Dr Who - Game over

[bv310]

Bandwagon to victory!

vote: Zang

[bv310]

Oooooh, Counter-wagons are fun.

[bv310]

In other news, where the hell is bv310?

Short answer: Working stupid hours. Had 16 hours of work in 24 yesterday.

Caught up now, and this is the biggest offender atm.

PPE:

Interesting little exchange between Nexus and Hoppster. The FoS on pappums was odd to me, as I don't see not jumping on a wagon or counter wagon page 1 as scummy. I didn't explain this because I wanted to see how he reacted to a page 1 vote against him.

Since when is this townposting?

MFoS: Surye

I wish I could respond, but I don't see the problem that you obviously do :/

unvote, vote: Surye

You really don't see the problem here?

Honourable mention of Scumminess goes to Snake, for completely ignoring the building cases and instead trying to reboot RVS.

Oooooh, Counter-wagons are fun.

Then why didn’t you try to start one as opposed to mindlessly wagoning along?

Because when I voted, there were only 2/3 votes on the primary wagon. It's not an effective counter until you're providing a clear alternative to the main.

^ Because I'm RVS'ing GMan, and will continue to do so until I am ready to leave RVS.

This bothers me. I don't like people who refuse to leave RVS when actual things have happened in the game.


Incidentally, to respond to Snake's 3rd Q: The Weeping Angels. Blink was one of my favourite episodes.

[bv310]

So your reason for voting MoI is that he's acting like a 5-man wagon may contain scum on it (not a big stretch imo)? And if it does, you think he's the most likely out of the five?


Also, sidebar, mid-season finales are annoying. My River theory was half-right though.

[bv310]

If you actually read the posts you'll see I'm not being aggressive at all.

Read the thread before you comment, Snake.

And then vote Surye.

This.

Anyway, Tar, what's up with the fake DK?

[bv310]

Because, in my experience, a fake-DK gambit is much more common than an actual daykill and a Bulletproof.

[bv310]

Because, in my experience, a fake-DK gambit is much more common than an actual daykill and a Bulletproof.

Hmm, fake-daykill must have become more common recently. Darn.

It may not be more common, I just play with Fate a lot.

[bv310]

/prodded. Sorry I'm away a bit, trying to get ready for a trip tomorrow, so i've been dealing with the myriad issues involved.

[bv310]

Also, bv310 - I see you posting over in GD. Why aren't you posting here?

Because that post is me procrastinating from studying for my Roman History midterm. I will get to this game and all my commitments tomorrow afternoon.

[bv310]

Sorry, surprise funeral today. I'll have time for this game tomorrow.

[bv310]

Okay, I caught up with what I missed. I'm willing to say that Nexus is likely Town, but his reactions at his wagon so far have been extremely scummy. Looking at his iso, he goes from trying to start a counterwagon, to weakly defending a case, to flat-out aggression, to flailing. I'll be willing to vote him once it gets a bit closer to deadline, since I feel like there's a bit more conversation that we can extract first.

[bv310]

Okay, I caught up with what I missed. I'm willing to say that Nexus is likely

Town, but

his reactions at his wagon so far have been extremely scummy. Looking at his iso, he goes from trying to start a counterwagon, to weakly defending a case, to flat-out aggression, to flailing. I'll be willing to vote him once it gets a bit closer to deadline, since I feel like there's a bit more conversation that we can extract first.

So which is it, do you think he is town or scum? I hope that fence post isn't hurting your ass too much

Ugh. Bolded should say "Scum, since". I changed my mind part way through writing that post. This week has apparently consumed my last bits of logic.

[bv310]

Well, I don't fully believe Amy Pond as an investigative role, but we have the time to test it, so

vote: CES

This is L-1. No hammering until we get more information and I get a good read in, please.

[bv310]

Well, I don't fully believe Amy Pond as an investigative role

How is this assuredness, Snake?

Anyway, since we appear to be massclaiming (and if aren't, we really should be), I'll go first: River Song, 1-shot Vigilante. I shot Magna N1.

[bv310]

I'm assuming that it's the ideal action for the moment. Given that it's MyLo, it's either massclaim or no lynch. I prefer MC.

[bv310]

I was eager to claim because I wanted to have time to get the massclaim out of the way, and I figured I'd be picked to start anyway.

As for why Magna, I have an excessively difficult time reading him in the average game, and his early play this game rubbed me the wrong way, so I figured I'd get two birds stoned at once and get a concrete flip from him.

[bv310]

A No-Lynch is a good idea, since it allows our potential lynch pool tomorrow to be one less (Say it's 4:2 Town:Scum. By no-lynching and bringing it down to 3:2, our chances of hitting scum go from 33% to 40%, if we were to lynch randomly), plus it allows any PRs to get another action in.

[bv310]

Given that my last post was 6 posts ago, I really don't have that much to add. I like the idea of a no-lynch (as should be obvious), but I think there's some good information that can still come to light. First off, I'd like to know whether Surye believes me or not, and his reasoning for such.

[bv310]

That's a pretty good point, re: info. I'll wait until tomorrow night, and if nothing useful is going on, I'll hammer the no-lynch.

[bv310]

Sorry. We should NOT be massclaiming and lynching. There are 6 of us still alive, with (probably) 2 scum remaining. If we mislynch today, we lose. We are No-Lynching. No-Lynching means I probably die, but we get one more night of PRs getting to do their work.

vote: No Lynch

[bv310]

In fact i'd rather you lynch me to get the game moving than have nothing going on.

Okay. He's scum. No Townie in MyLo would say "lynch me so we can move on".

[bv310]

You know what? The hell with it.

vote: Snake

If he's not scum, then GG you lurked your way to victory.

[bv310]

I figured it was better to shoot early on my biggest suspect/worry, rather than wait until late when it would be more swingy.

I really think that CMAR's modkill really hurt us. I can see why you chose to do so, but I don't agree with it. Nothing he was saying would have given him an unfair advantage or otherwise confirmed his info as real.

OTT, Well done Hoppster. I never suspected you.

P-EDIT: I stand by my choice of vig, Magna. From my perspective, you were extremely hard to read, and leaving you until later meant that there was going to be at least one complete wild card. I'd happily do it again if given the opportunity, since it was far and away the right choice for me.