Cerebus, I for one hate these point-by-point breakdowns, so I detest you for making me do this.
in post 82 farside wrote:
Usually in any game my first vote is a joke vote. I think Skitzer is talking about the first post were I made fun of everyone's name. I'm a pretty serious player as far as mafia goes, but I was just playing up my character role. I thought some people would considering this was a reality game. Guess I was wrong.
in post 92 Cerebus wrote:
Don't you think it is kinda early to go about claiming you role name farside?
So at this point, you are concerned that farside is claiming role.
to follow up, farside wrote:
I just thought everyone would have a character type. I didn't think it as indicative of actual alignment. At least I would hope it wouldn't be.
I had some questions about this so I wrote:
Anyways, cerebus3, what is it exactly that you think farside did? Do you think that she has revealed too much info about her role?
If so, what was your read?
to which you wrote:
I thought she was saying the name of her role. And revealing any role information carelessly can only help the scum. (power role tells, fake claims).
It doesn't say much about her alignment though. Neither scum or town would have reason to do that, so I think she was just having fun.
I am not going to say more because needless speculation is bad for the same reason as revealing role information if there isn't a good reason to do so.
So, the question is can you tell me where exactly she claims her role? Because if not, then sorry to say homey, you are speculating. And for you to say that needless speculation is bad, then that's contradiction in my book.
As for me, I feel that speculation can be a good place to start, especially so early in the day. If you see something, then say it, don't cop out with this needless speculation garbage. If you don't wish to elaborate on your speculations, then just don't say anything. Or better yet, please keep on doing as you are doing. Rather you look like the jackass than me.
