Mini 559 - Cult Mafia again - Game over

[XReyoX]

What situation was there to respond to? OMG still advocating for his lynch, or Elias voting?

The L-1. Maybe someone might have unvoted, thus creating an alternative discussion. People might have wanted to question elias about his vote. OMG was basicly the only candidate yesterday, that why it was bad.

[GhostWriter]

Dahen, don't you dare give us summaries again. We know what's been said the past few pages. We can read.

[XReyoX]

#575 Reyo replied to Norinel's post
#576 GW warned Dahen not to give a summary again
#577 Reyo made a summary of the last 2 posts.

[GhostWriter]

...






lol, shut up

[Pink Puppy]

I'm here again and will continue my catch up today. From what I scanned through on the last page it seems like interesting things are starting to happen.

This is getting really annoying.

[Xtoxm]

I'm here again and will continue my catch up today. From what I scanned through on the last page it seems like interesting things are starting to happen.

This is getting really annoying.

Mm.

He's just ignoring us...And going about this in his own way...

[Norinel]

And how was I supposed to know Elias was a "bad direction"?

If you're anti-town, particularly mafia, then you'd know that Elias at least wasn't in your faction, and have more general info as to figuring out what his role is. (Plus, of course, you'd know that lynching him would help you regardless of Elias' actual alignment)

On the other hand, Norinel, I think your play has been more watching us play and commenting, than actually playing. Which... is scummy.

What would you consider actually playing? If it's aggressive scumhunting, I've already mentioned that that's not something I often do unless I get a strong scent. Some people need to be shaking the thread, and some people need to be poking at it.

I said that I did not like how people were jumping onto the bandwagon with such weak reasons. People jumped onto the wagon, using reasons stated by those before them, and the wagon was building up to a hammer way too fast. Someone could have waited until the L-1 vote was placed, and placed a vote in that same minute, and then said that they didn't know someone else had voted as well. What's more, when someone said that wagons can be a good thing, I agreed with them, and then stated that SPECIFICALLY that OMG one was not a good wagon. I've used wagons before. I know they can be a good thing, when properly looked after. That one was getting out of hand, at least to me, and so I said so.

The entire point of a bandwagon isn't that everyone has a really good reason to vote for the person in question. Part of the reason that bandwagons occur is that somebody having votes is in and of itself another weak reason to vote them, since three or four votes on one person is a lot more than three or four times as powerful as one vote. And your hypothetical's kind of silly- it's tough to make something look like a simulpost that isn't unless you're insanely active, and a hammerer should always receive extra scrutiny.

As for the last few posts, in a game with fixed deadlines, dahen's behavior is little more than stalling. That's worth a vote on its own.

vote: dahen

until he posts new content.

[Pink Puppy]

And how was I supposed to know Elias was a "bad direction"?

If you're anti-town, particularly mafia, then you'd know that Elias at least wasn't in your faction, and have more general info as to figuring out what his role is. (Plus, of course, you'd know that lynching him would help you regardless of Elias' actual alignment)

Thanks for proving my point.

You're assuming I am anti-town to prove I am anti-town. Your assumption is not evidence.

On the other hand, Norinel, I think your play has been more watching us play and commenting, than actually playing. Which... is scummy.

What would you consider actually playing? If it's aggressive scumhunting, I've already mentioned that that's not something I often do unless I get a strong scent. Some people need to be shaking the thread, and some people need to be poking at it.

Well, it could be a difference in play styles. But I'm usually suspicious of your type of play style and think it has a high probability of being scum.

[Xtoxm]

Oman, you were just convincing me you were town.

Then you go on a 10 day lurk binge.

Save a "I got prodded" post.

...What are your thoughts?

[XReyoX]

Oman has been posting across the site every single day =_=

[Xtoxm]

Oman has been posting across the site every single day =_=

O RLY?

...I am not impressed.

unvote vote Oman

.

To my experience, it is usually scum who try to lurk like that.

[dahen]

I'm going away for Easter, but I've taken the pages with me cached so I can read and write something while being away.

[Battle Mage]

I'm majorly busy atm, and unable to do anything useful here for now. Dont do anything crazy in my absence please, and ill give this game the attention it deserves, soon.

BM

[Pink Puppy]

I'm starting to think Oman is the play.

[Xtoxm]

I'm majorly busy atm, and unable to do anything useful here for now. Dont do anything crazy in my absence please, and ill give this game the attention it deserves, soon.

BM

Let's lynch him while he's away.

[Pink Puppy]

That would be funny.

[Xtoxm]

I'm starting to think Oman is the play.

Then vote for him.

L-4 isn't exactly dangerous.

[Battle Mage]

lynching Oman is stupid. need i say more?

[Xtoxm]

lynching Oman is stupid. need i say more?

Yes.

[Pink Puppy]

I'm starting to think Oman is the play.

Then vote for him.

L-4 isn't exactly dangerous.

I'm just thinking of mafia and cult members out there piling on.

[Xtoxm]

I'm starting to think Oman is the play.

Then vote for him.

L-4 isn't exactly dangerous.

I'm just thinking of mafia and cult members out there piling on.

Oh? You don't think Oman is scum?

[Pink Puppy]

o thats true. but what if i'm wrong?

[Xtoxm]

o thats true. but what if i'm wrong?

We have to start somewhere. Obviously, all the scum in the game will instantly bandwagonly the first townie to get voted by a couple other townies.

Frankly that comment makes me quite suspicious of you.

[Pink Puppy]

But we're essentially only voting oman for lurking. Is that enough?

[Pink Puppy]

Wait a second, if I was mafia/cult, I would not be worried about oman being quicklynched. I would welcome it. So don't be that suspicious.