Mini 425 Generic Western Mafia- Game over!

[Avinyl]

/Confirm

[Avinyl]

Vote: Vryklan

because he put the third vote on Guardian if Guardians count is correct.

[Avinyl]

Putting the third vote on someone is as good a reason as any for being random voted.

[Avinyl]

Putting the third vote on someone is as good a reason as any for being random voted.

But why random vote? There are already so much material to go on.

Because this was in the evening, i was tired, and i hadn't time to read. I also feel that it is better to random vote someone than to not vote at all.
However,

Slight Finger of Suspicion: Guardian

for appearing so town-like.

[Avinyl]

I would also like to point out a VERY crucial bit of information that could easily be missed:

The members of the town rush out of the local saloon to see that the local sheriff and doctor have both been gunned down.

To me, this suggests no power roles. That gives the Scum incredible freedom to make accusations, form false bonds with town players, and in general post without fear of being busted by a cop. It also puts a lot of pressure on the town during end-game, as all we will have to go on is voting record and posting. This also allows scum to target whoever they want.

Without a doctor, It is highly likely that pro-town players, as well as players who are correctly picking out scum, will be targeted for night kills.

-Peter

Even if the sheriff and the doctor are dead, we may have other power roles. Also, there may be backup roles for the sheriff/doctor. I guess we will have to wait to see if any power roles die before we can be sure.

[Avinyl]

For some reason, i couldn't log in to mafiascum, but now i am here again. I am rereading and analyzing right now, but i think i will be done soon.

[Avinyl]

I have reread the thread, however, i can't see anything distinctly scummy.

DLMF

: Only 6 posts excluding confirmation, sticks with his vote because of gut feeling. I don't think he's scum though.

Gor

kc

at

: He seems to be very skeptical about why people vote.

Guardian

: He seems to be a little to eager newbie, but i have a gut feeling that he is scum and is just trying to seem like a little to eager newbie. I am also suspicious of the "speedlynch Raffles" and the proposition of a random lynch.

Ichigo

: 4 posts; Confirm, random vote, talking about the tigers on April 1.

John

: Many posts, but no post is longer than a few sentences. I don't know what to think about him.

Mustafa15

: Only a few short posts, however, he has posted that he would be away.

Occult

: Doesn't want to vote definitively yet, however, he is suspicious of 3 persons.

Peter Venkman

: Insists upon that we probably haven't any power roles. How can he be so sure?

Raffles

: I can't make up my mind on him, either he's town or he is scum that seems protown.

Vel-Rahn Koon

: He switched rather quickly from Guardian to Vryklan.

Vryklan

: I no longer know what to think.

Unvote Vryklan

,

Vote Ichigo

for reasons stated above.

[Avinyl]

I have reread the thread, however, i can't see anything distinctly scummy.

DLMF

: Only 6 posts excluding confirmation, sticks with his vote because of gut feeling. I don't think he's scum though.

Gor

kc

at

: He seems to be very skeptical about why people vote.

Guardian

: He seems to be a little to eager newbie, but i have a gut feeling that he is scum and is just trying to seem like a little to eager newbie. I am also suspicious of the "speedlynch Raffles" and the proposition of a random lynch.

Ichigo

: 4 posts; Confirm, random vote, talking about the tigers on April 1.

John

: Many posts, but no post is longer than a few sentences. I don't know what to think about him.

Mustafa15

: Only a few short posts, however, he has posted that he would be away.

Occult

: Doesn't want to vote definitively yet, however, he is suspicious of 3 persons.

Peter Venkman

: Insists upon that we probably haven't any power roles. How can he be so sure?

Raffles

: I can't make up my mind on him, either he's town or he is scum that seems protown.

Vel-Rahn Koon

: He switched rather quickly from Guardian to Vryklan.

Vryklan

: I no longer know what to think.

Unvote Vryklan

,

Vote Ichigo

for reasons stated above.

You vote me when it seems, atleast to me, that you're really suspicious of Guardian, but of course I could be way off in my observation there, correct me if I'm wrong. I thought the whole point of the game was to lynch the mafia not lynch a random lurker. Oh and if you really want to put pressure on a lurker you're going to need more than one vote.

I am not very suspicious of Guardian, i have only a small feeling that he is scum. However, now that you've posted, I'll

Unvote Ichigo

,

Vote John

, for posting many small posts without really saying much.

[Avinyl]

My reasoning for voting Ichigo

I was not very supicious of anyone, and so voted for the one who had participated the least. When he came back, i had no reason to vote him, so i voted John instead.

My reasoning for not being so suspicious of Guardian

I had many reasons to be supicious but none of them were strong reasons.

[Avinyl]

1. Guardian, I believe that was the third vote on me, so I am at lynch -4, not lynch -3.

2. I do not know what you mean by my "weird logic".

3. My vote History:
Random vote
Vote Ichigo for Lurking
Vote John because i think that he is the most suspicious one.
I would not call that vote switching, at least not more than normal.

[Avinyl]

Because this was in the evening, i was tired, and i hadn't time to read. I also feel that it is better to random vote someone than to not vote at all.
However,

Slight Finger of Suspicion: Guardian

for appearing so town-like.

I don't like this post, with the too townie and the random vote after discussion had started. Then, in post 171, he talks about a couple of people lurking and votes Ichigo for lurking, in his 3rd post with any content at all whatsoever, the darned hippocrit . Plus he talks in indigo, which is slightly annoying, and pushes me over the edge into

vote:Avinyl

.

Note: I know I'm putting him at lynch -3, but I don't really see that as being to big of a deal. It does make some caution neccessary, I suppose.

1. The discussion had started, but it wasn't very long and i felt that it is better to vote than not to.

2. I was not sure about who to vote, and so I voted Ichigo to at least give him some incentive to come back. When he came back, I had made up my mind, and voted John.

3. It is spelled

hypocrite

, not hippocrit.

4. Do you really mean that you are voting me because i posts in indigo?[/indigo]

[Avinyl]

I am sorry, i didn't notice that the forums were available again. I have forgotten most of this game, so i will reread before saying anything.

[Avinyl]

I apologize, i had internet problems. I will post soon.

[Avinyl]

I apologize, i had internet problems and then a friend of mine died in a traffic accident. I will reread and post soon.

[Avinyl]

Probably Town

Occult: He seems pro-town to me, but it's just a gut feeling.
Gor

kc

at: Also gut feeling.
Thesp: I agree with Gor

kc

at that he plays mostly the same as in my other game with him.

Unsure

John: Mostly short posts, which makes it hard for me to know what to think.
Guardian: He confuses me, i change my mind about him each hour. He has done some scummy things and some anti-scummy things.

Scummy

Peter Venkman: I don't know why, but he feels like he is scum.

Unvote John Vote Peter Venkman

just because he feels scummy.
I will analyze the other 5 players posts later.