DEFCON Mafia 4.0 - СЛАВА РОССИИ МАТЕРИ

[Cheetory6]

I think LLD is town

Weren't you just saying that LLD is scum? q.q

[Cheetory6]

Anything else? Hmmm. LLD still feels a bit scum to me. Got little else.

q.q

[Nukebringer]

At least I'm not asking someone to choose my actions for me.

it kind of doesn't matter who i choose though i think about it.
I think letting a town read chose is better because it lets people access you based on your choice rather than a dead slot thats already confirmed.

also it stops you from possibly lynching town in future or saving lynch for another scum if your right.

[Nukebringer]

nothing is really scummy about mcmemester

Then who is scum exactly? I think Cheetory is town, I think Mastin and Reck are town, I think LLD is town, I think SpyreX is town. Vax felt like town based on Spiffeh's interaction, although it's a bit marginal still. MoI is town. I think GIF's counterclaim makes him likely town, that makes Hiplop at least not-Russian. That's 9 town. Zito is likely town from the sub, although he could be scum earning points. Nahdia is town.

You and me are probably dying.

So that leaves what, Accountant, Cephrir, McMenno, Ircher? I still think Accountant is pretty town. Hiplop could be SK I suppose, he's done jack shit. Nuking Cephrir sadly is probably not the worst.

I think MoI kind of scummy though equinox disagreed with me.
Nahdia is a also one for me.
sPyrex too.

those are my main scum.

[GreyICE]

I think LLD is town

Weren't you just saying that LLD is scum? q.q

Yes I said that.

It's possible she's scum who took the bunker to avoid nukes because she figures she can dodge the lynch. That's possible. I mean dodging the lynch is only a matter of not being the slowest, while dodging the nukes is a matter of not pissing anyone off, and the odds LLD can play a game of mafia without pissing anyone off are about zero.

Huh... that's actually some solid logic...

I dunno though. I think she's town.

[Cheetory6]

Nuke is there something tangible about McMenno that you're confident about in terms of him not being scum?

[Cheetory6]

Also, GI, same question but with LLD.

[Nukebringer]

Nuke is there something tangible about McMenno that you're confident about in terms of him not being scum?

he recalled on me.
that was good enough.

[Cheetory6]

So you think it's reasonably more likely than not that McMenno would recall as town vs scum?

[GreyICE]

nothing is really scummy about mcmemester

Then who is scum exactly? I think Cheetory is town, I think Mastin and Reck are town, I think LLD is town, I think SpyreX is town. Vax felt like town based on Spiffeh's interaction, although it's a bit marginal still. MoI is town. I think GIF's counterclaim makes him likely town, that makes Hiplop at least not-Russian. That's 9 town. Zito is likely town from the sub, although he could be scum earning points. Nahdia is town.

You and me are probably dying.

So that leaves what, Accountant, Cephrir, McMenno, Ircher? I still think Accountant is pretty town. Hiplop could be SK I suppose, he's done jack shit. Nuking Cephrir sadly is probably not the worst.

I think MoI kind of scummy though equinox disagreed with me.
Nahdia is a also one for me.
sPyrex too.

those are my main scum.

I maintain from PYP that people are super eager to take the scum roles out of play as town, while scum don't want them. That and Nadhia feels generally town. Seriously though, I don't think she takes it as scum.

MoI... I think he could do what he's done as scum. I dunno. Not the worst nuke I guess.

Think you're underselling Cephrir scum. He's been significantly non-entity in a bad way, and he's not a bad player at all.

[McMenno]

I say nuke accountant

[GreyICE]

Also, GI, same question but with LLD.

No. I self-admittedly have problems reading her. That doesn't stop me from trying.

I think she'd be trying harder to control things as scum. Pushing people to nuke people and what have you.

[Vaxkiller]

Busy reading up, will have some actual thoughts later today.

Meanwhile:


__________________________________
bob as planned if your guess is as good as mine

__________________________________

they held fire

__________________________________

waiter out. you know what to do.

__________________________________

confirming that robert frost was a great poet

__________________________________

not xavier?

[Accountant]

Well, I can talk more about it tonight when I'm back from work, but the SS votes dropped on D1 are kind of awkward and the Spiff/Accountant interactions are especially weird.
Accountant calls Spiff weird.
Spiff doesn't respond. [which is pretty non-standard Spiff behavior, I would seriously expect him to either try to discredit or dissuade someone]
Accountant then proceeds to hard-defend Spiff for the rest of the game.
Spiff puts Accountant in the top tier of his top block without having commented on him at all beforehand.

Really just feels like the sort of interactions that I can see Spiff going for and Accountant trying to deal with it and it maybe not working out as cleanly as either of them would have liked.
Entirely possible that Spiff just felt like Accountant would be easier to ignore than to push but just.. no reaction just feels more like he feels like Accountant is no threat because he knows he's no threat via scumbuddy. I suspect Spiff is like me in that he tends to skim his scumbuddies' posts because they're not as important to what he's trying to accomplish as scum.

I'm also feeling that Accountant's votes have that air of scum bussing where they feel they need to. Especially the hops on and off the SS wagon.

as if i would be that bad a scum

Case dismissed

[Accountant]

Could be trying to coast through on his universal townread status.

When is mcmenno a universal townread

[McMenno]

[Cheetory6]

See, Accountant. The nice thing is that I don't have to deal with people being coy. And it's not just because Nukebringer might nuke you if I ask him to.

[Accountant]

See, Accountant. The nice thing is that I don't have to deal with people being coy. And it's not just because Nukebringer might nuke you if I ask him to.

I wasn't being coy. I was giving a dumb answer to a dumb case.

[Accountant]

Is SpyreX scum for calling Spifd transparently town out of the blue?

When A calls B weird, that's a super vague and toothless threat, especially when not backed by a vote. Spiffeh had no reason to stick his neck out by going out of his way to throw shade on me.

Do you have any examples of my scum bussing mystical aura?

[Cheetory6]

Dumb case huh? Well. I guess I'd have to be pretty dumb to do this.

Nuke: Accountant

[Accountant]

Let me know when you start feeling like you want to play mafia.

[Cheetory6]

I don't really have to, do I?

[Papa Zito]

[Day 3, DEFCON 1 - Game Event]

Papa Zito looked furtively at his watch. He walked over to the short-range scanner and saw nothing. "Ops, where did that ICBM go?" He turned to look at the two young men operating the scanners.

"No idea. It just disappeared a minute ago."

Papa Zito shook us head. "ICBMs do not just disappear in-flight."

"We'll check again. If its out there, we'll find it." The men saluted and returned to their work.

"Back to your posts," He said to the Spectator a gathered around. "We're not dead yet."

As his staff saluted and returned to battlestations, he glanced at his watch one last time before heading to his quarters for a drink.

AYYYYYYYYYY

[Cheetory6]

Just for fun let's see what your response is! You know, honestly, dumb 'ol me just doesn't really get it.

Frankly I don't see what Spyrex has to do with anything here, let alone him calling Spiff town out of the blue!

When A calls B weird, that's a super vague and toothless threat, especially when not backed by a vote. Spiffeh had no reason to stick his neck out by going out of his way to throw shade on me.

Gosh I suppose Spiff had no reason to stick his neck out when I gave him a little bit of shit without a vote either.
Almost like those reactions are completely different for different reasons!

Do you have any examples of my scum bussing mystical aura?

I'm yawning at you.
That's literally what my response is to this.

If you're going to call my shit stupid, don't respond with dumber shit.
Thanks.

[Papa Zito]

Cheeto you're my hero.

VOTE: hiplop