Gistou (Over!)

[Salt Squad]

What do you think about Expe and Song of Ice and Fire?

what do

you

think of us ?

~Ice

Nulltown
I don't think most of what you've said has been AI but the stuff that didn't involve Expe looked townish.

-SC

us was me and expe. I'm more curious about your expe read

~Ice

Oh I thought you were referring to your hydra with us
I think he's town, I don't think he'd be this engaged and aggressive as scum

-SC

[Expedience]

shutting scumhunting by overfocusing on probability discussion.

Clearly not a thing.

[A Song of Ice and Fire]

can you link me to a proper alignment indicative discussion in your opinion?

I think discussing the motivation behind people's moves is more relevant to alignment, than discussing the probability of being culted disagree?

what do you think about the motivations behind BBmola flavor claim
the motivations of Tom questioning mola
and the motivations of people talking about how bad was it /or wasn't it.

talk about motivations with me.

~Ice

[A Song of Ice and Fire]

I think he's town, I don't think he'd be this engaged and aggressive as scum

where is this meta coming from?

~Ice

[Salt Squad]

shutting scumhunting by overfocusing on probability discussion.

Clearly not a thing.

^
P-edit: there was a blitz he was scum in where he was very out of it and not really interacting with anyone iirc, can't remember the exact game
-SC

[Cephrir]

I think that Tim's scum, and BBMolla's town.

Why do you think Tim is scum? I think they're town

Because they seem to have overblown bbmolla's claim out of proportion

It seems pretty in-character to me for Iec (I assume Iec is posting) to be concerned about optimal play

[Cephrir]

Luna what do you think about the people who were talking about the probability stuff?

I think if they're town, they should be discussing alignments instead of probability and if they are discussing probability they should explain how it relates to finding alignment.
If they are scum like i think Exp is, then they are doing fine by shutting scumhunting by overfocusing on probability discussion.

the point of the probability discussion, while it got excessive, was to determine whether bb's play was likely town motivated.

as much as i don't agree with the conclusion that he's scum for his actions, it has more merit than most early game discussions i've seen

[Luna Fox]

what do you think about the motivations behind BBmola flavor claim
the motivations of Tom questioning mola
and the motivations of people talking about how bad was it /or wasn't it.

I think Molla just wanted to let info out regardless of it's veracity to get reactions.
Tom got overly paranoid for it "increasing chances of being culted" i think that was scummy.
Can't really be sure on how bad is or isn't, we can be certain of the strength other roles may have or how they may compare to Molla's role, but i dont think anything alignment indicative will be found in such a discussion.

@Exp: How come you havent commented on me not townhunting yet? Are you even really paying attention to anything im doing?

[Cephrir]

Tom got overly paranoid for it "increasing chances of being culted" i think that was scummy.

Why, Ms. Motivations?

[Luna Fox]

the point of the probability discussion, while it got excessive, was to determine whether bb's play was likely town motivated.

as much as i don't agree with the conclusion that he's scum for his actions, it has more merit than most early game discussions i've seen

Well all i remember seeing is something about being like 3.5% chance of being converted or whatever and i found that kind of discussion useless for figuring out alignments.

[Luna Fox]

Tom got overly paranoid for it "increasing chances of being culted" i think that was scummy.

Why, Ms. Motivations?

I think his motivation was most likely to sling mud in the direction of Molla.

[Expedience]

FA is seemingly acting as a mediator here and I think it's scummy.

[Salt Squad]

Ceph why is Tim town?

-sc

[A Song of Ice and Fire]

mediator

You already are assuming I'm mafia and your trying to fit my game in your scum illusion.

Your beyond help in this topic. as I said whenever you tried to read me and not just shitting around I'm here to answer.

~Ice

[Expedience]

@Exp: How come you havent commented on me not townhunting yet? Are you even really paying attention to anything im doing?

???

the point of the probability discussion, while it got excessive, was to determine whether bb's play was likely town motivated.

as much as i don't agree with the conclusion that he's scum for his actions, it has more merit than most early game discussions i've seen

Well all i remember seeing is something about being like 3.5% chance of being converted or whatever and i found that kind of discussion useless for figuring out alignments.

Was clearly semi-serious, at lesat I thought it was.

If Tim is "slinging mud at molla" then somehow he managed to make it look like he was just scumreading him.

[Expedience]

mediator

You already are assuming I'm mafia and your trying to fit my game in your scum illusion.

Your beyond help in this topic. as I said whenever you tried to read me and not just shitting around I'm here to answer.

~Ice

I'm not sure what that means but are you saying that I'm scum?

[Cephrir]

Tom got overly paranoid for it "increasing chances of being culted" i think that was scummy.

Why, Ms. Motivations?

I think his motivation was most likely to sling mud in the direction of Molla.

Hm.

I think it's potentially having the effect of causing others, if they exist, not to do the same thing molla did. I also don't think it's super likely they expected to get Molla lynched off this/at all, as people tend to townread actions like what he's done.

FA is seemingly acting as a mediator here and I think it's scummy.

I've liked her tone, but having seen some of her play before I don't think I'm going to be great at reading her.

Ceph why is Tim town?

-sc

I'm quoting this so I remember to answer it.

[A Song of Ice and Fire]

I like luna answers. need to see some of her older games.

I like cephir for town.

pedit : you know that percentages are bad , right ? by more flavor claims scums will figure out how they can use their own probable mechanics (hidden if exists or public ) so it matters. scums will have a clear map for playing this as we go forward if this attitude remains.

No more idiot flavor claim please. stop advertising like it has no bad effects.

~Ice

[Salt Squad]

Luna are you an alt?

-sc

[Cephrir]

"Are you aware there is a cult in the game"
"But what does it mean?"

+

"Please give region"
"Why'd you do that bro"

I liked this post. I haven't fact-checked to see whether it's a valid criticism of Wayward Thinker, but it's a post made by someone who's honestly analyzing the game. To be fair, it presumably being multiball makes this less important, but town will still be more interested in putting themselves out there and having strong opinions.

But I'm no closer to understanding why, if you're town, you made someone else's chances of conversion that much more probable.

If you really are having trouble following the most basic facets of what I'm communicating to you, I'm just going to assume that you were not thinking like a townie with your non-human race and be done with you.

p-edit:

Yes

LMFAO wHo cAREAS HAHA Xd

I do. Well I did.

There's at least 3 factions that have a 1-shot recruiting ability, and the cult probably is multiple shot but I can't imagine them not being able to recruit humans.

Do Bulletproofs claim so their role becomes worthless? No, because that's stupid.

But by all means, continue to troll. Maybe more sods like Expedience will buy that

Okay, but how does that make BBMolla scum rather than just bad town?

Do you have any experience playing with BBmolla? He's not bad town. you can say maybe he's performed badly as town sometimes, but he isn't bad town. 2ndly, he has a carefree attitude as all alignments really. And he's done speculative plays before as scum before as well.

@Bbmolla: Perhaps you don't have the same kind of "how to play a role" sense as I do, but that kind of play really stretches my limits of credulity. In any case my metric for scumminess won't be defined as just that, so if your day play is satisfactory it will do a lot to help your claim

These posts all show a consistent and coherent line of thought even if you don't agree with it. Opinions are not shifting in the wind. They make sense if you first assume the player in question cares about this sort of thing which they clearly do

obviously it's only page 6 but that's sufficient for me at this time

[Luna Fox]

Luna are you an alt?

-sc

No (why does this question come up every game)

[A Song of Ice and Fire]

I'm not sure what that means but are you saying that I'm scum?

yeah lets see who was accusing me of not being able to read.

nope , I didn't say that. I feel your an idiot town who made a tunnel at page 3 and will be trapped inside it for the rest of the game . like the 28 players listed in my notepad ; I will write your nae down at endgame in that list proving in your face that you suck at least in reading me

and asking you to back off cuase I have a unique playstyle and a decent play *which although so many people called pure luck so far* which will provide results ; unlike your play.

I don't have any reads on you yet. and very likely I'm going to delay making one to see others stuff. your a type I can't interact directly with. i prefer to read you when your out of your shell and based on your interactions

~Ice

[Cephrir]

Luna are you an alt?

-sc

No (why does this question come up every game)

Why do I recall otherwise?

[Salt Squad]

Luna are you an alt?

-sc

No (why does this question come up every game)

Yes u are don't lie.

unless you changed this account to ur main instead of ur other one.

[Luna Fox]

unless you changed this account to ur main instead of ur other one.

That would be the most accurate interpretation.
And i said multiple times in the past that was my intention, so i don't know why this comes as a surprise.