Mini 98-Cellular Mafia! It's Over!

[BlueSin]

Malaprop,
cool graphics+analysis. Maybe he is betting on role pm or is a

slow

town, i mean organel. 8)

for me,
mlaker is just a little slow in understand the situation, like Malaprop, if both are innocent.

vIQleS,
I get that

thing

, that's why I believe rick. I misunderstood your question.

vote: Quailman
i'm on Rick side after read through the whole game.

he has posted something that make me believe his innocent.

unvote: Malaprop

[Rick]

Wow, that was quite an answer. No, that was outstanding. OK I believe you, you were distracted. As for the Mafia Grapher I really like it (I have a couple of suggestions if you are interested).

Personally I am very keen on analysis, however over time I have learnt that analysis on its own, doesn’t work. On top of analysis you need to go with your gut and intuitions and look for those slight subtleties that analysis will never pick up. [Hey this is only an opinion so if you disagree with it that is fine by me, and anyway I think you should keep up with the MG].

Anyway, let me point out one of the subtleties that you missed (you were probably still to distracted):

First you did make a defence (post#108):

Ah, just it clicked and I checked, the quote that is not a quote. Didn't have my PM memorized word-for-word.

Now in my opinion I thought that it was a very good defence. And as such a good play on your part.

But Kleimar didn’t get it:

I would like to join the Malaprop bandwagon but given the amount of votes he has I will FOS him instead. I want to hear a defence first.

Kleimar did not think that you had made a defence!! Which means that Kleimar is ‘out of the loop’.

But instead of pointing this out you went and made a second defence (post#113). This second defence in my opinion was one of your bad plays (1 out of the 4 that I hinted to). For a start if players haven’t got it by now (and I would have thought that the scum would have got it straight away – but I’ll post about that later) they certainly have got it now. Also . . . actually I’m not going to say, but there were other points in your second defence which I didn’t like.

If I were you, all I would have done was FOS:Kleimar and say something like, “Kleimar why don’t you think I (Malaprop) made a defence in post#108?”

[Rick]

I'd bet the farm that both Yggdrasil & mlaker are scum.

Wow, MeMe that is one big bet.

What about kleimar - isn't he "out of the loop" as well?

[Dirge]

MeMe, being unable to post, but as anal as ever, has asked me to post this, sent via PM, for her.

What about kleimar - isn't he "out of the loop" as well?

Perhaps – but it’s hard to tell as this was his response to the situation…

unvote Rick

I would like to join the Malaprop bandwagon but given the amount of votes he has I will FOS him instead. I want to hear a defence first.

That doesn't imply anything about understanding the bandwagon OR being clueless about it. But Yggdrasil – who, by trying to explain to me why your

role name

convinced him, threw a spotlight on the fact that he missed your win criteria as being pro-town - and mlaker – who, if he’d understood the Malaprop vote, wouldn’t have designated vIQleS his secondary choice - have removed most doubt from my mind.

So...it may be a big bet, but it doesn't seem to be that risky.

[kleimar]

I must confess that I overlooked the subtile hint in Malaprop's defence. (It even took me some time to find it even after it was said that there was a hint in it.)

vote Yggdrasil

MeMe has convinced me of his scumminess.

[Rick]

Oh, Malaprop one more thing:

Bigbenwd is silent, posting only once in the game; very uncharacteristic for him

Yes, I thought Ben's silence to be very strange, but I checked it out and he posted on the vacation forum that he has limited access:
http://mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopic.php?t=25&start=277

[Dementia Blader]

Vote Count

Quailman-1-(BlueSin)
BlueSin-1-(Yggdrasil,)
Kleimar-1-(Glamdring)
Yggdrasil-2-(Meme, Kleimar)
Malaprop-1-(Mlaker)
Mlaker-1-(Caveman)

7 to lynch

[Caveman]

I'll go ahead and fix that messed up count with an

Unvote: Malaprop

[Caveman]

Just read the thread again. mlaker either doesn't get it or he's scum for sure. I say the latter.

Vote:mlaker

But still,

FOS:Malaprop

Yggdrasil, I'm not so sure about. I'll read more

[Caveman]

Sorry for the multiple posts, I'd usually sit in preview while looking in the thread, but the stupid thing doesn't work right now.

BlueSin, what was the bug in the game you spoke about? (In reply 109, for those who don't remember (I can't quote either)).

[Malaprop]

To further correct that vote count; I unvoted MeMe in the middle of p5. Rick also unvoted me near the bottom of p5. Didn't check the others.

[BlueSin]

Caveman,
i mean the *h*i*n*t* (encripted).
Are you just act like a scum or really don't get it?

unvote: Quailman
vote: Yggdrasil

[BlueSin]

unvote: Quailman
vote: Yggdrasil

[Glamdring]

wow, I thought I'd done this already:

Unvote: Kleimar

Still, I'm not ready to jump on the Yggdrasil bandwagon... I leave it at an FOS.

[Caveman]

I'm irritated that I hadn't noticed this sooner. bigbenwd has posted a grand total of.........drum roll please.........

2 TIMES

.

That's it!!!!

Unvote: mlaker. Vote: bigbenwd

[Dementia Blader]

Yes, I thought Ben's silence to be very strange, but I checked it out and he posted on the vacation forum that he has limited access:
http://mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopic.php?t=25&start=277

Vote Count

BlueSin-1-(Yggdrasil,)
Yggdrasil-3-(Meme, Kleimar, Bluesin)
Malaprop-1-(Mlaker)
Bigbenwd-1-(Caveman)

7 to lynch

[Caveman]

Oops, didn't read the last page too thoroughly. Thanks mod. Even though, his post on the vacation thread,

I probly wont log in for 1 2 or even 3 days in a row this week, sorry. I'll be at my dad's out in cali, and i prbly wont have THAT much time to do this, don't expect posts to be as frequent... I know, you're all dissapointed

was posted 3 days after his only other in-game post

AND

3 days after the 26th would be the 29th. It's the 31st!

My vote stands.

[BlueSin]

mod,
Yggdrasil (Meme, Kleimar, Bluesin). there is 3 ppl, not 2.

[Quailman]

I have been swamped at work all week and unable to keep up (not that much is happening anyway). Now I'm headed off to a Boy Scout campout for the weekend. I promise to catch up Monday.

[MeMe]

Um...so...anyone got anything to say?

[Malaprop]

I've agreed with your analysis so far. I've resisted voting for Yggdrasil so far because I made the same mistake he did and figured people would see it as very scummy.

I originally disregarded that part of Rick's post because I had been told in another game that good mods will usually vary role PMs to prevent sittuations like that. Plus, I've almost been mod killed once for trying something similar to what Rick did, and since people say playing that way is somewhat unethical, I didn't bother checking my role PM to see if the wording matched up. So, yes, the "mitochondrion" part of his role was enough to convince me. Hopefully malaprop is scum, or else this whole win condition thing will waste two lynches.

I don't really follow this defense. He said he noticed it and was reminded of a similar situation he was in, but didn't think to check at all? That strikes me as really weird. Additionally, he's really only talked to accuse others. To keep the game moving, it's with a little trepidation that I

vote: Yggdrasil

.

[Caveman]

Well, I'm sticking with my vote. bigbenwd has posted on 'Scum

Today

! Mod, could you prod him? This is totally ridiculous.

[Rick]

Ok MeMe, count me IN.

*Throws chips on the table*

vote: Yggdrasil

*lights cigar*

[Dementia Blader]

have been swamped at work all week and unable to keep up (not that much is happening anyway). Now I'm headed off to a Boy Scout campout for the weekend. I promise to catch up Monday.

Vote Count

BlueSin-1-(Yggdrasil,)
Yggdrasil-5-(Meme, Kleimar, Bluesin, Rick, malaprop)
Malaprop-1-(Mlaker)
Bigbenwd-1-(Caveman)

7 to lynch

[bigbenwd]

sorry, I'm a bad inactive person *begins his readthrough*