Mini 470 - Some Guys Are Trying To Kill You (done)

[Gatorguy91]

OMGUS/Random Vote: Oman

For kiling me last game.

[Gatorguy91]

I may be gone the next 5-7 days so please don't replace me.

[Gatorguy91]

Nevermind, I have internet in this hotel/condo

[Gatorguy91]

vote: gatorguy91

we just lost our cop on the first night. why you so anxious to hold onto your place in the game despite being gone for 5-7 days?

Woah, call off your dogs, dude. I came to this site to play mafia, isn't that

what I'm supposed to be doing?

FoS: Soupfly for having a dumb reason for a legitimate vote.

[Gatorguy91]

My Defense is that Soupfly had no evidence to Go on and just decided to say i was
scum. I saw that as dumb, and stated as so, and that's scummy? Then Again, What's not scummy theese days?

A little bit of anaylasis:

Soupfly is obviously eager to point his finger at someone, however he seems to be playing not too well. I'll keep my FoS on him.

Jenter Didn't like my reasoning, his points seem to be short. I'm not very suspicious of him.

Oman Pressure voted me, which wasn't very scummy and is a nice routine for finding scum. After he unvoted Soupfly, which seemed to be a popular thing to do at the point.

Niv has been protecting me, which is part of certain scum strategy (Befriend a townie) But I'm not all that suspicious of him.

Thaiboxershorts quickly jumped on the bandwagon and quickly jumped off after Oman. Fos: Thai for bandwagoning.

Erecthomania has not made any contributations to the game townwise, yet has posted.

Erg0... I'm sorta confused about him.

Zakk_status and Langley haven't even posted, yet I'm not suspicious.

[Gatorguy91]

Legitimate=not random

[Gatorguy91]

in the spirit of Sherlock Holmes sleuthing

Erotomachia-style

...

i'm similarly curious how gatorguy is posting in other threads today (friday), but has made only feeble attempts to respond to accusations against him in this game:

http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... &start=225
http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 3&start=50

also, if he posts here on sunday that he'll be gone for the next 5-7 days then why does he sign up for another mafia game on the same day?
http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... start=1625

care to answer these gatorguy?

@niv, after looking through the site yesterday, i understand your suspicion of me vis-a-vis my argumentation style (WIFOM/metagaming). in my defense this is my second game so i'm still learning.

1. I didn't know i would have access here, and i didn't expect that game to start for 5 days anyway.
2. Here's a post. I wanted to post after lots of activity so I wouldn't have nothing to say, really.

I'm upgrading my FoS to a vote.

Vote Soupfly

[Gatorguy91]

I'd Like To see some content from Langley, because he's been in other games but not this one since the sign up.

Zakk_status... Probably just has limited access, but I'd still like to see something from him..

Until then,

Unvote Soupfly

. In all likelyhood this could go back right away.

[Gatorguy91]

IGMEOY Jenter. I forgot about this, but you were being extremely hypocritical.

[Gatorguy91]

the one thing i'm not liking is that suspicion seems to be falling on those who are most active in posting.

Good Point!!

Vote Zakk_status

Tell Me WHY You're not scum. [/b]

[Gatorguy91]

Village Idiot i might be.

Unvote Zakk_Status

a pointless vote really.

Thoughts: Soupfly. Earlier I thought you were scum, but your material seems to be good. UnFoS Soupfly. Agree with Thai here.

Why He might be scum: "We lost our cop" speech, drawing suspiscion from an empty post.

Why He might not be scum: Large contributions to the game, very active, seems to be trying to help the town.

Anaylasis: Probably Not Scum.

Thaiboxershorts

Thoughts: He's putting out some pretty good points there, some of them confusing though.

Why he might be scum:
[QUOTE=Thaiboxershorts] As for Jenter, well... I dunno. The anti-Jenter arguments kind of hold water. Criticizing lack of substance while acknowledging his own lack of substance, the possible "feigning ignorance" thing that Eroto pointed out. But I'm just not getting a scum vibe from Jenter. I can't really give an objective reason why, though I'll go back through his posts and see if I can find something. [/QUOTE]
Looking at this it summed up to me possibly as "Jenter's Acting Really scummy but I'm pretty sure he's not scum." I don't understand. It's obvious some vibes have to occur from his scummy behavior.

His bandwagoning has also worried me a bit. He jumped on the soup bandwagon and also got off quickly.

Why He might not be scum: He's been pretty active and has not done anything close to lurking

Anaylasis: I still have an FoS on him.

Questions for Thaiboxershorts:
Why did you unvote soupfly so fast?

I have to go, but I'll finish this later.

[Gatorguy91]

Sorry Thai, You did not Jump on the bandwagon quickly,

you jumped OFF it quickly.

My Mistake.

Continuing on:

*Credit goes to Oman for the Format*

Oman

Thoughts: He's been defending me. I liked his style with the for and against lists.

Why He might be scum: It looks likei I'm the VI. Town idea: Always lynch the VI, but he seems to try to keep the VI around. Hmmm....

Why He might not be scum: He always seems to have materials with good, protown thoughts.

Question(s):
Do You

really

think it's scummy that i stole your format?

Just kidding.

Jenter

Thoughts: Short posts every once in a while.

Why He might be scum: Lurking, Lurking, Lurking. He's had very many posts none of them having much content and then pointing his finger at me for doing the exact same thing.

Why he might not scum: At least He's posting a lot.

Questions:
Jenter, who do you find most scummy now?

Also:

Niv I think is Town

Langley and Zakk need replacements

I have no read on Erotomachia or Erg0

[Gatorguy91]

I sware I'm the VI.

[Gatorguy91]

Yes..

MOD: Vote Count Please?

[Gatorguy91]

My post was more to say to soupfly that in that situation I am the VI, not scum.

My Role is NOT VI. I'm not sure I want to claim.

[Gatorguy91]

Vote Jenter

Niv brought up some great points.

[Gatorguy91]

GATOR: I'd like to know what your hypothesis is now. Who do you think is the scum pair(/trio?)? Where do you rate everyone in scumminess?

scum trio:

Jenter, Thaiboxershorts (either that or he's just REALLY Paranoid) or Haut boy, Streetflo

[Gatorguy91]

GATOR: I'd like to know what your hypothesis is now. Who do you think is the scum pair(/trio?)? Where do you rate everyone in scumminess?

scum trio:

Jenter, Thaiboxershorts (either that or he's just REALLY Paranoid) or Haut boy, Streetflo

Why Streeflo?

Streetflo's been playing "Under the radar" not posting much material but posting, i find that a bit suspiscious.

[Gatorguy91]

GATOR: I'd like to know what your hypothesis is now. Who do you think is the scum pair(/trio?)? Where do you rate everyone in scumminess?

scum trio:

Jenter, Thaiboxershorts (either that or he's just REALLY Paranoid) or Haut boy, Streetflo

What is your reasoning behind this?

Its obvious of Jenter Hipocracy's and content after being under fire for not posting mouch content. Thaiboxershorts made a post saying i had lied trying to prove him as scum when i just made a mistake, so that's why i said or he is paranoid. Haut, YOU haven't done anything suspiscious but Zakk_status made a pointless bandwagon, and i explained Streetflo.

[Gatorguy91]

4-6... that's enough for me to claim.

I am a

Mason

. If the town would like to claim my partner i shall.

[Gatorguy91]

woah, forgot to remove my vote on jenter

unvote jenter

[Gatorguy91]

I will only vote Niv if Jenter decides that if Niv comes up town Oman is tonight's NK.

[Gatorguy91]

K.

Vote Niv

hammered.

[Gatorguy91]

Hold the lynching. By my count there are only 5 votes on Niv.

Votes for Niv that I counted: Soupfly, Oman, Jenter, JimmyR, Gator

Can somebody verify my count?

Yes only 5.

Erotomachia said Streetflo was voting Niv

[Gatorguy91]

Haut Boy, Do you have any thoughts?

[Gatorguy91]

But I am not, I Really want to hear from Haut boy first. I'd like you to eventually hammer, but

unvote

to make sure.

[Gatorguy91]

But I am not, I Really want to hear from Haut boy first. I'd like you to eventually hammer, but

unvote

to make sure.

Why? You voted for Niv before and even thought you were hammering him yourself. What can one person who has made no contriubtion so far have to say that will change everyones opinions?

I'm not that eager to lynch really but this is just an unneccesary holdup.

I can admit that what i did before was a VERY stupid move. I should have considered the fact that everyone needs to check in and drop opinions before we lynch.

[Gatorguy91]

Going to wait to think about Niv's Claim...

[Gatorguy91]

Vote Count?

[Gatorguy91]

EBWOP: It's 5-5-0... So.. Please Don't hate me if I'm wrong, I'm sorry if so!!!

Vote Oman

[Gatorguy91]

Vote Thai

[Gatorguy91]

BUMP

[Gatorguy91]

Where is Maz?

[Gatorguy91]

Aw, man. I think i know who the scum is. Go town!