.

I agree with going for VTs.
I think THB is town, but I'd go for Stels or vezok or Cobbler unless given convincing reasons otherwise.

[tarsonisocelot]

I don't see where Stels has done anything particularly town-ish. Could you point out why you've decided that Stels is town.

Our reason: general (slightly dickish) townie attitude. Plus we skimmed his other games in ISO and he seems to have very distinct metas as town and scum. This matches with his townmeta.

Even aside from meta and gut, he has at LEAST one, if not two, if not THREE people that are scummier than him IMO. We're not lynching him today, at all.

~Pie

Can you link to some games that you consider good examples of Stels' town and scum play? (ones that aren't too confusing please)

Until then VOTE: Cobblerfone , as a fairly suspicious individual that I didn't pay enough attention to yesterday.

[tarsonisocelot]

Can you link to some games that you consider good examples of Stels' town and scum play? (ones that aren't too confusing please)

SSB Maf for a town game, and this one for a scum game. His other games are newbies - check his wiki and search the games yourself if you want more proof.

Just ISO a few posts and look how he talks as each alignment.

Also: VOTE: Cobblerfone

~Pie

I've looked at the ISOs and still don't see Stels as townie.

You seem quite certain though. Is that just for meta reasons?

"Nacho logic found scum!" = RVS?
UNVOTE: VOTE: Stels

[tarsonisocelot]

Also, sorry for hogging all the day kills, guys. The first kill was situational. I didn't want to go a day without a kill. And I thought he hadn't really posted; I didn't want to give myself away.

I wasn't lying about the "Stels looks more like he's acting in his scum way" by the way. If I were town and shown those ISOs I'd still probably vote Stels.

Not a problem.

First game as mafia.
Second game that ended up wildly imbalanced.
'Twas fun but.