Succession Mafia II: OVER!

[DrippingGoofball]

Tajo, I'm not as certain.

Nah, that's not tajoscum.

[Battousai]

I'm no liking how thAdmadral is suddenly changing up HOW he is calculating his list based on "weight". Notice how it basically made it so Chrono would HAVE to be lynched by his logic. This is AFTER people were deciding that xvart may indeed be a good lynch. Cult looking for a myslynch? I think so.

Unvote Vote Thadmral

This post is less scummy, more, well, wrong?

If thAd is a recruit, then he would be interested in ANYONE ELSE being lynched. He wouldn't try and alter the list to get someone lynched over another (unless it's an outted unrecruitable). If anything, him making a list is scummy not altering it.

[ThAdmiral]

I hate the above list WITH A PASSION.

I don't love the list either* but I felt like I needed to do SOMETHING. Everyone was just sitting around throwing votes on people and not wanting to wagon anyone because " eh, the case isn't great".

Of course the case isn't going to be great!!!

We are trying to find one-man scum teams, so that means nothing to be gleaned from interactions, nothing to be gleaned when a couple of people pile on one person like a scumteam might do, nothing to be gleaned from pretty much anything.

I feel like people needed something to help them come to a consensus.

*actually that's a lie, I've really enjoyed being the custodian of the list!

Woah there, that seems arbitrary. I didn't list mine in order of preference and if I did it wouldn't be a simple 3/2/1 exercise anyway.

I think it should be pretty clear by now that this is list is FAR more just for me than for anyone else.
That being said I did think of that, but I've included the original "how many times have they been mentioned" stats as well. As you might notice, and what is fairly predictable, is that they both go more or less hand-in-hand anyway.

We need to stop this insanity. It's gone to far. What are we doing, the scum's tax returns?

While we're on that topic, the scum

might

be interested to hear that the shipment of ak-47s they recently purchased is completely tax-deductible.

Let's speak no more of ordered lists and carry on with the lynch.

Don't make me stop. Please. It's all I've got...

Im not open to looking at xvart because its turned a game I like into random guessing which is what this bandwagon is.
xvart - 8 (Yosarian2, Seraphim, ThAdmiral, DrippingGoofball, Chronopie, Fritzler, bvoigt, Nobody Special)
=

Every single player on this wagon should know better and are not playing at there best. It's like you have all given up because the word scum has changed to cult.[/quote]
My stance is that, yes, the xvart wagon is mostly guesswork, but at least it is

educated

guesswork. He ticked all the boxes of being in that group that scum would like to recruit, but not being too obvious, while also being unlikely to be lynched as their general meta, and finally not making too much waves in this game in order to fly under the radar.

Really not happy with the way TheAdmeral is trying to do some meaningless math voodo to figure out who we should lynch rather then just placing his own vote based on his own logic.

As I said above, at least I am trying to do something. And you might notice I haven't changed my vote, and am still voting for the person who I chose based on my own logic.

Really not happy with the way TheAdmeral is trying to do some meaningless math voodo to figure out who we should lynch rather then just placing his own vote based on his own logic.

^this.

As I said above, at least I am trying to do something. And you might notice I haven't changed my vote, and am still voting for the person who I chose based on my own logic.

^this.

I'm no liking how thAdmadral is suddenly changing up HOW he is calculating his list based on "weight". Notice how it basically made it so Chrono would HAVE to be lynched by his logic. This is AFTER people were deciding that xvart may indeed be a good lynch. Cult looking for a myslynch? I think so.

Unvote Vote Thadmral

Did you miss the bit where chrono was the leader of the list regardless of how the stats were interpreted? Did you miss the fact that I'm not actually voting chrono?

this is reaching and sheeping

Well said.

[Yosarian2]

Really not happy with the way TheAdmeral is trying to do some meaningless math voodo to figure out who we should lynch rather then just placing his own vote based on his own logic.

As I said above, at least I am trying to do something. And you might notice I haven't changed my vote, and am still voting for the person who I chose based on my own logic.

(shrug) I don't really mind the list; although I've had bad experiences with similar things in the past, I understand the impulse to try to get a consensus created for a lynch before deadline. But I would like to see you scumhunt as well, was my point. It's been a while since we really heard your opinions on anything.

[ThAdmiral]

How does Tanarin know that Admiral is pushing for a MISLYNCH?

To be fair, how would one recruit know that someone else is also not a recruit?

This post is less scummy, more, well, wrong?

I pretty much agree with this.

Yeah, here's a new list, Admiral, top three choices:
Admiral (There's got to be some kind of ulterior motive in this switch of tallying. Whether it's to get the person YOU think is the most scummy lynched, or a theoretical scumbuddy into safety.)
Chronopie
Seraphim

(And yes, I changed the order intentionally. Thank you for keeping track of the lists, though. )

So, I had some time today. Here is my list. I couldn't decide on the third, but here are two:

Flameaxe
Herodotus

^ those aren't tears of sadness...

...they're tears of joy. People clearly still want list!!!

[ThAdmiral]

(shrug) I don't really mind the list; although I've had bad experiences with similar things in the past, I understand the impulse to try to get a consensus created for a lynch before deadline. But I would like to see you scumhunt as well, was my point. It's been a while since we really heard your opinions on anything.

I've been inserting my opinion on matters here and there amongst my posts, but it is true that I don't really feel strongly about anyone. I find it hard to properly scumhunt in this game as I just don't know what to look for. I mean I know that cult would be after a lynch, anyone's lynch, but they surely wouldn't want to make this too obvious, or maybe they would and rely on wifom etc. etc. etc. Basically it is difficult.

I am approaching it more from a process of elimination point of view, or a PoEPoV (ooh, I like that). There are a bunch of people I think the scum would have to be a bit daft to recruit, and then there are some others who I have more or less discounted as possible recruits because of how they have acted today and that has left me with a smaller group of players, of which I would basically be happy to lynch any of them.

[DrippingGoofball]

Let's speak no more of ordered lists and carry on with the lynch.

Don't make me stop. Please. It's all I've got...

It's all you've got, and you're handing it to the scum. They'll give you a standing ovation when the game is over and a huge raise. You're doing their work.

Of course we're having trouble, the scum isn't helping with the usual bus'ing. It's really hard to get a lynch without the Greyhound Fleet.

[DrippingGoofball]

We are trying to find

one-man scum teams

[...]

How do you know?

[ThAdmiral]

We are trying to find

one-man scum teams

[...]

How do you know?

Assumption.

[Magister Ludi]

Players I would like to lynch:
Yos2
Chrono
Thad/Batt

People that I will oppose lynching :
xvart
Cobbler

I'm still not very willing to move off Yos2, but at this point in the day if enough people aren't convinced then it probably isn't going to happen. I'm making one last call here.

Chronopie could.

I think waiting until deadline now is a disaster. For one, we've talked about all we can think of, going further into the day serves no purpose (in my opinion), people aren't going to change their reads.

Second, we may need this bankable time on subsequent days.

[Magister Ludi]

I think the most likely low posting/low visibility player that is a recruit is Chrono.

Its bothering me that there are around 5 lpayers with almost no content. the people who have very few posts should get their asses in gear.

[Seraphim]

Ass: In Gear

Unvote

Vote: Chronopie

Let's fucking do it. Enough people are suspicious of him. Let's roll with it.

[Kinetic]

I know what your ability is DGB.

I'll burn your house down.

[Fritzler]

I know what your ability is DGB.

I'll burn your house down.

MAYBE HE RECRUITED THE OTHER PROSTITUTE!?!?!?!?!?!?!!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?

FOS: FLAMEAXE

YOU SIR, ARE HIGHLY SUSPECT

[xvart]

So, I had some time today. Here is my list. I couldn't decide on the third, but here are two:

Flameaxe
Herodotus

This is very interesting since you were previously "most inclined to support my lynch" yet I fail to make your list, especially when you consider your recent soft support of me being scum.

I'm still not very willing to move off Yos2, but at this point in the day if enough people aren't convinced then it probably isn't going to happen. I'm making one last call here.

Chronopie could.

I don't see the Yos2 lynch going anywhere based on game/wagon/discussion momentum so the best bet is to move your vote to Chronopie to get that to the viable wagon stage.

[Magister Ludi]

Unvote

Vote: Chrono

Time is now.

[Katsuki]

Unvote, Vote: Chronopie

[Yosarian2]

mmm. I still think xvart is more likely to be scum.

Of course, the dumbest thing we could do today is no-lynch.

[DrippingGoofball]

Second dumbest thing is to lynch obv-lynchbait as potential recruit.

[Magister Ludi]

We aren't no lynching in this game when lynching is 10 times more important than normal.

Dripping, if you mean Chrono, I fail to see how that is 'lynch-bait', but after 44 pages of play and posting and game theorey traps and previous preconcieved notions of that players play, if after all that you are still 'lynch-bait', you're doing it wrong and probably should be lynched.

[Albert B. Rampage]

Let's move this along now, shall we.

[Magister Ludi]

Where have you been?

[Yosarian2]

Let's move this along now, shall we.

Where have you been?

Why, aren't you allowed to prod your cult recruiter during the day?

[Magister Ludi]

Its that sort of nonsencial rubbish that really affirms you being recruited in my eyes.

[Chronopie]

Let's move this along now, shall we.

Translation: Not my Recruit.

--

All you have right now, is my word, that I am not recruited.

This Wagon looks to be nothing more than a Policy Lynch by way of Lynch all Lurkers (explained absence), and is sub-optimal play.