greyice you are calling me out on defending that SS opening post considering that he also said it wasn't scummy end of D1.
cephrir is a firm townread based on what little i know-- a dedicated dive might change that, but i don't expect it to. i dont think mastina is scum.
A SAD lynch is unexpected to me-- i dont find people saying that SAD follows from SS scum on D1. Remember that keely threw out Nukebringer as a name following from SS scum but i don't remember anything else (also, I believe that keely's stance on nukebringer has been inconsistent in a way that i don't think has a good justification). Keely D2- says SS -> SAD is bad, something which doesn't swing things either way but I think it was unmentioned D1.
I don't think that Keely is scum as of now but there is no way he deserves the powertown belief that so many people seem to hold.
Magna's push on SAD is very town in a vacuum (not factoring in how magna usually behaves because i dont know that very well) to me from how i see it. he comes out of the gate guns blazing, he's excited, he's got something good and is ready to push this.
Looking at how Spiffeh stayed far away from the SAD wagon: I think that scum as a whole is content to let a mislynch happen (and I think that the people pushing the lynch are town). I see Cephrir talking about RC looking good bc of SS as reasonable, but I don't agree at all.
GI, talk to me-- D3 to come later
