The Hobbit Mafia - GAME OVER

[Corsato]

Confirming...

[Corsato]

So we have goblins (kills with a scimitar), Smaug (kills with fire) and trolls. The trolls either kill by snapping players head, or their kill failed. Let's hope for the first.
The lightning bolt must have been from Gandalf, I can't think of any other character to do it.

No random vote today.

[Corsato]

What are our percentages going to be like with a game this size? 9 evil, 20 good? Here's a stab at it:

That's hard to say. Unlike a game with a single mafia group with a clear target (killing everyone) this game has multiple killing groups. This means te scum groups have to look out for eachother as well.

About the setup you describe, it could be correct/ The future will tell.

[Corsato]

A random bandwagon? You can hardly call one vote a bandwagon....

BTW Random Vote: Argoti for thinking that "Gollum didn't do much!!"

vote: Lord Gurgi cause that post about the dwarves makes no sense to me...

Vote: jediknight

. Your reasoning for voting are very strange, and not at all random.

[Corsato]

But either way IS is full of crap.

No more then usually I guess.

Jediknight, I've read your explanation for your behaviour, but I still see it differently. Your vote for Argoti was not random but based on his assumption that "Gollum didn't do much. That's not picking a number between 1 and 29 and voting accordingly. It's a reason, and thus not a random vote.

Seven posts later you decide to vote for Lord Gurgi, because hisr post "doesn't make sense to you". Usually when I do not understand a post or if it simply doesn't make sense to me, I ask for an explanation.

Keeping my vote, as I believe you are the best we've got (so far).

[Corsato]

Jedi's roleclaim doesn't seem to match the book.....of course it is possible that mikehart took some libery in making the roles.
Still, a doc that can protect one player is really limited. What are the chances that he manages to target Thorin? It would only make sense if Thorin was a really powerfull role.

[Corsato]

Thank you for explaining, I almost missed the sarcasm.

[Corsato]

It can be usefull, you should try it for a change....

[Corsato]

OK. so we're waiting for someone else to vote?
Of the 9 players not voting there must be someone who actually has a thought about this??

[Corsato]

Yaw, what do you mean with "the interaction between Korais and Mr. Flay"??
There were 13 people voting for jediknight yesterday, 11 were not. Why is Korais more suspicious then any of those 11 players?

Lord Gurgi, you were not on the jediknight bandwagon as well, so if you think that's a valid reason to bandwagon someone, then why shouldn't we bandwagon you?

[Corsato]

Becase he was attacking me and others would as well if I lynched him, or voted for him in respnse to his vote for me.

Then can hardly be called an explanation for your behaviour.

Yaw, I'm curious about the suspicious interaction between Korais and Mr Flaw, could you be more specific?

[Corsato]

Thank you for your explanation Yaw, I see what you mean now. Just to keep things moving I will put another one on korais666 (for the record, I think he's scummy enough to warrent a vote).

Vote Korais666

[Corsato]

Korais is indeed a bit jumpy. Instead of defending himself he seems concetrating on attacking other. I'll keep my vote, since it's our best lead at the moment.

[Corsato]

I feel like a newbie. What is a vote proxy?

[Corsato]

I'll keep my vote on korais, lynching a troll can't be bad, even if he claimed it himself.

[Corsato]

I'm still around, re-reading so I can actually post some content.

[Corsato]

Vote:ID

, just following Tigris on his lurker hunt.

[Corsato]

Vote Lulu

as well.