Mini 1219 - Bedtime Stories Mafia - Game Over!

[Llamarble]

It's kind of depressing that the main reason people think i'm town is because i screwed up a bunch of times :X

I personally don't really get this since I think of you as sufficiently competent never to make those errors as town -> they're fake.
I felt like you were joking about the 3 cults thing and then people were "NERUZ IS A TOTAL DERP & THEREFORE TOWN" so you ran with it.
But mreh, WV is still more scum than you.
I greatly prefer WV lynch over others at this point.

[Neruz]

Eh, i'll be honest, i wasn't really paying a whole lot of attention to the game.

[Thomith]

think Thomith will be the best lynch for today.

I don't want Thomith lynched.

Oh the contradictions UNVOTE: VOTE: EB I know we said not to lynch a power role today but this is the biggest contradiction ever, "i want to lynch this person" "i don't want thomith lynched" scumradaroffthecharts.

[Llamarble]

Minds change, youngling. Yes they do.

[Neruz]

Flail some more scumith.

[Llamarble]

Actually yeah that was pretty bad.
VOTE: Thomith

[Thomith]

Explain, don't just echo neruz.

[Thomith]

so minds change in the same bloody post? I'd love to hear the explanation on this one.

[Llamarble]

VOTE: WV
Actually attacking somebody for NOT voting you counterbalances "I know we said lynching X is a bad idea but I think I can attack X."

[Llamarble]

so minds change in the same bloody post? I'd love to hear the explanation on this one.

It was a catch up post.
Though really I wouldn't be stunned if EB is scum.
And I haven't reread ponies in a while and I think they might be somebody I think of as goodscum.

[Thomith]

if it is a catchup post you say
"person A would have been a good lynch today but because of Evidence X i don't want to lynch person A anymore"

You don't say
"Thomith is a good lynch for today" then later go on to say "i don't want to lynch Thomith today"
imo it was a contradiction slip, if it was a catchup post or not there is no excuse for it.

[weirdvoigts]

Link to the post(s) before I make a conclusion.

[Thomith]

http://mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopic.ph ... 5#p3403185 is the post if you mean the EB contradiction post

[GreyICE]

Vote Count 2.4

Ellibereth(0) -

Banshee(0) -

Evil Bullet(1) -

Thomith

hiphop(1) -

WeirdVoights

implosion(0) -

Neruz(1) -

implosion

Llamarble(0) -

Rainbowdash(0) -

Thomith (3) -

hiphop, Neruz, RainbowDash,

weirdvoigts(1) -

Llamarble

Not Voting (2) -

Ellibereth, Evil Bullet,

With 10 alive, it is 6 to lynch

Current VLAs

~none~

Prod/Replacement Status

~Everyone is within posting guidelines~

Deadline

The day will end in:

(expired on 2011-09-13 14:00:00)

[/quote]

[Evil Bullet]

think Thomith will be the best lynch for today.

I don't want Thomith lynched.

Oh the contradictions UNVOTE: VOTE: EB I know we said not to lynch a power role today but this is the biggest contradiction ever, "i want to lynch this person" "i don't want thomith lynched" scumradaroffthecharts.

keep in mind I read about 150 posts in between those two statements.

[Thomith]

keep in mind it doesn't matter it is still a contradiction.

[Evil Bullet]

I can't see Thomith being such bad scum (not just the recent posts, I'm talking about yesterday more). He's been a perfect paradigm of almost every scum tell in the book at one point this game. It's too easy.

[Evil Bullet]

And for everyone voting him:

Find me some reasons why you think it's possible that Voided and Thomith are on the same team.

[Evil Bullet]

vote: Weirdvoigts

Les git dat counterwagon

[Llamarble]

:yepyep:
I've played with bvoigtscum and he sounded more or less like here.
Also he and voided had sketchy D1 interactions.
And a whole bunch of the other ponies are town.

Town:
Llamarble
Implosion
Ellibereth

Probtown:
Banshee
Evil Bullet
Rainbow - I need to not let this one coast because the ponies are all very good at playing scum. Also would explain the Beckkill well.
Thomith

Scumsland:
Hiphop
Neruz

Scum:
Weirdvoigts

[wierdalexv]

@Mod: You have us voting both Thomith and Hiphop.

Hmm. I'll talk over that contradiction with Bvoigt.

~Wierdalexv

[wierdalexv]

EBWOP:

@Mod: You have us voting both Thomith and Hiphop.

Just bolding that so the mod doesn't miss it.

~Wierdalexv

[weirdvoigts]

EBWOEBWOP:

@Mod: You have us voting both Thomith and Hiphop.

Hmm. I'll talk over that contradiction with Bvoigt.

~Wierdalexv

EBWOP:

@Mod: You have us voting both Thomith and Hiphop.

Just bolding that so the mod doesn't miss it.

~Wierdalexv

/Crap

Fixed

[weirdvoigts]

@Llamarble: Please explain whether or not you did any meta on Thomith.

think Thomith will be the best lynch for today.

I don't want Thomith lynched.

Oh the contradictions UNVOTE: VOTE: EB I know we said not to lynch a power role today but this is the biggest contradiction ever, "i want to lynch this person" "i don't want thomith lynched" scumradaroffthecharts.

I guess it's a contradiction, but I don't see what makes it more likely to come from scum. EB's not going to forget his "read" in 150 posts, and even if he did, a townie's just as likely to forget about something as scum.

keep in mind it doesn't matter it is still a contradiction.

You don't think that was enough time to change his mind, or simply forget about it as town?

:yepyep:
I've played with bvoigtscum and he sounded more or less like here.
Also he and voided had sketchy D1 interactions.
And a whole bunch of the other ponies are town.

Have you played with me as town? I sound pretty much the same.

[weirdvoigts]

-bvoigt