Mini 436 - Game over - Mafia wins with no casualties!

[StallingChamp]

Vote: VanDamien

, lets get this bandwagon rolling!

[StallingChamp]

Sorry, I haven't had much time for this game, my apologies.

Anyways, Snichkin is by far the scummiest player in this game so far, in my opinion, for a small quote. It may seem harmless at first, and in fact probably still seems harmless to the rest of you. Hopefully you will see how scummy it is by the end of this post. The quote in question is below.

In Newbie 335 (If I remmember right), I changed my vote oftenly and then voted someone for long time. StallingChamp and Rosso Carne saw this tactic as a scumy one and lynched me (I was the doc). So I'm trying to prove that it wasn't scumy at all

First of all, there is a rule against referencing ongoing games. This is a rule in every game, and so isn't like its a rare rule or anything. Last time I checked, Town players don't tend to go around breaking rules in order to attempt to make a case.

Secondly, I am not even dead in the game in question. Because of this, my alignment is not public yet, and I am not about to talk about that here. Without going too deep into the game (see the rule mentioned above), can you not think of a possibility that would lead me to play against what is best for the Town?

Last, and most importantly, I am being extremely misrepresented by what he is saying. Not only was he the prime suspect (from what I recal), but I did not even post in the almost 3 full days before the lynch occured. I was not in agreement with his lynch (which also happened to be a quicklynch, with the hammering vote coming much sooner than the Town was comfortable with). Is is making me out to be the big bad guy here, but the fact remains that I placed a vote on him to pressure him, and never unvoted. Also, when he mentions that I lynched "the doc", he didn't quite add in that he NEVER CLAIMED.

Ah well, I said much more about that game then I meant to, but I'll leave it here anyways. It doesn't really say much that isn't easily seen by a skim of the game, and I need to clear up what he "forgot" to mention.

Unvote, Vote Snichkin

MOD - Can you please make your own posts for VCs, instead of just editing another player's post?

[StallingChamp]

No time for game-related post, but thought I'd throuw this out there.

MOD:

It is rather distracting for me to have you edit in your VCs. It would make it alot easier if you would make a post of your own.

Other Players:

Am I the only one that finds the edited VCs troubling, or do some of you share that view?

[StallingChamp]

Sorry guys, I forgot about this game...

Anyways, I don't like lynching ABR today, and so I am suspicious of ryan and paraxombie for pushing it for no apparent good reason. Para seems to be doing it much, much more, though, so I will

Unvote, Vote Paraxombie

[StallingChamp]

Well, I was prodded, so I assume that they also were, and perhaps they avoided the prod and/or are intentionally lurking.

[StallingChamp]

I read the whole thread, and find that his reasons (and yours, to a lesser extent) are far from anything that is even a decent theory.

[StallingChamp]

Heh, way to misrepresent!

I never said that I

believed

ABR, in fact, I didn't even comment on the claim at all! All I said was that I do not think that he is

today's

lynch.

[StallingChamp]

As for scum pushing the wagon, I know I'm vanilla and will be confirmed as such if ABR is actually not lying, and I feel pretty good about para for the same reason. It just wouldn't make sense for any scum to sacrfice themselves on Day one to get one townie. Ryan I can't say either way at this point.

WIFOM.

[StallingChamp]

But DogMom, are you willing to let him coast until endgame because he might have made a powerful and scary claim?

[StallingChamp]

Meh, with a deadline looming, I think we might as well pressure a lurker.

Vote: Poison Ivy

[StallingChamp]

Yeah, apon further review, HurriKaty is actually lurking, Ivy could have forgotten about the game.

Unvote, Vote: HurriKaty

, but

IGMEOY Ivy

[StallingChamp]

Unvote, Vote: DeathSauce

Way to take all of that way out of context!

[StallingChamp]

Okay, explain how any of those statements is "out of context"?

You just took every time he mentions HK in any post, and put them all there. Just because he happens to, in the middle of a post, mention that at that point he isn't feeling the HK wagon doesn't mean that he is defending her.

[StallingChamp]

Except I didn't defend or explain his actions at all...But even if I had, if I see craplogic being used, I will say it, no matter who it's targetted at.

[StallingChamp]

So, does that mean the plan is to lynch hurrikaty

?

I'm willing to vote her today if she doesn't post within the next 24 hours. I am inclined to agree with death and ryan in this situation, that katy's lurking has become quite the fiasco.

I don't think enough people have weighed in their opinion yet

I think that HurriKatty's last post is all the opinion we need. She blatently ADMITTED to lurking, for pete's sake.

Unvote, Vote HK

[StallingChamp]

I'm gonna give her one last chance, if her post feels scummy, I have no problem changing my vote to her

So, she lurks all day, is called on it, and does nothing but ADMIT TO LURKING. Why is it that you insist on giving her so many chances? Don't want to lose a buddy on Day 1 I guess...

FoS: ryan

Mod edit
Votecount:
Hurrikaty 5 (DeathSauce, VanDamien, DogMom, Albert B. Rampage, StallingChamp)
Albert B. Rampage 2 (Paradoxombie, ryan)
Paradoxombie 1 (vollkan)
Poison Ivy 1 (Miztef)
StallingChamp 1 (Poison Ivy)

Not voting 2: Tophat, Hurrikaty

With 12 alive it takes 7 votes to lynch. Reminder: deadline is 3rd of June. Reminder 2: don't forget to unvote before you vote someone.

[StallingChamp]

I don't think there is much of a chance of that, given that ABR claims to be a psychopath. I find it unlikely that there would be another weird role (I think you mean "Jester" by suicidal role) in this game. Obviously, it is still a possibility which we can't dismiss but I don't think the likelihood is that high, since it would create a very messy game.

There better as hell not be a Jester in a Normal game...

[StallingChamp]

I think he means he wanted to ask for Doc protect to make the scum less likely to kill him, in fear of a protected kill.

[StallingChamp]

2 questions for Damien:

- When do I seem to be coaching Ryan?

- Even if we were scumbuddies, why the heck wouldI be coaching him in-thread?

FoS: VD

[StallingChamp]

Why? You tell me. A slip, frustration, thought it was disguised?

-You may not discuss this game outside the topic, unless your role says you can.

If your role says you can talk outside this topic, you can do so during day

, night, via msn, aim, PM, or whatever you wish.

Emphasis mine.

[StallingChamp]

Scum can ALWAYS talk outside the game...The rule I quoted says that those roles that CAN talk outside the game (scum, masons, etc...) can do so any time, not just at Night. That's my interpratation of it, at least.

[StallingChamp]

Two deaths.

I just think it'd be a little overtaxing on the town if there were two full mafia factions.

A vig wouldn't have killed dogmom, she was so overwhelmingly helpful. And I had thought everyone had come to some sort of agreement to let albert get to Day 2 at the least.

From my experience, the "Standard" set-up, is 3M/1SK/8T.