Cthulhu Speed Mafia (Finished)

[Ant_to_the_max]

I KNOW!

I was scared about posting first because I thought I might die if I did so >_>

So do we skip the RVS in this game and just start arguing right away?

[Ant_to_the_max]

Usually if someone says something controversial in their first post like "i'm scum. Discuss." We can get started right away

*waits for someone to say something controversial*

In the meantime, VOTE: Twistedspoon. It needed to be done.

[Ant_to_the_max]

Overreaction to the deaths and prematurely trying to pass off any scummy play as his playstyle. Nope, not gonna fly.

Yeah, I have to agree that this argument is pretty weak. It is not like he went "OH MAW GAWD!! NOT TEH COPZ!!!11!1!!1!" or started talking about possible setup speculation.

[Ant_to_the_max]

I would say null

I don't think everyone knows the game started =/

@Mod: Hey, can you send a PM to everyone letting them know the day started? Thanks.

[Ant_to_the_max]

Bad argument is bad argument.
But basically what I said would be bad is what TS said and you pointed out.

@C-Worl: how many games have you played with THB?

[Ant_to_the_max]

Nah.
Part about posting first was more of a joke. Heads were really rolling with 4 deaths and like Empking said, we are most certainly doomed at this rate

More stuff when I get home

[Ant_to_the_max]

Bad argument is bad argument.
But basically what I said would be bad is what TS said and you pointed out.

Erm. What?

~Pie

Sorry. First part was reasoning for defending Bob. I claim that what he said didn't fit what you were accusing him of.
I then wanted to point out what TS said fit more for your accusation.

As for Nacho, could your pwetty pwease explain your logic? I think I see what you are thinking. Just want you to confirm it for yourself.

And dang it...forgot to mention it earlier, but just refer to me as Ant

[Ant_to_the_max]

@C-Worl: how many games have you played with THB?

Still waiting for Nacho as well

[Ant_to_the_max]

?

VOTE: C-Worl

Let's try this again. Penguin wagon can get itself back up to L-1 by itself. Still waiting for Nacho before sheeping.

[Ant_to_the_max]

After we lynch him THB and Ant are his scum buddies.

Nope. Not going to be that easy. And I am not allowed to sheep?

Texted Fugi. We both think the daykill looks most like a scum-daykill-WIFOM-frame against C-Worl. No one that's town would shoot that early, let alone someone who's made two posts. And I'm assuming daykill unless we find out there's some unorthodox role or odd mechanic that caused this.
~Pie

How would that be framing C-Worl? Besides the vote he had on C-Worl, there was no other interaction.
As for the death, my first thought was Rule 19...but w/e

[Ant_to_the_max]

Vote Count 4

2. vezokpiraka
3. bobsnox (1) - Amrun
4. Ant_to_the_max (1) - tarsonisocelot
5. RaudhrGarm
6. Nachomamma8
7. Twistedspoon (2) - Ant_to_the_max, Energetic Penguin,
9. Cobblerfone
10. C-Worl (2) - RaudhrGarm, TwoHeadedBoy
12. TwoHeadedBoy (1) - Cobblerfone
13. tarsonisocelot
14. Stels
15. Amrun
16. Energetic Penguin (6) - Twistedspoon, bobsnox, Nachomamma8, Stels, vezokpiraka, C-Worl

Not Voting:

13 Alive, 7 to Lynch

Someone with 2 votes on them (one being a guy that is V/LA) compared to a guy at L-1
If anything, I see it more of a revealer of Energetic Penguin lynch than a C-Worl lynch

BUT!!!! WITH 12 ALIVE, YOU ONLY NEED 6 TO LYNCH! AKA 6 PEOPLE ON PENGUIN, SCUM TAKE A DAY SHOT TO CHANGE THE REQUIREMENTS FOR A LYNCH AND THEY GET A QUICK MISS-LYNCH D1 ON PAGE 5

IMO proof that Penguin is town.

[Ant_to_the_max]

Hmm, not specifically stated in the rules.

@Mod: How many does it take to lynch now?

But like I said, possible derailer, but I just had my lightbulb and I got all excited >__>

[Ant_to_the_max]

Catching up now just want to say this first though:

Alright, I read a couple pages into a game where Vezok was a cop, and he looks way less sheepish and way more active in it, even on the first (and only) day that he plays.

You wouldn't be happening to be looking at Execution Mafia are you? Bad move on his part in that game but meh

[Ant_to_the_max]

Not to offend you, but right now, you're making a fool of yourself. How in the world did you get 6 to lynch? It's 7. the requirement for the lynch hasn't changed. It needs to be 1/2 + 1. Invalid argument.

Yes...so? I do that often.

You are starting to look bad yourself though.
I suggest everyone just take a quick look at Stels' ISO and tell me if he really has added anything to this game at all.
FoS: Stels

Yes, that actually was the game.

For everyone else: That was a game with me/spoon/amrun. Vez was the cop and pulled the "no! let me live one night!" deal. We were going to let him live....but then scumspoon/amrun killed him >_>

About that game though...I will admit, I think Spoon did the same scum tell of "oh noez! our cop is dead!" in Execution Mafia as well. Similar to his first post here...

Isn't Vez kinda compared to dmzshotty(whatever)?

Anyways, moving on. I get a town feeling from Cob. Unfortunately his newbie game is ongoing and he has yet to die, so there is no info there but I really get a trying town feeling from his posts.

Amrun = busy? Nothing to say here.

Nacho nacho nacho... Last post on the 22nd. In his newbie game he is modding he claimed he would be V/LA for a day or so. He has posted on the 23rd and today. Anyone know if he is normally busy on the weekends?

C-Worl- Also feeling townish/not a good D1 lynch
UNVOTE:
I followed the Date Show mafia and didn't like him, but still getting the same vibes from him now. >_>

VOTE: Stels

Still want Nacho to come in before I move to penguin. But right now I think Stels is a far better lynch.

[Ant_to_the_max]

But why policy lynch when we actually have another viable option?

[Ant_to_the_max]

As stated, Amrun/Spoon/Vez in one game.
I have stalked C-Worl and Nacho in others

[Ant_to_the_max]

Amrun, if F***ing love you

Amrun/C-Worl/<one more person>
Are 99.99% town. Only 0.01% chance that they are all three pulling of a fake mason claim gambit, which honestly, would that really happen? (But if it did, that would be pretty cool >_>)

Preview Edit: BRB WITH MORE STUFF

[Ant_to_the_max]

^you need to think harder(TwoHeadedBoy)


I am down for a Energetic Penguin/tarsonisocelot/bobsnox lynch today
VOTE: Energetic Penguin

multiple preview edits later: DANG IT, I WANNA POST!

FYI HE IS AT L-2....or should be >_>

[Ant_to_the_max]

BRB going to watch My Little Pony

[Ant_to_the_max]

I get excited easily

*shrugs*
just makes my job easier

[Ant_to_the_max]

Don't do anything stupid and let him post.
Although, if he doesn't post tonight, we need a hammer tomorrow morning. Tomorrow is deadline.

[Ant_to_the_max]

*shrugs*

[Ant_to_the_max]

?
>__>

[Ant_to_the_max]

DANG IT!
I get a cool PR only to find out I die once I use my power >___>
Yeah, I think that one more player would have made a big difference in this game. Was fun though.

Also, who's idea was it to have the masons all vote for Empking? Very clever.

[Ant_to_the_max]

After Spoon claimed Supersaint, he should have automatically been the lynch for the day >_>

Wouldn't it always be in the towns best interest to policy lynch one of them once they claim? If you force someone scummy to hammer, you not only check the claim, but you get rid of the scummy player as well.

Depending on my result from THB idk how D2 would have gone if I was still alive

[Ant_to_the_max]

Reviewers: Snow Bunny, Faraday and CMAR

[Ant_to_the_max]

But really though...
What is the policy on how to deal with them?

[Ant_to_the_max]

If TS ever claims anything, he gets lynched immediately >_>

And yes, Supersaints.

[Ant_to_the_max]

We didn't get his results because he was never given any results. What this game boiled down to was
Kill scum on D1 and you have 2 deputies and 3 masons
Or
Don't kill scum on D1 and you have 3 masons with 2* more misslynches

[Ant_to_the_max]

True. I forgot about that point.