Fight me
In post 26, Something_Smart wrote:oh hey I finally rolled town in a large
but now I have 23 slots to sort...
I'll probably just sheep people who are actually good. (Which is like, everybody. Except me.)
i have this idea that what the fuck are you going on about half the game hasn't even postedIn post 60, McMenno wrote:it's not about the gameplay it's about nuking people
okay I have this idea that the scumteam have one plant that's against total war
No, I volunteered, being respectable and keeping the peace is my natural roleIn post 64, Spiffeh wrote:Ceph did your scum team elect you as the honorary "respectable player" to try and stop Total War to save your scumbuddies from complete annihilation?
![:]](./images/smilies/icon_smiling.png "Cheerful Smile"){kind=icon}
dang he nailed us
I mean I'm here bc hippo told me to be here i barely read the rules firstIn post 70, Nukebringer wrote:Who joins this game only to wimp out when it's time for nuking?In post 57, Cephrir wrote:I have only read the first post once but it seems like total war isn't the best. It's more fun, but night actions + getting actual gameplay to then nuke based on seems better. Convince me I guess.
Embrace the MADness.
realistically there is zero chance of this happening.In post 76, Cheetory6 wrote:I suppose we could use the dayvigs like extra lynches?
In which case could not effectively do like.. five lynches a day or more?
town stupidity probably. you give a guy a dayvig he's gonna be a crazy person. i do not claim to be immune to this effect.In post 86, Cheetory6 wrote:Like, what's to stop town from just powerlynching through the playerlist with nukes?
Time limitations?
The practical answer is no one wants to.In post 91, Cheetory6 wrote:Why not? We could hash out deadlines and be organized about it.
I'm probably barking up the wrong tree with this game and playerlist but I mean, theoretically this setup could be easy as fuck to basically give town so many more lynches than they normally get.
This. It can also be used to curtail town stupidity. It occurs to me that I'm thinking troops re-happen every night, they do right?In post 111, Spiffeh wrote:I think the nuke doctor is way more useful than 3/10
Well, nights with investigative powers in play and no scum kill seem pretty thoroughly good, that's where I'm at at this point. Even if you don't see the value in having a couple normal day phases not marred by insanity, which I do.In post 114, Spiffeh wrote:Are we still allowed to discuss stuff during DEFCON 1?
Because if so I see no reason for TOTAL WAR to not happen
How could anyone fail to catch that?In post 117, RedCoyote wrote:Gross post. All sorts of commie pings coming off of it. That GiF caught this as well makes me feel good about him.In post 26, Something_Smart wrote:oh hey I finally rolled town in a large
but now I have 23 slots to sort...
I'll probably just sheep people who are actually good. (Which is like, everybody. Except me.
I have a feeling we are not going to get alongI'm also liking Cheetory so far as he seems relatively analytical compared to the rest of the players that are posting lots.
I think the odds are small that a town player with Strategic Missle Defense is alive in late game and is effectively stopping nukes on the correct player. Doctor is already a relatively weak card depending on the circumstances, when you limit him to just defending nukes, eh, I just think it's a very situational role.[/quote]In post 111, Spiffeh wrote:I think the nuke doctor is way more useful than 3/10
Did you think I quoted him and posted emoticons for fun, or...?
Not that it really matters, but why?In post 144, Spiffeh wrote:I meant that scum would prefer no TOTAL WAR to TOTAL WARIn post 138, Cheetory6 wrote:Are you actually standing behind that stance in practice? Because I would expect scum to be pretending to be cautious in doing something like this, not to actually try to oppose Total War for some mechanical purpose.
The façade they put on for the thread is obviously a different story, but I'd expect them to latch onto the insecurities town players have about TOTAL WAR and ultimately try to get it opposed
Why?In post 158, RedCoyote wrote:I totally sympathize with this. I'm really not out to be the heavy; I don't have the personality for it. The history of 3.0 needs to be put out there though.In post 149, Cheetory6 wrote:If this were a tryhard group, I would be voting no Total War.
That isn't the case so I'm feeling kind of meh.
The temptation to nuke mastina, Something Smart and MoI though... hard to fight that.
You aren't supposed to have trouble remembering your own reads. Buddy much, etc.In post 159, RedCoyote wrote:Spiff, I'm getting town vibes from you despite our disagreement here. Don't let me forget I said this.
Thank you, tbhIn post 172, xRECKONERx wrote::3In post 134, Spiffeh wrote:I think we'd get a lot more out of flips from nukes and troop selection than we would out of 2 weeks of talking
And it's not like we lose all discussion anyway
Scum are more likely to dislike the random element of TOTAL WAR and oppose it
VOTE: AGAINST TOTAL WAR
this admittedly does not really sound like your sort of thingIn post 184, xRECKONERx wrote:sry all players didn't agree to total war, your votes are meaningless, prepare for slow trudging bullshit
In post 163, Lady Lambdadelta wrote:Mastin's scum.
I agree with Lady Lambdadelta. Pretend I bothered to find the sign holding smiley dude.In post 167, Lady Lambdadelta wrote:Oh and RedCoyote needs nukes to the face before endgame for his current posting. Could be town but it's just essentially quoting a bunch of stuff from 3.0 and trying to make himself look useful.
I can dig that.In post 206, xRECKONERx wrote:but making people angry IS 100% my sort of thingIn post 203, Cephrir wrote:this admittedly does not really sound like your sort of thing
It's global nuclear war anyways. Probably not much anymore.In post 211, Nukebringer wrote:What will happen to timon if you do that?In post 209, Cephrir wrote:I am nuking myself discuss
~Fire
I feel like I've been in this movie before.In post 212, Spiffeh wrote:This is scum Firebringer too btw
The fact that LLD scumreading you did not spawn a self referential wall is very worrisomeIn post 218, mastina wrote:Btw I actually have gained reads in spite of not reading the first few pages. People here feel ridiculously transparent. (Well not all, I'll never claim to read one or two of the players in here, but some legit are seriously scum or obviously town.)
The main issue I'm having here is on whether I should tell you or not.
Because while telling you is technically pro-town...it also ruins the mood, kills the fun, and is an actual ~town~ thing to do and thus not the TROLL thing to do.
Nah.In post 320, Accountant wrote:dayne is probably scum
She apparently actually did it last time or something thoughIn post 329, xRECKONERx wrote:TOWN
mastina
cheetory
Something-Smart
hiplop
Cephrir
SCUM
SpyreX
Untrod Tripod
k that's all ive got for now
no clue what to think about LLD atm. inclined to believe mastin's read but idk. the whole GIMME THIS USELESS THING SO I CAN BE A CODEBREAKER AND REAL TOWN HELPER seems forced and actor like and ugh.
p.edit: i have no idea what you're talking about
Re mastin I will try to remember not to ignore this possibilityIn post 335, xRECKONERx wrote:i sure wish i could in a way that wasnt essentially lolgutIn post 331, Accountant wrote:are you gonna explain your reads on UT and spyrex and mastina
spyrex feels off compared to his old townself but that could be rust
mr tripod is playing similarly to how i remember him rolling me as scum one time + i also think he's smarter/better than he's playing right now. he's going after easy policy bait like a hungry dog
mastina's play is so fucking bizarre for her that i just cant see it as anything other than town trolling. mastin-scum i think would feel a bit more indebted to a team than to play this stupidly.
You as in weIn post 350, SpyreX wrote:Nope guys you can only launch 1 per day not land one per dayIn post 347, SpyreX wrote:I don't think that's the intent more a dont wait 72 hrs
That's quite a theory you've got there and would require a fuck load more planning ahead than I've ever done in my entire life but ok budIn post 377, Accountant wrote:Implying scum read that he can pull out later to say he was scum reading Dayne all along but was apparently "too easily manipulated" to *really* scumread him while also having plausible deniability while also trying to cover it up with a cavalier attitude
Cephrir needs to die
Omg usIn post 380, Ser Arthur Dayne wrote:In post 24, Papa Zito wrote:Getting 2 lynches before the mafia start killing seems like a plus? Help me out.So I thought Cephrir the first one to do the "guys stop being hyped up about total war lets think logically" and I generally think the first one to do that is town. But actually Zito did that.In post 57, Cephrir wrote: I have only read the first post once but it seems like total war isn't the best. It's more fun, but night actions + getting actual gameplay to then nuke based on seems better. Convince me I guess.
Now his post is looking bad cuz it looks like makes him look like he's contributing without actually pointing having new insight or a fresh idea.
Do you spell it you or uIn post 395, Accountant wrote:What does this mean i am entitled millenial who only knows text speechIn post 391, SpyreX wrote:Yeaaaa i like the gusto accountant. Thats fine jib cuts but
It's not a literal cut you know. It's a sailing thing.In post 396, SpyreX wrote:I like the cut of your jib but i think the knife needs a better home
hotIn post 410, hiplop wrote:thats exactly what i was doingIn post 403, Accountant wrote:Not to be crude but it kinda looked like you were sucking UT's dick there
i feel like youre expecting this to be a Unique Special Snowflake Read sorry to disappoint youIn post 418, McMenno wrote:on page 6 and I think redcoyote is scum currently
no it's not because he's against total war
cheetory is town maybe
???In post 482, Ser Arthur Dayne wrote:How do people glance at this and think these reads are okay and not call out their bullshit.In post 443, Nahdia wrote: Not liking Dayne. 372 was just bad IMO. There was nothing about the post Spiff made that pinged me in the slightest so I really don't understand such a forceful call-out like that. Reads as just fake to me.
Disagree with Accountant that 375 is bad. I make posts like this as town.
Recks' 321 is needlessly defensive and 430 bugs me. I make flippant early reads on really minor stuff too but that just feels a bittoosimple a post to form a read on.
your mother was a town.In post 498, Spiffeh wrote:especially since she's town
so he's gif? okIn post 507, Spiffeh wrote:I could also see scum!GIF
He's around enough to make a few fringe comments and have somewhat of a presence but he's not making any "waves" and seems to be escaping everyone's radars
which is a sweet spot I'd expect scum to seek out given the nature of this game
i don't know what part of this obvious fact needs to be explainedIn post 536, RedCoyote wrote:Last game, you mean? Explain.
zzzIn post 575, McMenno wrote:☑ lld scumenlighten meIn post 557, RedCoyote wrote:[Town]-----Cheet--Nahdia-GiF---Grey---MoI-Nukebringer-Ceph-Spiff--PZ--Reck-Ircher--hiplop-Fate-Spy[∙]-LLD-Accountant-Dayne--mastina--Errant--McMenno----SS------------[Scum]
nonsequitur.In post 582, McMenno wrote:patience, patienceIn post 433, Cephrir wrote:hotIn post 410, hiplop wrote:thats exactly what i was doingIn post 403, Accountant wrote:Not to be crude but it kinda looked like you were sucking UT's dick therei feel like youre expecting this to be a Unique Special Snowflake Read sorry to disappoint youIn post 418, McMenno wrote:on page 6 and I think redcoyote is scum currently
no it's not because he's against total war
cheetory is town maybe
cheetory is adorable and i just want to take him home with me
Slayers gambit!!!!!!In post 694, GuyInFreezer wrote:There's this #4 too but it's kinda personal thing.
I enjoy reaction testing a lot in the most perverted (No, not sexually perverted) way possible, but I can't seem to find the purpose of reaction testing with stuff like #26.
Like, if he was actually reaction testing with that post, what exactly was he trying to fish and what kind of reaction was he looking for while doing that?
In my limited experience, it isn'tIn post 711, GuyInFreezer wrote:I don't. But I'm expecting it to be in very high accuracy because they know each other well.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_b ... ted_StatesIn post 736, GreyICE wrote:None really. The game just started. And if you think I care about pregame posturing when nothing is at stake and no one can die, you're... accountant.
Whatever it is, I am slow.In post 738, mastina wrote:The mastina you want is already here. I mean, I'm PMing reads as of this quote to the mod, because I'm not sharing them in here (I didn't think it felt appropriate), but I already told the mod yesterday (and told the mod to post said thing to spoiled players because I'll be pissed if that wasn't shared) exactly what I am doing.In post 500, Cephrir wrote:i want to see the mastina i know.
I know you're town here (so I'm not worried you're missing it), but I was honestly a bit surprised.
Of all the people here, I thought you'd be the first one to figure it out.
I AM the mastina you know.
Reconcile that with what I've posted thusfar.
I think this could lead you astray quite often, especially in this player list.In post 767, MagnaofIllusion wrote:Given that my reads don’t line up with yours and your reasoning is “gut” the first place my mind goes is scum faking reads.
ThisIn post 879, Ser Arthur Dayne wrote:I don't understand why anyone should be thinking about a plan for the dayvigs or forming a bloc or anything right now (other than obv pming the mod with a choice for role/nuke - but do that in the privacy of your thoughts while watching tv or the much more superior anime).
We have two days to go without nukes. Stop the dumb lining up of events. Treat the game in a more spontaneous matter.