578 by Stormblade intensifies my town read of them. Reasoning makes sense, it's full of actual content and there's a 72% chance it's Town-motivated.
I don't understand how Luna is scummy. Exped's reasoning is shit. At this point her actions have been to direct the Town away from a pointless discussion and to ask clarifying questions of people. She's putting the town on a productive path and trying to figure the game out. My comment that "Luna is our FRIEND" had two-fold meaning:
1. to imply that she's my townread. I don't see how you'd be confused by that.
2. her signature actually says, "Everyone's your friend"
581 by exped is awful. Spelling, formatting, grammar or whatever other errors make sense. Outright saying scummy things isn't excusable by "I'm tired
"
Cephrir has similar reads to mine, but it's bugging me. I don't like
580 because even though I disagree with Exped, it's not just the fact he disagrees that make him feel scummy. Ceph is making less effort to understand Exped's POV than he is focussing on the fact that he apparently thinks Exped is just wrong. Town are wrong all the time. Scumreading people because you think they're wrong is dumb.
I can't stand
604 - as a general rule I zone out and can't be fucked dealing with meta and delving into other games. If someone wants to give a specific example from another game they can go and get it themselves. I'll still disregard it but it annoys me to no end to be told to go and look at another game. Explain your actions in THIS game without sending Town on a multi-game-interpretation circlejerk. Also the statement, "it's not important what my reasons are" is just setting Wayward up to make a whole bunch of shit reasons for reads and expect people to not question them. Sorry, not letting you do that.
VOTE: Wayward Thinker
@MathBlade post
608 duly noted - but can you point out what you see to be a lack of content? As far as I'm concerned I'm sharing reads and pressing people on their opinions/thoughts, with the numbers for flavour. You seem to be implying that I'm just throwing out arbitrary numbers with no meaning - show me what you're talking about.
Following on from that, Ceph pointed that out in
623 - I'm wary of Ceph sheeping me here for the same sentiments I expressed about his post 580. He likes me just because we seem to agree - that's not a good reason to townread someone imo.
Post
629 is crap. I read this as having a lot of potential for sheeping on MathBlade's
608 - where am I sheeping? Show me. Planning ahead? Who doesn't? Are you saying that you don't read into the interactions and their context between people in the game and think about how they might play out? Surely if someone died right now and flipped scum, you'd have an idea of where that'd lead you next right? If I was doing full-blown scum-association crap and trying to pick the scum-team, I'd understand your skepticism. I don't understand it from this POV though because I'm clearly not playing the scum-association game.
Post
671 - Yes you've watched me play a game as Town and also as Scum. My first and second games ever. Being that it was about 2 months ago that I played my last Town game (this is my 4th game overall, 1 as Town, 2 as Scum) I've obviously changed quite a bit. Also you mention in this post that what I'm doing here is something you've not seen me do either as Town OR Scum - so what's with the scumread? Shouldn't it be NAI? Why don't you focus on the other stuff I'm posting instead?
Post
683 There's a 64% chance that Mastin has a crush on me and gives me special italics treatment in the Vote Count.
Post
688 What am I hiding? What's not clear to you? There's an 84% chance you're confused Town not understanding why I'm posting numbers.
735 I don't really understand what Exped doesn't understand about
590. He's asking you if you generally think players putting in a lack of effort into posts is a scumread in your opinion, because that's what you specifically mentioned not liking in
546...also wtf: did you just do the
exact same thing
in
751?
@Expedience in
747 you say you'd prefer to lurk. How come?
770 can we not have, "I'm tired
" as a defence? I made a joke that I say less sig-worthy things when I'm not sleep-deprived, but I find it fully acceptable if people find things I say or do scummy when I'm sleepy and I see no reason why I'd be somehow "more scummy" just because I was tired. Motivation of figuring out game and helping town is still there.
771 is cute. I hereby
deny
so that you can tunnel me all game because this is scummy-af and the perfect cherry on top of your ice-cream sundae of, "I don't need to reason it doesn't matter!" if and when it's successful and I flip Town there's an 90% probability that you'll be next lynch and I'm perfectly okay with a 1-for-1 Town/Scum trade. Tunnel away baby. You're my highest scumread and I'd happily die if it means you get lynched next.
775 -
There's like 4 more pages now. Trying to catch up again. There's a 69% chance that I'll post in the next 30 minutes.
