Mini 1170: Nowhereville Mafia '11- Over!

[CooLDoG]

SO we have 3 people who are role fishing now?

Reads coming. Thins have gotten a little bit off track, but you will get those reads soon.

[CooLDoG]

Why is the "load draft button" not there? Ohh yes because this the wrong account. Apologies to all.

[CooLDoG]

Yah, but could you see a kool, kal, and panzer scum team? Bub has told me repeatedly that he doesn't think kal is scum with kool. He based that mostly off of the back and forth they had back a while ago.

Put simply at this point I would be willing to vote for panzer or kool.

[CooLDoG]

Damn it. Sorry for posting in this account.

[CooLDoG]

SK, you do realize, the only way i can be scum to these people, is if you are scum. You know your alignment, dont be an idiot and actually think for yourself

This is exactly why sk shouldn't have hammered.

Panzer it is assumed that we will win. I really highly doubt that mith will take punishment. If they do pm me and I will

vouch for

defend you. If in fact everybody else is a vt (they are, barring an untruthful claim for what reason I do not know) then usually the game is just called.

Actually at first I wasn't 100% on panzer claiming jailkeep. But then I realized that it would make it a 50/50 and hiplop wasn't exactly considered the most pro-town. But I am most surprised at the sk hammer.

[CooLDoG]

clarification, I think that panzer played admirably, and he doesn't deserve to be punished for a small slip up.

[CooLDoG]

SK, you do realize, the only way i can be scum to these people, is if you are scum. You know your alignment, dont be an idiot and actually think for yourself

This is exactly why sk shouldn't have hammered.

I don't follow you here.

logic:

Sk knows he is town
Hip claims jk to protect SK (towney) from being lynched.
No sane scum would claim a power role in order to save a towney
Shouldn't have hammered.

I think we did well, I did make a few mistakes. Like that stupid serial killer lurker comment.

[CooLDoG]

Elfin, the only thing that you did wrong was the fact that you never made a case. If you had made a case you would have developed your arguments and been able to view the game in a better light.

[CooLDoG]

@espy, sorry for the pre-game banter about you flaking from games

@kool, you have to be a merciless cut through to win this game. Treat this a your noob game and play another mini normal. Don't go into a theme game yet... All in all you okay for a first scum game. You just needed to make a case and be decisive. Sitting on the fence is how you got suspicions on you. That's mostly how you look town is by be definite in your reads and making cases. Make a few walls here and there so that people think you are contributing to the game. And lastly forget that you are scum. If you take any of this advice make it be that last sentence.


@all, sense this is part of my improvement program (aka, the Lets Make CooLDoG Not Suck at Mafia Program), do any of you have any comments about my play in general, posting style, or anything that would be counted as criticism. Personally the tougher you are the better, I need all the comments you can think of.

with all that said Kool shouldn't be taking any of my advice

[CooLDoG]

^grrr, he's to town to be town this late in the game wifom. lol. Nobody has ever told me to be less town before, I take that as a complement. Apparently making a conscious effort to improve really does help.