Scummies 2011 Nominations

TheButtonmen · Post Post #318 (isolation #0) » Sat Apr 23, 2011 2:45 pm

Nicodemus wrote:
VP Baltar wrote:
Nominate Feysal for Most Outstanding New Player

I had the most experience with him in Percy's Stars Aligned III. He's a very strong strategist and a thorough thinker when it comes to the game of mafia. Whereas most new players would have been easily overwhelmed in that setup, Feysal stepped forward and was one of the leaders of the scum team. I have also seen him a couple of times as town and I found him to be equally thoughtful.

Second

3^rd.

TheButtonmen · Post Post #930 (isolation #1) » Fri Aug 19, 2011 8:03 pm

Self-noming is wrong.

Counter Nth

, I'm very much opposed to her winning this scummy for this nomination now.

Any 'noming of her for this scummy for this entire nominiation period is now tainted by this, all around bad form from those involved.

TheButtonmen · Post Post #965 (isolation #2) » Sat Aug 20, 2011 6:31 pm

Robocopter87 wrote:
But Thor, being the sportsman he is, pulled out every card he could think of and played it against the Town. The Town almost decided to kill the Jailkeeper. Unfortunately, he did lose. But that does not mean he did not do any excellent job.

Not only did he play excellent, the entire time he was writing down the reasons for his actions in the Mafia QT so the Newbies post game could learn from his play.

Here's the QT in question, it's extremely well written out step by step guide for his actions in a very newbie friendly manner.