Open 487: Hard Boiled Day 3: A sinister Murder

[The Acting Method]

http://www.quicktopic.com/50/H/cK3JMiVEW8E Dead, QT is fun.

http://www.quicktopic.com/50/H/ENZCN76VHxEi Scum QT is meh...

I know I'm adding shit to my ruleset now for my next modded game.

Orc, It played a large, large, large, large, large part in it.

Larger than your inflated ego will probably be willing to give credit.

[Malakittens]

Damn it. I thought my crumbs were clever. Apparently, not..

[The Acting Method]

http://www.quicktopic.com/50/H/cK3JMiVEW8E

[Ms Marangal]

and our demise

Pedit: it was, Scum never caught it which was a good thing

[orcinus_theoriginal]

Don't lie to me Orci. I dun like Liars D:

IDFK why I ever decided to do a 1v1 with you, one of the things that ended up with me false claiming.

No, I do. I would never have forgiven you if you were town. But you weren't so all is forgiven.

Hi TAM setup was broken for town go think a bit before you post

[The Acting Method]

Town sided or not, you guys got EXTREMELY lucky that HD and Ms Marangal did what they did.

I do not think that Town would have won this game so quickly HAD NOT scum played the way they did.

[nopointinactingup]

You aren't that good orc, don't be so cocky. It really annoyed me.
That's the only complaint i have about this game. Otherwise good game

[RachMarie]

Dino why did you not send in a kill

I knew I would die last night but I still investigated...

[orcinus_theoriginal]

You aren't that good orc, don't be so cocky. It really annoyed me.
That's the only complaint i have about this game. Otherwise good game

NAU MVP

[Leafsw0rd]

Setup was broken, we've hacked it to pieces.

If Orc hadn't been so cocky and arrogant, I probably would have voted for his lynch. I hate to admit it, but how self-confident he was pushed him town for me.

[Ms Marangal]

Orci was effectively town, a bit annoying now and then, but he was effectively town. I was actually surprised that I was able to bring up some dirt in regards to him

[freezing-hell]

Orc was definitely an annoying brat, but a good player nonetheless. MVP!!

[freezing-hell]

Marangal, you really drove me nuts. Sorry for calling you VI and everything Nice job getting to reveal Dino as well. You also had a difficult game, tbh - with your partners getting replaced etc.
Leafsword, you played quite a nice game as well, although because of your infrequent posting sometimes I felt a bit uncomfortable.
PC, job well done! most valuable hydra.
Mathdino, you played a good game as well. Felt you were town pretty much from the beginning, same as orci.
Neko, wasn't too sure on you throughout the game. Maybe it was also because you didn't post that often. But in hindsight you didn't do that much scummy, and I was just seeing things.
Rachmarie, sorry for not picking up on you being a PR. It was just so strange that you were 'hanging back' so much!
Jon, nice game as well. You also looked pro-town throughout your posts. Which you were more often here though!

Thanks to all the replacers as well. Not easy to catch up when there are already so many pages of content out there.
It was a strange game, especially with all the PRs revealed on day 1.
GG town!

[Human Destroyer]

Town sided or not, you guys got EXTREMELY lucky that HD and Ms Marangal did what they did.

I do not think that Town would have won this game so quickly HAD NOT scum played the way they did.

You're seriously going to blame a setup failure on the scum?

Seriously, even with killing 2 outed PRs in a row, there were

3 confirmed town

. That's ridiculous and not possible for scum to win.

[Ms Marangal]

Despite this being one of my worst games ever, I really despised being called a VI...

and I drove you nuts on purpose, that's kinda what I do as scum. I just loved your reaction to thinking that you were likely to get shot, it was a move that I did to try and save HP from being lynched and you were an easy target to pick on

[Human Destroyer]

http://www.quicktopic.com/50/H/ENZCN76VHxEi Scum QT is meh...

fun fact: I actually forgot leafsw0rd was confirmed town

[freezing-hell]

Despite this being one of my worst games ever, I really despised being called a VI...

and I drove you nuts on purpose, that's kinda what I do as scum. I just loved your reaction to thinking that you were likely to get shot, it was a move that I did to try and save HP from being lynched and you were an easy target to pick on

I tried keeping it civilised, hehe. I completely over reacted there, that's true.

[The Acting Method]

Town sided or not, you guys got EXTREMELY lucky that HD and Ms Marangal did what they did.

I do not think that Town would have won this game so quickly HAD NOT scum played the way they did.

You're seriously going to blame a setup failure on the scum?

Seriously, even with killing 2 outed PRs in a row, there were

3 confirmed town

. That's ridiculous and not possible for scum to win.

Had Ms. Marangal played differently, there would not have been 3 confirmed town perhaps,

While I agree this game is town sided, I do believe that the reason town won so quickly was bad scum play. It's common sense, Day one had a great chance for a mislynch. Many times. However, what I consider bad play from the scum team, defintely contributed to scum's loss, not just the townsidedness of the setup. I've seen many a townsided set up won by scum because scum played it right. (or town played really really stupid.)

[pirate mollie]

I am not so sure the set-up was all that town sided, here is why; mala's first instinct was to use the hider as a cop role. I had a slightly different approach, I wanted to use it to solely clear town so that town would have a pool of players to work with. so we went with that and I took a bit of a backseat in the game thread cos I am very aggressive and with our role we needed to be a bit more diplomatic and mala is good at that. I am always

shocked

when people can't tell us apart I mean it is so obvious.

all the night choices were mala's and I let her do the breadcrumbing cos she was so excited about it. I thought they were really obvious and kept expecting for us to die, but I guess no one else picked up on it. she made awesome night choices.

@ orc

spotted you as town in a couple of posts, it was a relief to have 1 good town read early on d1 and you had a lot of really good insight. I got to the point a couple of times where I had to sit on my hands cos of some of the flak you were getting. I think town won largely cos of how you took charge right off the bat and steered the game and mala and I had the wit to let you run with it. lol, orc we didn't need to confirm you as town it was obvious to us that you were. the only thing that gave me pause was you had such confidence in me as a player and I wasn't sure where that was coming from.

question: when you asked mala if she likes to hide, were you reaching out to us see if we were the hider? cos that is how I took it. I thought you were the vig at that point but I guess it was dino.

(((scum team)))

there were definitely some things the scum team could have done better. I think having good scum chemistry is huge in winning games especially when there is no day chat. hd I felt bad for you when I read the end of the game. I once lost my entire team at the end of n1 and was left with 13 town 6 of who were specials and one SK. I won that game out of sheer luck, cos the SK was my mentor and when he realised he had left me all alone and that he was not going to get the endgame he wanted he decided to help me. I think you guys just got very unlucky in this game.

thanks for the game TAM!

marangala I thought you looked like pondscum but I am not going to tell you why. it is always fun to play with you.

[jon_h61]

GG all. I get to add another Town victory to my stats.

I called two thirds of the scum team Day One. Rach had me confused by how laid back she was playing, but now that we know she had a PR I can understand why.

Sorry about being such a low count poster, I had two unexpected doc visits that took all day, and a camping/fishing trip this weekend. I think TAM forgot to post my v/la, but it wasn't really needed since this last day was so short. The Day before was over before I even saw the opened thread.

I think Town played well (all of you). I had Leaf pegged as Town early on, and was pretty sure FH was Town too. PC was definitely Town from the start. Orcinus was Town all the way, making it a small group for scum to try to hide in. I had M_M pegged as scum early on, mainly due to her attack on Orcinus. She had to make things up that didn't add up, but she gave it an honest shot.

TAM thanks for the opportunity to play the game, and thanks for modding!

[Ms Marangal]

marangala I thought you looked like pondscum but I am not going to tell you why. it is always fun to play with you.

I felt like newb-scum so I can forgive you for that I was so terribly off my game for the past three weeks, even my town games were sub-par.

I love playing with you to Mollie, I'm probably going to game stalk you <3

and I left so many scumslip's other then the fact that I decided to attack Orci that I'm kinda surprised that people thought that I was town before my false-claim

[orcinus_theoriginal]

Thanks for the kind words, everyone. Mollie, I was PR reading you later on, but the below was a coincidence. I'm flattered that you thought I could've picked it up that early, though!

Unless you want to hide something lol

[orcinus_theoriginal]

oh and i wanted hider to target town too--which was why i wanted mala to target me.

[Malakittens]

Yeah, but we felt our read on you was confidient enough we didn't have to target you. We could have had you as our indi block member withotu officialing it.

[freezing-hell]

Also, big thanks for modding the game Acting Method. It's appreciated!