Open 36: Picking Simplicity - Game over!

[Nightfall]

While I'm certainly not defending JDodge... just a meta-gaming point, though. He is always rather quick and certainly aggressive -- whether scum or town. It can't really be considered a tell, although it will always make people more suspicious of him.

Just, FYI.

It is interesting though how many people are focusing on him though.

Just FYI.

[distad]

I'm certainly suspicious of him myself. I just have to remind myself every time I read through that I have to temper everything a little. I have to remember to evaluate the argument, not the tone.

[mneme]

Ever a page late, yet a not dollar short, here's your ever-ready

Vote Count!

All errors provided by error-o-matic! ;^)
============================================================



Vendagoat: 3 (Nocmen,ojpower,YogurtBandit)
YougurtBandit: 1 (Vendagoat)
Jdodge: 5 (kravhen,Doctor Kisses,AmeliaLi,Somoda,DeliciousD)
Rishi: 1 (Falcone)
WhoMe?: 1 (FlameAxe)
distad: 1 (WeyounsLastClone)
Falcone: 1 (Nightfall)
AmeliaLi: 4 (wiggle, distad,Samruc,Who Me?)
Nocmen: 1 (Jdodge)
Somoda: 1 (Qman)

Not Voting: 1 (rishi)

11 to lynch

[JDodge]

I find the speed with which my wagon grew to be rather odd.

[WhoMe?]

i think at the moment we need to be looking at Amelia Li for her rather odd EBWOP and Doctor Kisses for his potential scum guiding. It is interesting that both of these people are on JDodge's fast wagon.

[kravhen]

Unvote: Jdodge

It was a random vote still there and I don't want it benefiting scum.

[kravhen]

EBWOP: Also good observation WhoMe. I wasn't sure if DK's intention was scummy when he dropped the "scum guider" but seeing him jump on a fast wagon makes it more probable.

[Vendagoat]

Since we are out of the random vote stage.

UNVOTE

I haven't had much time lately. As soon as I do, expect more from me.

[Nocmen]

I will also

Unvote

[Flameaxe]

Unvote

It's an unvote bandwagon!

[wiggle]

Dear mod, I never unvoted

[distad]

Gee... glad you decided to join us here, wiggle...

Unvote, Vote: Doctor Kisses

The more I look at that "thoughts of strategy" sequence, the less comfortable I am with it. While Amelia's really could be a small slip (I will still remember it!), the DK comment is more of a mid-day scum discussion.

But, to whom?

Well, since wiggle just rejoined us, he went to DK's defense there after that. Poorly, but yes. (It's more than just giving them hints they might have heard before... they also might NOT have.) So, that's something to remember, also...

[Doctor Kisses]

i think at the moment we need to be looking at Amelia Li for her rather odd EBWOP and Doctor Kisses for his potential scum guiding. It is interesting that both of these people are on JDodge's fast wagon.

My vote on JDodge was random.

Unvote

For the record, I don't think the attacks against him hold water at this point.

Gee... glad you decided to join us here, wiggle...

Unvote, Vote: Doctor Kisses

The more I look at that "thoughts of strategy" sequence, the less comfortable I am with it. While Amelia's really could be a small slip (I will still remember it!), the DK comment is more of a mid-day scum discussion.

But, to whom?

Well, since wiggle just rejoined us, he went to DK's defense there after that. Poorly, but yes. (It's more than just giving them hints they might have heard before... they also might NOT have.) So, that's something to remember, also...

I really don't get what the problem is with what I said. The scum are going to do what they are going to do regardless of what we say. I can't direct them any more than I can direct the rest of the town. Also, I'm not sure if you're implying that I'm communicating with my scum buddies (which I certainly would not need to do in thread if I was scum).

In other news, it's pointless to vote AmeliaLi while she is away, since she obviously can't defend herself.

I'm thinking JDodge and distad are being a bit too eager to jump on what's probably just a typo

vote: JDodge

Why are you singling out JDodge? distad was pushing a lot harder against AmeliaLi than JDodge was.

[Somada]

Unvote

Yay for the unvote bandwagon! Looks like it's time for another re-read now that the semi-random stage is ending.

[kravhen]

The scum are going to do what they are going to do regardless of what we say.

Wrong. ( Is that a WIFOM-inviting statement too? )
That basically is saying that whatever is said here has no effect whatsoever on the actions of scum, which is obviously false.

[Doctor Kisses]

The scum are going to do what they are going to do regardless of what we say.

Wrong. ( Is that a WIFOM-inviting statement too? )
That basically is saying that whatever is said here has no effect whatsoever on the actions of scum, which is obviously false.

That's not nearly the same thing.

[kravhen]

Hmm?
I'd think if anything they ARE almost nearly the same thing but can be interpreted differently.
Tell me why they aren't nearly the same?

[Nightfall]

-Falcone dies tonight
-I was the only person going after him during the day
-Therefore I must have killed him? (WIFOM)
-Therefore someone else must have killed him to frame me? (also WIFOM)

[DeliciousD]

I'm thinking JDodge and distad are being a bit too eager to jump on what's probably just a typo

vote: JDodge

Why are you singling out JDodge? distad was pushing a lot harder against AmeliaLi than JDodge was.

JDodge has ben jumping his votes around a lot and while I think distad's catch is pretty flimsy, I find it less suspicious that he'd vote on it himself than JDodge's getting on board with it, then going straight onto Nocmen saying that he'd made himself 'painfully obvious'. It just looks to me like JDodge is trying to cause as much suspicion as possible.

[JDodge]

I'm thinking JDodge and distad are being a bit too eager to jump on what's probably just a typo

vote: JDodge

Why are you singling out JDodge? distad was pushing a lot harder against AmeliaLi than JDodge was.

JDodge has ben jumping his votes around a lot and while I think distad's catch is pretty flimsy, I find it less suspicious that he'd vote on it himself than JDodge's getting on board with it, then going straight onto Nocmen saying that he'd made himself 'painfully obvious'. It just looks to me like JDodge is trying to cause as much suspicion as possible.

O RLY?

Vote-hopping = sparking discussion in the random vote stage
Nocmen = painfully obvious

[Samruc]

I did a re-read, and found a few things interesting, guess one of the most interesting things so far really is the Dodge-wagon:

vote: JDodge

for putting Yogurt at lynch-9 on his first post =O

The first vote, nothing to say about this one. (Obviously pseudorandom)

This is gonna be fuuuuun...

Dice Roll:
Original Roll String: 1d20
1 20-Sided Dice Results: 7

Vote: Jdodge

Also obviously random, and *not* jumping on the fast wagon like kravhen called it. In fact,

FoS: kravhen

for misrepresenting Dr K!

Mmm I need to do this for old times sake

Unvote; Vote: JDodge

This is where it starts to look interesting from a wagoning point of view, getting up to three votes. Combined with our previous suspicions towards Amelia, I feel my vote is at the right place at the moment, and I'm really looking forward to her returm.

Vote: JDodge

For serial vote hopping.

I'm thinking JDodge and distad are being a bit too eager to jump on what's probably just a typo

vote: JDodge

Hi guys,

I have been on my hols (I posted in V/LA) But I am back now. I'm going to

vote JDodge

I don't know what to make of the last votes. Somada and DeliciousD motivated their votes appropriately, even though I don't quite agree with them. WhoMe, the last/latest on the wagon for now, put him up to six votes but then unvoted quickly. I think it really was a random vote, but I guess IGMEOY, WhoMe.

***

Summary: No big pingin' on my scumdar from the wagon, (except Amelia), but I guess one of the last votes *could* be scum trying to sneak in. I'm more interested in kravhen after this re-read though.

If someone can get more out of this than me, please share your thoughts.

[AmeliaLi]

Okay. Hey all. I'm back. Let me do a read and I'll post shortly.

[Nocmen]

Okay. Hey all. I'm back. Let me do a read and I'll post shortly.

Welcome back. I don't think I am the only one interestied in what you have to say.

[kravhen]

Okay. Hey all. I'm back. Let me do a read and I'll post shortly.

Who are teh scummz, tell us!

[Falcone]

I'm still here, I was having some computer problems for the last 4 days, I'll try to reread and post in the next 24 hours.