SMBM 1: IoBC GAME OVER! CONGRATULATIONS: TOWN AND KAMIKAZE!

[Nexus]

Plus, you hardly gave me chance for a rebuttal. Less than 24 hours.

OH LOOK. Sharkfinn went from the Zdenek wagon at 6pm yesterday to me at 5am. How isn't that vote hopping?

Yes, I contradicted myself, but I believed at that point that Zdenek was less town than the other wagon.

And it's only 5 votes on me. How isn't it scummy that DP and Lowell are quite happy to have hammered someone without them giving a response?

[mallowgeno]

Alright gang, few Questions:

-MS who's ur mentor?

-Why Nexus QL?

[CryMeARiver]

Alright gang, few Questions:

-MS who's ur mentor?

-Why Nexus QL?

Thought you were dead...

UNVOTE: Nexus
Yo Swift, target Nexus tonight (not with a vig).

[CryMeARiver]

Mallowgeno- MA Mole

Kise

Gollum

- Magikoopa - Avenger

Nexus- johnny jones
Lowell- Sergeant Flutter
Bunnylover- Jinx - Gains Apprentice
GhostWriter- Frogfucius

SharkFinn- Croco

DavidParker

MehPlusRawr

- Toadofsky - VT
Midnight's Sorrow- Booster

CMARchkflip- Princess Toadstool

jimfinn- Yoshi
Zdenek- Toad

SwiftStrike- MARIO - 2 shot vig, targets people

Babyspice

Lakitu

- Assistant to Chef Torte - Mason

@Mod: Prod Babyspice/jimfinn/anyone else who hasn't posted today?

[Swiftstrike]

I'll target Nexus tonight if we leave him to confirm his claim, it's what I planned to do until the modified roleblocker came up for last night.

I think the mallow character is dead not mallowgeno the player, didn't we have this discussion already when geno (character) died it's confusing having the character names as part of the player names. Also Mallowgeno is a claimed vanilla townie as well.

I would also like david parker to explain his logic from the last day's play when I raised this. Why his vote went on me when his reason given for voting is the same reasoning of why not to vote for me.

ugh what.

Unvote, vote swiftstrike

The fact MULTIPLE PLAYERS have claimed that MS has some link to them STRONGGLYYY INDICATES MS IS TOWN...

So the fact that both Jim Finn and Danakillsu both wanted me to target them should indicate that your vote is madness.

Iecerint indicates that that they would become lovers which would hint that at least one of then was scum where as Bunny lover says she chose to target MS to apprentice him, (not that they where linked before the choice.) and that nothing seemed to work in response to this.

[SharkFinn]

OH LOOK. Sharkfinn went from the Zdenek wagon at 6pm yesterday to me at 5am. How isn't that vote hopping?

And you didnt point out yesterday where I pretty much started every wagon? Do you homework sir. I decided that I should up the pressure and wow your are crumbling pretty quickly.

And notice this is like the 100th player who says "Something happens if Mario targets me". WTH IS THIS!?!?!??!

Unvote

Anyways, Lowell just ping'd the scumdar.

[Nexus]

How am I crumbling? I'm simply answering questions put to me, and pointing out scummy and hypocritical behaviour of everyone else. Isn't that what I'm meant to do?

<3

[Bowser]

Votecount coming.

[Bowser]

First Invasion Log of Day 4

mallowgeno
Kise
Nexus [3] Zdenek, Lowell, DavidParker
Lowell
Bunnylover
GhostWriter
SharkFinn
DavidParker
Midnight's Sorrow
CMAR
jimfinn
Zdenek
SwiftStrike
Baby Spice
No Burn

8 to burn, 8 to no burn

Deadline: 2/20/2011 @ 7:00pm EST

[CryMeARiver]

Mallowgeno- MA Mole - VT

Kise

Gollum

- Magikoopa - Avenger

Nexus- johnny jones

Lowell- Sergeant Flutter
Bunnylover- Jinx - Gains Apprentice
GhostWriter- Frogfucius

SharkFinn- Croco

DavidParker

MehPlusRawr

- Toadofsky - VT
Midnight's Sorrow- Booster

CMARchkflip- Princess Toadstool

jimfinn- Yoshi
Zdenek- Toad

SwiftStrike- MARIO - 2 shot vig, targets people

Babyspice

Lakitu

- Assistant to Chef Torte - Mason

@Mod: Prod Babyspice/jimfinn/anyone else who hasn't posted today?

@Mod: Prod Babyspice/jimfinn/anyone else who hasn't posted today?

Okay, so I figure that since this is a bastard mod game and since the town wincon is word for word posted in the rules, the mod might not have given the scum safe name claims and so maybe the scum might have slipped up in their name claim. There will be more analysis (order the name claims came out in and the already revealed mafia's name claims), but for now, here is a flavor analysis. By the way, I figure one of the scum names is Exor.

Flavors:

Note: All of the bad guys are associated with Smithy and the Smithy Gang, not just enemies of Mario.

Mallow's "MA mole" is a character rescued by Mario, not aligned with the bad people.
Kise's "Magikoopa" isn't a person. It is a species.

In Super Mario RPG: Legend of the Seven Stars, several Magikoopas appear as minions of Bowser. Unfortunately for the Koopa King, the Magikoopas, along with the remaining members of the Koopa Troop, chose to abandon him rather than aid him against the Smithy Gang.

Also, a brainwashed magikoopa aids the Smithy gang.
Nexus' "Johnny Jones" is a pirate that Mario fights, however he helps Mario to catch Yaridovitch and is not associated with Smithy.
Lowell's "Sergeant Flutter" is a character which aids Mario.
BunnyLover's "Jinx" is a dojo that Mario fights, but is not associated with Smithy except for the fact that the brainwashed Magikoopa used Jinx clones to fight Mario
Ghostwriter's "Frogfucius" is Mallow's grandfather and is the one who lets Mario know of the Smithy gang
SharkFinn's "Croco" is a villainous thief. However, the wiki specifically says...

Croco is not allied to Smithy. In fact he is allied only to himself and his only interest is getting rich.

David Parker's "Toadofsky" is a composer that gives Mario a mushroom and helps him.
Midnight's "Booster" chooses to hold Princess Toadstool hostage and marry her after she fell out of the sky into his castle. However, the wiki specifically says...

Booster is actually not a part of the Smithy Gang nor is he evil at heart.

Also, the fact that "Grate Guy" flipped town (and he was defending Booster's castle" suggests that Booster is likely town.
CMAR's "Princess Toadstool" is the damsel in distress that Mario is saving from Booster's castle.
Jimfinn's "Yoshi" is a pal of Mario's. "During the events of Super Mario RPG: Legend of the Seven Stars, Yoshi acted as Mario's interpreter as the Yoshis on Yo'ster Isle only spoke the Yoshi language."
Zdenek's "Toad" is originally supposed to rescue Princess Toadstool however he's too late. "In Super Mario RPG: Legend of the Seven Stars, Toad is an adviser to the Chancellor of the Mushroom Kingdom. He appears throughout the game to offer Mario tutorials on how to accomplish certain tasks. "
BabySpice's "Assistant to Chef Torte"...

During the events of Super Mario RPG: Legend of the Seven Stars, Torte was tasked with creating the worlds greatest wedding cake for Booster and Princess Toadstool's wedding. The chef and his apprentice eventually create the masterpiece Bundt which they rush over to the wedding ceremony.
...
Thus Torte and his apprentice attack Mario and his allies.

[CryMeARiver]

At the moment,

based strictly on name claims

, I find the following town/suspicious

Town

Mallowgeno
Midnight's Sorrow
SwiftStrike
CMAR
Zdenek
jimfinn
BabySpice

Null

Nexus
Lowell
GhostWriter (leaning town)
SharkFinn
DavidParker

Suspicious

Kise
BunnyLover

Kise says he's an Avenger. It works to our advantage then. Let's lynch Kise (name claim I find super suspicious), despite me doubting mafia would claim to have a shot like that, and get him to shoot BunnyLover (name claim a bit suspicious as well as his one-shot "apprentice target" not working).
VOTE: Kise

[CryMeARiver]

by Baby Spice
Tue Feb 08, 2011 6:02 am

Last visited:
Mon Feb 07, 2011 10:19 pm

Come out come out wherever you are!

[SharkFinn]

Vote Kise

In CMAR we trust.

[SharkFinn]

And if you're trying to tell me that none of you others have quickly changed your minds and hopped wagons in this game, or any other game as town, I'm calling BS. Everyone is guilty of it at one point in their lives.

Im guilty of this several times, intentionally (ESPECIALLY AT THE END OF YESTERDAY!)

[GhostWriter]

Yeah, it's a good plan. I can get behind it.

VOTE: Kise

[jimfinn]

Sorry, I was on last night only to read my PMs for the game I am modding and didn't see the thread for this game was open yet. I'm going to do a reread on Kise, but the flavor so far is pretty interesting. I still haven't received anything useful from the Mario, but my empowering his repeated 1-shot viggery isn't a bad plan.

[CryMeARiver]

Also, @Swift: I'd hit someone on the "Null" list, but don't announce who and no protective role should be on anyone on the "Null" list. I want to see 2 people die tonight or else I suspect you.

[SharkFinn]

Also, @Swift: I'd hit someone on the "Null" list, but don't announce who and no protective role should be on anyone on the "Null" list. I want to see 2 people die tonight or else I suspect you.

CMAR: that seriously ping'd my scumdar. That statement is incredibly scummy and sets up for scum to NK gambit.

[SharkFinn]

btw. I still think you are town, but that was a bad statement to say.

[CryMeARiver]

Also, @Swift: I'd hit someone on the "Null" list, but don't announce who and no protective role should be on anyone on the "Null" list. I want to see 2 people die tonight or else I suspect you.

CMAR: that seriously ping'd my scumdar. That statement is incredibly scummy and sets up for scum to NK gambit.

You're absolutely right and I didn't realize that
I just think it's weird that by D4 a vig with multiple shots has yet to prove himself...

[SharkFinn]

he shot me intentionally, and he got the extra shot the day before...

[SharkFinn]

this was the first time he could do it....

[SharkFinn]

WAIT!!! Swift: who have you tried to kill, (minus me)

[Bunnylover]

I don't mind lynching Kise, but if he is telling the truth about his role, I would rather him shoot MS instead of me.
My flip will only confused rather or not to kill MS (the only reason he was kept alive was because I targeted him).
I am assuming that MS will flip something that will reveal that I am not lieing, and if he doesn't then I say Swift should shot me to eliminate WIFOM situation.

[Kise]

I'm (still) Magikoopa - Avenger. I have no clue

who's supposed to die before I get my buffs

but the flavor in my PM

may

suggest Bowser since that's the only individual character mentioned. Testing a mod-lynch doesn't seem worthwhile at the moment though.

I'm not a bomb nor vengeful townie. I'm a backup role. Looking over the character claims, I don't seem to be connected to anyone. So, could be another 0% role.

In Super Mario RPG: Legend of the Seven Stars, a brainwashed Magikoopa appears as a boss. This Magikoopa is intended to be Kamek due to him being old friends with Bowser and, if players read his mind with Mallow's Psychopath ability, the Magikoopa will state "That's... my child?", referring to Bowser, whom he raised. However, when the game was translated to English, the translators forgot about giving the name "Kamek" to the individual Magikoopa character and, as a result, Kamek was called "Magikoopa" in the English release. This has caused confusion among fans and led many to believe it was another character altogether.

I was able to catch this because I figured if I am someone's avenger, it'd be Kamek, but since Kamek apparently isn't in this video game, my theory has no validity.

But in other words, my lynch does nothing but end the day - can't shoot back at anyone.