Newbie 08 - Game Over

[Banana Bob]

hmmm, lets see

*closes eyes, spins around and points at a name*
*points to .... Max22*

random vote: Max22

[Banana Bob]

hmmm, wonder where blackhawk is. Maybe another vote should suck him out

unvote: Max22
vote: Blackhawk

[Banana Bob]

unvote: blackhawk

back to my old vote

random vote: Max22

[Banana Bob]

roxy, the game wouldn't have started if not everyone has gotten their role and confirmed it.

[Banana Bob]

i'm just thinking about what he said about the mafia being not active and having to be a lurker to be sucessful (well not that but he said it's a good strategy)

I find that it is foolish for him to think that because players now a days target lurkers. And even then you're underestimating the scum because you think their offense is limited because there are many methods the scum can use. I think in one game where meme won as an SK. She make one accusation and then sit back and watch the chaos. She stay active and talked like a town with intentions otherwise, and it's this that basically got her the win.
Now you may think, she's an SK. It's every different to the mafia, but aren't their intentions the same, kill off everyone against her. So basically the strategy is the same.

I find it suspicious that you are going in such great depth to prove your innocence by a mere accusation of being active. You could easily have just said I like to be active because i'm into the game. But no you had to assume that the mafia will not be so active as a defense to yourself. Kinda like you are scum but have to make that point to make sure you are not suspicious.

vote: Pie_is_good

[Banana Bob]

damn, only just remembered that i hadn't unvoted

so

unvote:Max22
vote: Pie_is_good

[Banana Bob]

ok, looks like morning came before the deadline, but we got some inactives.
Right now max 22, is inactive. Which means he HAS to be a normal townie (unless of course he's not posted in anything else)
Then theres UT, he's inactive here but is infact active elsewhere. This can mean he's a lurker.
Then theres blackhawk, who made the vote a long time after i'd posted my reason for voting P_I_G.
I don't think that theres anyone else suspicious because they'd voted for P_I_G at the start.

So

FOS both UT and blackhawk

[Banana Bob]

I'd say it was the doc, anyone with a clue about the aim of this game would definately pic a target at night. and it would seem to me that everyone has a pretty good idea what their aim is here.

UT: I never voted for you did I, I merely FOSed you.
Now why would you want to defend yourself when an accusation isn't even made yet?

vote: Untrod Tripod

[Banana Bob]

ok then

unvote UT
vote: blackhawk