Mini 1493: Lucky's <insert cool name here> game (GAME OVER)

[Lucky2u]

If your wondering why I didn't choose 3 since it was only day 1.... This is a closed setup game, I couldn't restart with the same setup without giving some players an advantage (If ABR rolled town for example, he would already know what the scum roles were). I also couldn't redo the setup because I would need to stop and get the next setup approved for balance and normalacy all over again.

Side note: the original setup of this game had a double voter on town side. It was deemed overly balanced toward town and removed.

[Antihero]

Experience counts for shit in the game. You learn more from a game you lost than a game you won .

oh yeah? what's the lesson here?

if you're an investigative role, fucking ignore your results and play like you're vanilla?

The lesson here is you have to say what you think at that point . It is useless to not carry on to do so . I remember when you posted your innocent on Albert ,
someone(i think it was you) had posted day1 that town cop's innocent were pretty much useless . Fuck i am still new and i did not understand the setup , i just thought NicCage was seriously scum at that point.
I had it pretty straight forward whoever was on the VA lynch was scum, they should be lynched . I was hoping Scum would night kill people on that wagon only . Sadly i did not put my point across today as well .

It's easy to say that cop results should be taken with a grain of salt in MD threads. But in practice, the overwhelming majority of towns trust the cop innocents, as they should (because 9/10 times, they won't land on the secret bullshit godfather).

You know what would have fixed this lucky? If you fucking TOLD ME that there was a godfather. Then, everyone would've know to not trust the innocents.

No... instead i fall into this secret trap...

Well, this setup

got

me. Silly me. I thought I had an investigative role. Instead, I had a bastard role that lied to me. That'll teach me a lesson.

[aptil]

1 more thing i learned policy lynching Wake88 is not a bad idea .

[archaebob]

I don't understand why Sal's ass wasn't grass as soon as Viera got the track result on Anti.

I don't understand how Banksys survived.

I can forgive Albert skating by, especially with the cop result. It was pretty clear he wasn't vanilla though. Once all the PRs flipped there should have been some serious questions.

My unvote on Banksys was awful. Twill never happen again. Also, I shouldn't have been as timid to push Albert day 1.

This was a good return game for me. Any comments/feedback welcome.

[Lucky2u]

Experience counts for shit in the game. You learn more from a game you lost than a game you won .

oh yeah? what's the lesson here?

if you're an investigative role, fucking ignore your results and play like you're vanilla?

The lesson here is you have to say what you think at that point . It is useless to not carry on to do so . I remember when you posted your innocent on Albert ,
someone(i think it was you) had posted day1 that town cop's innocent were pretty much useless . Fuck i am still new and i did not understand the setup , i just thought NicCage was seriously scum at that point.
I had it pretty straight forward whoever was on the VA lynch was scum, they should be lynched . I was hoping Scum would night kill people on that wagon only . Sadly i did not put my point across today as well .

It's easy to say that cop results should be taken with a grain of salt in MD threads. But in practice, the overwhelming majority of towns trust the cop innocents, as they should (because 9/10 times, they won't land on the secret bullshit godfather).

You know what would have fixed this lucky? If you fucking TOLD ME that there was a godfather. Then, everyone would've know to not trust the innocents.

No... instead i fall into this secret trap...

Well, this setup

got

me. Silly me. I thought I had an investigative role. Instead, I had a bastard role that lied to me. That'll teach me a lesson.

As far as I know, the cop isn't told about a god father and the mods who approved my setup never mentioned it. They were pretty nit picky about my role PMs so I don't think something like that would have gotten through if it wasn't suppose to be like that.

[aptil]

Looking at scum chat again: you said i was easiest to control .Is that your assessment even now ?

[Antihero]

As far as I know, the cop isn't told about a god father and the mods who approved my setup never mentioned it. They were pretty nit picky about my role PMs so I don't think something like that would have gotten through if it wasn't suppose to be like that.

/boo

[aptil]

@Arch-It was again suggested that claimed roles should be left for mafia to kill .So were off the map .

[Banksys Flareon]

@Aptil: Kind of? My accusations against you were accurate enough. You never posted enough content to give me a clear idea of where you were going. When you chose to come after me it turned things around a little. StrangerCoug made it easier as well.

I can't believe I survived that game lol

[Antihero]

As far as I know, the cop isn't told about a god father and the mods who approved my setup never mentioned it. They were pretty nit picky about my role PMs so I don't think something like that would have gotten through if it wasn't suppose to be like that.

you should have put in a roleblocker instead of the godfather

it would've broken the cop/doc combo, provided a counter to investigative roles, and prevented me from randomly getting dicked over by investigating the "wrong person."

[aptil]

@Aptil: Kind of? My accusations against you were accurate enough. You never posted enough content to give me a clear idea of where you were going. When you chose to come after me it turned things around a little. StrangerCoug made it easier as well.

I can't believe I survived that game lol

Yep i don't think he ever read the game .
Also i was pretty much on to the scum team after VA lynch . So yea not holding back to what you think is also pretty damn important .

[uctriton00]

I LIKE GAMES WHERE I AM IGNORED THE ENTIRE TIME

[uctriton00]

I wanted to question Albert about that really, reaaaaaally suspicious claim of "well i'm not afraid of him", and was trying to peg him as scum #3

oh well

[uctriton00]

one thing I learned from watching how scum play as a moderator is that there is usually someone on the scum team who is just hiding in the back and not drawing suspicion, and that's what I wanted to talk to Albert about

To be honest, I probably was leaning more Aptil than Banksys, but this was all pending on how Albert answered my question

ugh

[uctriton00]

And I wasn't as active in the game due to real life time constraints, and with how freakin fast these bigger games go (I've been living in newbie games and micro games, and am trying to branch out into larger ones). Sometimes the game will go two days, and then 5 to 10 pages will be up. I could have had more influence than 30 posts in a 48 page game, but I'm going to try to stick my nose in farther more often, especially as a VT.

Good job Lucky on moderating; the vote counts were always convenient and there were no long twilight periods. Thumbs up!

[uctriton00]

And Nic that was a (very wrong) read I had on you. I wasn't scum looking for a quick lynch. Sorry about that; I just missed.

[theaceofspades]

how did bank survive this!?!?!?!?

holy crap. if it came down to me..... i woulda voted aptil before rampage, so I don't think town really had a chance after assasin's lynch

[theaceofspades]

also bansk..... why do you hate me so?

[aptil]

Well it is sad when you did not analyze the VA kill ace and ucti.

[uctriton00]

If I remember right, that day flew by in like 6 hours when I wasn't even on.

[aptil]

Yes i was not on either. That suggested to me all scum team has to be a part of the wagon. Anyways i should have made my case on banksys a little better and not assume everyone has come to the same conclusion already.

[Banksys Flareon]

I don't hate you ace, I was just hella frustrated. No worries.

[SalmonellaDreams]

I don't how you built your case on the assumption that both scum must've been on the VA wagon.

[StrangerCoug]

Well that was wacky. Pretty obvious who we had to lynch today . I was a lazy but Coug should have read the thread . Congrats Scum team .

I was kind of lazy too. I responded to you the way I did because you were being defensive and unhelpful. I even accounted for the fact that I might not have kept track of everything important when I posted the ultimatum.

That said, I think I've done things of my own to cost us the game even if I factor you out. I let my mind play WIFOM games re: Banksys Flareon.

[NicCage]

werp.
That scum QT is 2long. I want to read it but I don't have the attention span.
Yeah I guess I sort of let myself get mislynched. I didn't start very strong D2, but I guess I kind of expected town not to be so trigger happy. I'm lazy, what can I say. Also there was no reason to vote me, but w/e.
GG scum