Mini 559 - Cult Mafia again - Game over

[XReyoX]

I just thought of something that could be funny. sorry if its out of context but hey.

BM: Do you think you are scum?

Well... perhaps not that funny really.

[Battle Mage]

Not everyone has commented on this. But for the moment, the "everyone" you are referring to is only you, xtoxm and GW.

Anyway, I don't see anything wrong with me not agreeing with most of the town. And I certain don't think because everyone thinks he is town I'll then have to agree. I can judge on my own, i think, and I hope.

-.-

Thats not what i'm saying. I'm saying that it is generally scum who want to keep their options open. Thats what i felt you were doing.

BM

[Pink Puppy]

BM, I don't understand what you mean there, could you try to explain better?

Why to you think Reyo is scum?

I personally find him very town.

Let me tell u a story.

Player A is protown.
Player A makes an analysis.
Everyone in the town thinks that Player A is probably protown.
Player B is scum.
Player B doesnt especially want to eliminate a potential mislynch, so he argues against the decision of the town.

Its only a scenario, but ive done it on numerous occassions as scum. As such, i consider it a pretty reliable scumtell.

BM

I agree that that is a frequent scum reaction -- the more people you either confirm as town or express that you think they are townish -- the harder it is for you to hide and get somebody else lynched.

But I don't think your reasoning for confirming dahen as pro-town is that compelling that reyo has to agree or else is scum.

[Battle Mage]

BM, I don't understand what you mean there, could you try to explain better?

Why to you think Reyo is scum?

I personally find him very town.

Let me tell u a story.

Player A is protown.
Player A makes an analysis.
Everyone in the town thinks that Player A is probably protown.
Player B is scum.
Player B doesnt especially want to eliminate a potential mislynch, so he argues against the decision of the town.

Its only a scenario, but ive done it on numerous occassions as scum. As such, i consider it a pretty reliable scumtell.

BM

It looks like that is what you are doing to Reyo, and I think his not dismissing of dahen is compeltely warranted.

unvote vote BM

.

Umm, What?

I'm dismissing Xreyox as scum? I'm going against the majority by saying that he is a suspect?

I dont understand this post atall. Please explain.

BM

[Xtoxm]

I'm saying it looks like you are doing what you just accused Reyo of doing, to me.

[XReyoX]

I agree that that is a frequent scum reaction -- the more people you either confirm as town or express that you think they are townish -- the harder it is for you to hide and get somebody else lynched.

I don't agree with that because once a scum knows that everyone thinks someone is town, disagreeing with everyone else won't do him any good. He is not going to get him lynch on his own anyway so whats the point? He can keep his option open but it doesn't serve any perpose. He wouldn't be too late to turn his back on that guy when people starts to throw suspicion at and voting for him anyway.

[Battle Mage]

I'm saying it looks like you are doing what you just accused Reyo of doing, to me.

I dont understand. I dont even disagree. I dont understand how i could possibly be guilty of the same thing i accused him of. Please elaborate properly.

[Battle Mage]

I agree that that is a frequent scum reaction -- the more people you either confirm as town or express that you think they are townish -- the harder it is for you to hide and get somebody else lynched.

I don't agree with that because once a scum knows that everyone thinks someone is town, disagreeing with everyone else won't do him any good.

As was pointed out earlier, 3 people is not 'everyone'.

[Pink Puppy]

Maybe because a lot of people have said they think reyo is town?

[Battle Mage]

Maybe because a lot of people have said they think reyo is town?

really?
if that is the case, i wasnt payin attention. But yeh, i can see how you could think that.

BM

[XReyoX]

GW:

Why is Foo scum and why is pinkpuppy town?

[Battle Mage]

ooi, how many people think Reyo is probably town?

BM

[Xtoxm]

Ai do!!

[Battle Mage]

Ah there u are Xtoxm. You can save me the hassle of proving your point for you. Please go and prove that everyone here thinks Xreyox is town. Theres a good lad.

BM

[Xtoxm]

I didn't say everyone did.

[Battle Mage]

you said that alot did. Unless you are now retracting your point, about me being a hypocrite?

BM

[Xtoxm]

My point is/was that are trying to generate suspicion to a player I strongly believe is town, atm.

[Battle Mage]

My point is/was that are trying to generate suspicion to a player I strongly believe is town, atm.

thats a false comparison. My point was about people attacking someone who is WIDELY regarded as town. if 3 people is a loose definition, 1 person just doesnt cut it. Why is your vote still on me?

BM

[Xtoxm]

Cause I think you are scum.

Do you find it scummy that I don't unvote you.

How many players stated they thought dahen was town? 8, 9?

[curiouskarmadog]

Official Vote Count

(Page 21)

Battle Mage

–1 (Xtoxm)

Not Voting:

dahen, Friend of Old, GhostWriter, Battle Mage, Pink Puppy, Norinel, Oman, XreyoX

With 9 alive, it's 5 to lynch. 4 is a no lynch.

Deadline: (March 5th 10am EST)

[Xtoxm]

You mean April 5th?

[Battle Mage]

Cause I think you are scum.

Do you find it scummy that I don't unvote you.

How many players stated they thought dahen was town? 8, 9?

im not sure. not a majority of the town, but a majority of active players fo sure. There were no dissenters at least.

And yes i do find it scummy that you maintain a vote that is based upon logic which you can clearly see is bogus.

BM

[Pink Puppy]

Aren't we accepting xtoxm is the vig... and thus NOT scum?

[curiouskarmadog]

actually, deadline is stated on the first page at all times...and it is.
Deadline: Apirl 1, 8 AM EST

[Xtoxm]

Deadline: (March 5th 10am EST)

Ok, that's why I said that btw.