The War to End All Freaktowns: GAME OVER

[Flameaxe]

Apparently we don't.

[Kinetic]

It appears we have a delayed announcement of who is town or scum, and won't know until the next morning.

[YagamiLight]

That's items and shops, so not whether they are town or scum. I mean look at scotmany, we were not told his alignment, only his item and shop.

[Kinetic]

Ummm... Scotmany and Kilroy were town. Pay attention YL.

[YagamiLight]

Wow, forgot about that article, but even so, as a newspaper article, we cannot put complete trust into it without knowing which paper it came from.

[JDodge]

Wow, forgot about that article, but even so, as a newspaper article, we cannot put complete trust into it without knowing which paper it came from.

You can't necessarily trust it anyways

[YagamiLight]

Well, we could if it came from the Freaktown Sun-Times couldn't we?

[Flameaxe]

But we don't know that, so why keep discussing?

[JDodge]

Well, we could if it came from the Freaktown Sun-Times couldn't we?

Not necessarily

[Battle Mage]

rofl. I'd just like to point out that this town is thicker than 2 short planks.

SRSLY.

Most of you havent even bothered to pay attention to the game mechanics, so frankly, it aint looking good for us.

Ill probably show up to read some time, but i wont be defending myself against people who are clearly bandwagonning on absolutely appalling logic.

BM

[Kinetic]

I don't know BM, they have valid points. It is true that not everyone is paying as much attention to this game as they should, but then again your own actions are glaring in hypocracy. It wouldn't take a large amount of attention to notice them.

About the newspaper articles: As far as I'm concerned I cannot imagine this game to NOT have a way to figure out if our lynch targets are town or scum. I can understand where we might not know the alignment of the night kill, but it would be literally impossible for the town to win if we don't know if we ever hit scum or not. As such, I'm going to take the alignment reveals at face value until proven otherwise. A delayed reveal is much more likely than absolutely no reveal, and is also completely in line with how this game has so far progressed.

[Mariyta]

rofl. I'd just like to point out that this town is thicker than 2 short planks.

SRSLY.

Most of you havent even bothered to pay attention to the game mechanics, so frankly, it aint looking good for us.

Ill probably show up to read some time, but i wont be defending myself against people who are clearly bandwagonning on absolutely appalling logic.

BM

Typical BM defense. Full of insults, with no logic to be had. Why don't you get yourself replaced if you're that disinterested?

[Battle Mage]

rofl. I'd just like to point out that this town is thicker than 2 short planks.

SRSLY.

Most of you havent even bothered to pay attention to the game mechanics, so frankly, it aint looking good for us.

Ill probably show up to read some time, but i wont be defending myself against people who are clearly bandwagonning on absolutely appalling logic.

BM

Typical BM defense. Full of insults, with no logic to be had. Why don't you get yourself replaced if you're that disinterested?

it was hardly a post designed to be logical. If anything, i was hoping some bright spark would note the didactic tone, and (god forbid) ask what the bad logic i was discussing was.
As for getting myself replaced, i figure getting lynched is about the equivalent, except there are 2 reasons why getting lynched is better than requesting replacement.

1. It would be cruel to force another individual to read the thread, only to find that they were living on borrowed time due to a town who just cba to hunt scum.

2. Replace out of games = victim of flames. I try to only do this when absolutely necessary for the benefit of the game. Of course, i actually have an opinion on this game, which i hope to make clear before i die.

BM

[farside22]

BM:

It would be nice to read a clear direction that an all over the place direction of scum hunting. You have gone back and forth with ideas and haven't really said anything without taking it back.

Saything this I think some people are voting more personal and still think that MOS was right to say that we should have been voting on tautology.

[rajrhcpfreak]

Porochaz (replacing theopor_COD (replacing LoudmouthLee))

[Porochaz]

Hi reading posting sometime over the next few days when I have the time... hopefully sooner rather than later

[Dark Ermac]

I'm replacing!

[Battle Mage]

BM:

It would be nice to read a clear direction that an all over the place direction of scum hunting. You have gone back and forth with ideas and haven't really said anything without taking it back.

Saything this I think some people are voting more personal and still think that MOS was right to say that we should have been voting on tautology.

Well here's something i wont be taking back. The reasoning for votes against me because of something published in a newspaper WHICH IS JUST AS LIKELY TO HAVE BEEN WRITTEN BY SCUM, AS IT IS TO CONTAIN

ANY

ELEMENT OF TRUTH, is total bs.

I am still awaiting an answer to the question about whether or not i can drop items?

BM

[Mariyta]

I think it's safe to assume you cannot, considering it is no where in the rules saying you can.


Farside, while I do admit that I'm happy to vote for BM, my reasoning is more based on his actions yesterday than anything personal.

[rajrhcpfreak]

Dark Ermac (replacing Faeren Lord of Carlisle (replaceing SuperMarioSunshine))

[the silent speaker]

Still here, will finish my table soon (ie before the sun goes nova).

[MissMoo]

I'm also still here, stuck in the middle of a re-read. A bunch of junk due amid finals, and I'll probably find time Friday night to get more done.

On the subject of dropping items, that's something you have to do at night. See post 2 under night phase. Is there maybe a rule about scum not being allowed to drop items? /e confusded.

FOS: BattleMage

[Holy]

Oh well, I finally finished the re-read. And finished -the I don't know what for- listing the Day 1 items claimed.
I still find Tautology is scummy, especially from his fishing questions (page 39 + 40).

Vote: Tautology

Hm, and my other suspect after the re-read is:
Tarhalindur: Around the Day 1 deadline, we knew that Kilroy lied about his items and saw Taut's scummy-fishing acts; but instead one of them, Tarhalindur chose to land his vote on someone that still under the radar than the person that we could see well IS scummy at the moment.

[Battle Mage]

I'm also still here, stuck in the middle of a re-read. A bunch of junk due amid finals, and I'll probably find time Friday night to get more done.

On the subject of dropping items, that's something you have to do at night. See post 2 under night phase. Is there maybe a rule about scum not being allowed to drop items? /e confusded.

FOS: BattleMage

ofc, because as scum, knowing that town can drop items during the day, and knowing that i have been implicitly told i CAN'T, i'm obviously going to make a massive deal of it, thus proving myself as scum.

that was sarcastic btw.

[Battle Mage]

I think it's safe to assume you cannot, considering it is no where in the rules saying you can.


Farside, while I do admit that I'm happy to vote for BM, my reasoning is more based on his actions yesterday than anything personal.

thats poor logic, not just for the game, but for life.
What exactly did i do yesterday that was scummy?