Mini 1219 - Bedtime Stories Mafia - Game Over!

[Thomith]

Woo yeah.
Took long enough, and now i learned how not to play as town form my play this game.
win all round.

[GreyICE]

I'd also be curious what people thought of the setup.

It was my attempt to avoid giving scum a roleblocker, which is becoming the mini normal panacea to all balance issues, while still preventing claiming from really breaking the game open.

Obviously that didn't work quite as intended, but I never really anticipated the even-night jailkeeper to be in a position to confirm town, much less more than once.

RainbowDash's protection was an excellent piece of work.

[Beck]

I liked the setup personally, it was different and scum having day talk only with voided's role was interesting.

[Banshee]

Thank you for not lynching me and I am very very sorry I doubted you, Llamarble. That's the mislynch I regret most.

[Thomith]

This setup was good and i find the encryptor to be an brilliant thing to add as no-one ever expects it, And i love the use of the even/odd mechanics.

[Banshee]

I am grateful that implosion was able to identify Ellibereth because I would never have suspected him. Mad respect for implosion, seriously.

@GreyIce: The flavour of this game was exceptional. Thank you.

[Beck]

Basically the dead felt elli was going to win, he lost his town cred by lurking.

I never saw why he had it to begin with but that's just me.

[Thomith]

i only really thought elli would be a good lynch as they would be the scum we wouldn't catch.

[evilpacman18]

I enjoyed this game. I feel like it woulda been more balanced without the JK. It would've been quite different if Beck had lived long enough to get some kills in. Really good game. I liked the playerlist, even Thomith and Neruz. They really made the last couple of days tricky.

[evilpacman18]

Also, regarding Thomith, I'm just glad "too scummy to be scum" is still a legitimate argument.

[Banshee]

Any chance of seeing the dead or scum QTs? Did I miss the links somewhere?

[Beck]

I was so unsure who to kill n1

EB and Rainbow I didn't trust either, I wanted to rage kill EB but figured beter not.
Thom i knew was town despite being able to write a walk of scummy things
Hiphop I felt was scum but not enough to kill him
So I read the wiki and saw that killing an inactive is never a bad idea so I chose that guy. He was never going to be active enough and probably would not have progressed the game like it went if left alive.

I hate being vig cause I never have town reads.

P.edit - too scummy to be scum is my d1 philosophy usually

[Beck]

Dead QT- http://www.quicktopic.com/46/H/6hDKvChLAPKR

[Rainbowdash]

yay

As normal happy with day one play, not so with from there on out.

More later

[Banshee]

Basically the dead felt elli was going to win, he lost his town cred by lurking.

I never saw why he had it to begin with but that's just me.

It's my opinion that implosion won this for town. If scum had targeted implosion early I think it would have been an easy walk to victory for the scum.

[evilpacman18]

Basically the dead felt elli was going to win, he lost his town cred by lurking.

I never saw why he had it to begin with but that's just me.

It's my opinion that implosion won this for town. If scum had targeted implosion early I think it would have been an easy walk to victory for the scum.

I have no idea why you have this opinion. It was nice that he was confirmed though. I might've lynched him over Elli if he wasn't.

[Beck]

Weird lynch made little sense to me, I could see marble but meh.

It's always different watching from the bleachers. Nice luck hitting me n1, you actually helped town more than you realize by killing me off.

If they had a scummy for player who means well but still fucks up shit, I'd probably win that hands down lol

[Banshee]

Basically the dead felt elli was going to win, he lost his town cred by lurking.

I never saw why he had it to begin with but that's just me.

It's my opinion that implosion won this for town. If scum had targeted implosion early I think it would have been an easy walk to victory for the scum.

I have no idea why you have this opinion. It was nice that he was confirmed though. I might've lynched him over Elli if he wasn't.

You would have lynched me, or implosion. You didn't have a clue who the scum was, and neither did I. Implosion originated and pushed that lynch when you were all about lynching me.

So yeah, I'm giving this one to implosion because he is the one who pulled it out for town. You didn't and I didn't. He did it.

[Beck]

Implosion was the one who chose elli, he gets props for that.

I must say, all those roles outed so early really helped shape the game. I know grey didn't want it, and I don't feel it broke the game but yeah, it helped.

Hindsite, hiphop should not have claimed.

[GreyICE]

IMHO the vig shot was perfectly valid. At the rate he was contributing to the game, sleuth would have most likely been an information-free mislynch at some point in time.

I think you had a very good approach, Beck, especially since you had multiple shots - thin out the herd of lurkers.

[Beck]

Yeah I knew he was either scum or utterly useless. I just felt insecure after rainbow's comments d2. I'm sensitive

[Banshee]

Was it explained why the scum chose to shoot Beck?
That was an amazingly lucky shot; it made me think scum had a rolecop, honestly.

[wierdalexv]

GG. Really liked the setup.

Also, since nobody would explain during the game...
Why were we lynched?

[Banshee]

For my part, lurkiness, popping in just to hammer with no previous comment, general lack of input that was nonscummy. Also, I felt really bad about Llamarble so I was inclined to follow his suspicions at that point anyway.

[implosion]

daw, thanks.

And yay.

wv was lynched in my mind because if they weren't lynched then, they were going to wind up being lynched later. If they were town, I felt like they were going to wind up being lynched at some point, and if they were scum, i figured we might as well lynch them then. I didn't actually have a particularly strong read on them.

yay

As normal happy with day one play, not so with from there on out.

More later

It's kind of the opposite for me, actually. I never really got any scum on day one, except for hiphop - but then i kind of fizzled away from that as the day went on, and with a new bandwagon forming every few days we just managed to hit scum... partially by luck. And then I kind of decided that hiphop dying wouldn't be bad on day two, and then we were kind of pantsonhead until i decided to go with elli.

As for the setup, the even night jailkeeper + odd night vig synergy is beautiful. Didn't get to be used much, but it's beautiful, and the setup as a whole makes sense (it should be clear that i think that based on what i've been saying about the setup).