Mini 1535 - Game Over

[SXTLHGaiden]

Thank you to everyone for playing. Here are my mod notes that pretty much have all the spoilers. http://www.quicktopic.com/50/H/Yg3PvUn3sYc3

[Surye]

havingFitz Roleblocks chamber (Success)
chamber Roleblocks kush (Failed)

Haha.

SXTLHGaiden, thanks for modding the game, it was a lot of fun.

[Surye]

DoctorPepper targets Surye (He didn't specify what he is targeting with, so it doesn't go through)

This is pretty game changing, I am pissed for town that it went down like that, as much as I am happy for winning.

[Albert B. Rampage]

Yeah, this game was majorly affected by DP's lack of specificity.

[Albert B. Rampage]

Chamber investigating Aegor was also a mistake. Aegor was conducive, even key, to the scum victory.

[Albert B. Rampage]

Rubicon's Dessew hammer was bad. My neighborizing havingfitz too.

Anyway, a whole bunch of mistakes, small and large, were made.

What a disappointing defeat.

[Rubicon]

GG guys. I enjoyed it, even though we lost - you three played very well, better than town overall.

Ugh, should I have not changed my mind about kushm4sta? On the one hand, obviously yes, but on the other, I don't know how I could reasonably have stuck with it here at the end. Surye, fitz and Gooner were all independently scummy in LyLo, but so was kush.

Biggest regrets are probably the Tommy and Dessew lynches. Without either of those we might still have won.

Still, good game. Thanks to Gaiden for moderating.

[Albert B. Rampage]

The Dessew hammer was even more disappointing than the investigation on Surye not going through.

[havingfitz]

[Surye]

GG guys. I enjoyed it, even though we lost - you three played very well, better than town overall.

Ugh, should I have not changed my mind about kushm4sta? On the one hand, obviously yes, but on the other, I don't know how I could reasonably have stuck with it here at the end. Surye, fitz and Gooner were all independently scummy in LyLo, but so was kush.

Biggest regrets are probably the Tommy and Dessew lynches. Without either of those we might still have won.

Still, good game. Thanks to Gaiden for moderating.

It may be self-awareness, but it really felt like you guys had the scum team most of the time, you just couldn't get it together between each other. Hell, you had 2/3 scum at L-1 on big wagons. Also, letting kush live to lylo was a mistake, if Aegor wanted him dead he should have campaigned for it much earlier and he should not have been given "You better contribute tomorrow!"

[Rubicon]

The Dessew hammer was even more disappointing than the investigation on Surye not going through.

yeah, regretted it instantly. Combination of impatience and worry that we might not lynch either him or Surye... which were both dumb reasons to hammer. bleh.

[Rubicon]

GG guys. I enjoyed it, even though we lost - you three played very well, better than town overall.

Ugh, should I have not changed my mind about kushm4sta? On the one hand, obviously yes, but on the other, I don't know how I could reasonably have stuck with it here at the end. Surye, fitz and Gooner were all independently scummy in LyLo, but so was kush.

Biggest regrets are probably the Tommy and Dessew lynches. Without either of those we might still have won.

Still, good game. Thanks to Gaiden for moderating.

It may be self-awareness, but it really felt like you guys had the scum team most of the time, you just couldn't get it together between each other. Hell, you had 2/3 scum at L-1 on big wagons. Also, letting kush live to lylo was a mistake, if Aegor wanted him dead he should have campaigned for it much earlier and he should not have been given "You better contribute tomorrow!"

pretty much.

[Gooner]

Chamber investigating Aegor was also a mistake. Aegor was conducive, even key, to the scum victory.

I'd argue that that one wasn't a mistake. Aegor would have been lynched the day before LYLO otherwise and we might have been able to swing it towards Dessew/kush in LYLO.

[Gooner]

GG guys. I enjoyed it, even though we lost - you three played very well, better than town overall.

Ugh, should I have not changed my mind about kushm4sta? On the one hand, obviously yes, but on the other, I don't know how I could reasonably have stuck with it here at the end. Surye, fitz and Gooner were all independently scummy in LyLo, but so was kush.

Biggest regrets are probably the Tommy and Dessew lynches. Without either of those we might still have won.

Still, good game. Thanks to Gaiden for moderating.

It may be self-awareness, but it really felt like you guys had the scum team most of the time, you just couldn't get it together between each other. Hell, you had 2/3 scum at L-1 on big wagons. Also, letting kush live to lylo was a mistake, if Aegor wanted him dead he should have campaigned for it much earlier and he should not have been given "You better contribute tomorrow!"

I echo this. At the end of every day I was certain you would get one of us the next day.

[Albert B. Rampage]

Chamber investigating Aegor was also a mistake. Aegor was conducive, even key, to the scum victory.

I'd argue that that one wasn't a mistake. Aegor would have been lynched the day before LYLO otherwise and we might have been able to swing it towards Dessew/kush in LYLO.

Wrong. Kush had better reads than Aegor.

[Surye]

Chamber investigating Aegor was also a mistake. Aegor was conducive, even key, to the scum victory.

I'd argue that that one wasn't a mistake. Aegor would have been lynched the day before LYLO otherwise and we might have been able to swing it towards Dessew/kush in LYLO.

Wrong. Kush had better reads than Aegor.

His reads were pretty bipolar. I was obvscum and obvtown so many times from him.

[Tommy]

I've never been a Day 1 lynch before. Does anyone have any advice on how I could have played better?

[Gooner]

I've never been a Day 1 lynch before. Does anyone have any advice on how I could have played better?

Not really, I feel you were a little bit unlucky to be lynched.

[Albert B. Rampage]

Tommy, you weren't bad. You asked for critcism, so here goes. Never self-hammer as town. Never.

Learn from the mistakes below:

Is this a bus? Is that how Albert can be so certain of Gooner's alignment? Are you lining me up for a D2 lynch already?

A decent point in favour of killing Pepper is that's been so hard to do. The Gooner counter-wagon, on the other hand, sprang up very quickly out of nowhere.

Next I'll show that Surye is town.

Overall, I think you did good. You just stood on the wrong side of the town and were an obstacle to lynching Gooner/Surye.

[Aegor]

Scum played well. I should have campaigned harder for kush's earlier lynch, as has been stated. But it sucks when scum is the most active subset of players.

[Gooner]

Scum played well. I should have campaigned harder for kush's earlier lynch, as has been stated. But it sucks when scum is the most active subset of players.

I'd say ABR, Fusion, Rubicon were more active.

But yeah too many lurky/useless townies means a scum win. So this game proved.

[Aegor]

I guess I count activity differently. Someone posting tons of one-liners is not that active to me.

[Albert B. Rampage]

Aegor how come you have a join date of 2007?

[Aegor]

I joined in 2007.

[Albert B. Rampage]

What were your years of activity? I don't remember you.