Gistou (Over!)

[davesaz]

So basically i win with town but im not explictly town then?
The win con looked like normal town win con to me.

there's no functional difference between being town and winning with the town

Im confused by what BBMolla's going on about.

There is nothing that states winning with humans = town.

I interpreted the setup posts to imply that there may be multiple factions with "when all threats eliminated" type wincons. They would all be "town" in a loosely defined way.

[Luna Fox]

At least one town faction means the possibility of multiball town, does it not?

it's not a possibllity, it's a certainty, it's been advertized as multi factional in the signups thread.
But that's what not what my post meant.
Well either way i could literally have gotten this info from a mod fake role pm, so please dont townread me for all this.

[Luna Fox]

Oh wait you meant multiball town, in that case i disagree

[Luna Fox]

Actually or not?
I dont even know.
I don't even know how would another town faction's role PM even be, i interpreted the post that among all factions there would be 1 town, but now that you meantioned there could be more than 1 town? this is giving me a headache.

[Titus]

Housey/Wakey poo, are you scum?

Pedit let me post.

Of course we are.

You know I'm a lightning rod for scumreads over silly shit.

But you said something untrue to me. That makes me sad. I don't wanna be angry sat.

Where?

When you said Frozen wasn't emotional where I townread them

[Cephrir]

I was reminding Molla who I was in the last post.

am i supposed to care

Was I supposed to care whether you care when I said it?

it sounded an awful lot like the intent of post 346 was to defend against my dislike of your post. so it looks like you do care. was i wrong?

[Cane + Able]

Actually or not?
I dont even know.
I don't even know how would another town faction's role PM even be, i interpreted the post that among all factions there would be 1 town, but now that you meantioned there could be more than 1 town? this is giving me a headache.

That's exactly how I read it.

I think humans comprise one town faction, and there is a non-human town faction that is allied with the human town.

The op spells out the possibility of multiball town, and

Robb

Molla's claim sets up the framework for my theory.

[Luna Fox]

I think humans comprise one town faction, and there is a non-human town faction that is allied with the human town.

Wouldnt it that case make both town either way?
Does it even matter if both win together and are both uninformed?
Why separate the notion of both.

[Cephrir]

i think further speculation on multiple towns could reveal people as human or not human and should therefore be avoided thank you have a nice day

[No Retreat]

Should we all claim the checks we picked to limit shenanigans? Discuss

[Cane + Able]

Housey/Wakey poo, are you scum?

Pedit let me post.

Of course we are.

You know I'm a lightning rod for scumreads over silly shit.

But you said something untrue to me. That makes me sad. I don't wanna be angry sat.

Where?

When you said Frozen wasn't emotional where I townread them

That's not what I said, and I don't understand why you think that.

I said you townread them prior to the post you quoted, which seemed odd to me that you used a later post to justify the read.

[Luna Fox]

i think further speculation on multiple towns could reveal people as human or not human and should therefore be avoided thank you have a nice day

I agree and I will stop.

[Titus]

Housey/Wakey poo, are you scum?

Pedit let me post.

Of course we are.

You know I'm a lightning rod for scumreads over silly shit.

But you said something untrue to me. That makes me sad. I don't wanna be angry sat.

Where?

When you said Frozen wasn't emotional where I townread them

That's not what I said, and I don't understand why you think that.

I said you townread them prior to the post you quoted, which seemed odd to me that you used a later post to justify the read.

Yeah, no. I mean what I say and say what I mean.

Just so I get this clear, you're claiming that I townread Frozen prior to the post where I claimed to. Given you know my tendency to call a spade a spade, why would you think that?

[Salt Squad]

Luna is town

[dramonic]

Should we all claim the checks we picked to limit shenanigans? Discuss

...No?
That only favors the scum?

[No Retreat]

How does it favor scum?

[dramonic]

They know the spread of relevant info within their group, they know who's dangerous to them.
Also some powers are obviously stronger than others, so that's painting a giant target on their back.

[RAM]

Should we all claim the checks we picked to limit shenanigans? Discuss

...No?
That only favors the scum?

Yep. All it does is force the people who get multiple pieces of information to lie and say they only get one, and then causes all this bullshit later on when they have to actually claim they know THIS information for reals, and just casts doubt on pseudo cop claims for people, basically.

I get the idea, that it keeps scum from sharing information and attributing it all to one slot, or switching up claims when convenient, but like...the people who get lots of information SHOULDN'T be claiming it until it's relevant, which means there will be no discernible difference between scum shenanigans and optimal play.

-Cerb

[No Retreat]

I'm thinking along the lines of...like if I claim my hometown or region or whatever it is and Salt says no he's lying but if we all claim now it limits the potential of fake gultiy things like that.

[No Retreat]

fair point I guess

[Cane + Able]

Sigh...

[Luna Fox]

RAM maybe town, No Retreat also maybe town.

[Cephrir]

RAM maybe town, No Retreat also maybe town.

+1, I think.

[Titus]

The way we would do that is pick one that you'd always get as a multiple recipient. Not a fan of the idea though as I think the general tenor of Cerb's post is right. Mass claiming = baaaddd.

[Franky]

/confirm