Mini 1650: Greatest Idea Mafia (Game Over)

[Dechs Kaison]

I really wanted to have some kind of role, but I got only vanilla cards.

Underdog seemed strictly worse than Town, but it was ten times more interesting.

[copper223]

The fact that with your role and Pirate Ika's early lynch there was a group of 4 werewolves made the game pretty imbalanced.

@KittyCupCake
Well played, you sure tricked me! I would have offered you a draw if the rules allowed it.

[Dechs Kaison]

Yeah. This game was anything but balanced. Town lynched threats all three days.

[Kaboose]

Don't forget with Ika alive Wolves could be NK immune too. That's rather imbalanced too haha

[Guyett]

gg scum

[Dechs Kaison]

Meh. Just an advantaged setup. Four wolves and two serial killers is essentially the field that seven townies had to handle.

If you'd have lynched town Day 1, I'd have been on your team, but you'd still be down an extra townie from the start. Not sure that would have been any better.

[Soren]

Scum got rekt.

[Soren]

Wait

Werewolves won?

Fuck....

[Soren]

This was impossible for town to win. So gg.

And I thought you were town copper...

Didn't realise there was a scum cop. I should pay attention to the roles next game.

Dechs you trickster...

[Dechs Kaison]

I was so tricky because even I didn't know what my alignment was.

[Soren]

Why did investigate kitty on night 2 copper?

[copper223]

I knew everyone else was town so she was the only one that could have been scum.

[pirate mollie]

wait you mean we had a team

IKA

[copper223]

Lol

[Guyett]

I wish we finished my chart on the first day

[guille2015]

I had tons of fun with this game.

Mollie/ika you need to work on your scum game. It was 20x more obvious than I or Needful were making it that you were scum, but since it was a meta argument, it was harder to argue.

I successfully protected myself and Prawn from dying Nightone, I'm happy I figured out that Kitty was scum night one. Seeing two Kills on Night one made me think that Kitty was town.

Also, Damn I just knew Copper was scum. That's probably a flaw of mine. It been several times already that I get a strong early Gut feeling that Someone is scum and can't figure out what really set it off. I have to improve that.

Anyways, I really enjoyed playing with everyone here, except with Whimping willow.

[copper223]

@Guille
Yes that was a nice read of yours, I was trying to play on the scummier side because with TTH in the game I couldn't play my run of the mill scum game and the whole: I want to pressure everyone before we lynch and I don't have solid scumreads was setting up for the cop claim later.

[pirate mollie]

I had tons of fun with this game.

Mollie/ika you need to work on your scum game.

It was 20x more obvious than I or Needful were making it that you were scum, but since it was a meta argument, it was harder to argue.

I successfully protected myself and Prawn from dying Nightone, I'm happy I figured out that Kitty was scum night one. Seeing two Kills on Night one made me think that Kitty was town.

Also, Damn I just knew Copper was scum. That's probably a flaw of mine. It been several times already that I get a strong early Gut feeling that Someone is scum and can't figure out what really set it off. I have to improve that.

Anyways, I really enjoyed playing with everyone here, except with Whimping willow.

why are you yelling at us

I really thought we were playing solo cos ika did not give me all the info. like I srsly didn't know that we had teammates I am sure ika told me at some point but it was lost in the ethers.

[copper223]

@Mollie
So you didn't know you were bussing me from the start?

[Whomping Willow]

Congrats wolves, thanks Zaicon.

This game was one giant mess

[pirate mollie]

@Mollie
So you didn't know you were bussing me from the start?

nope

did I even make a post in this game if I did it was mebbe 1

[Dechs Kaison]

This game was one giant mess

Well, yeah, I don't envy you basically being a serial killer.

Still, you could at least try to play.

[copper223]

nope

did I even make a post in this game if I did it was mebbe 1

Lol and I was trying to use this game to analyse your scum meta

[KittyCupCake]

Maybe I should have taken Werewolf-Immune Werewolf.

[Zaicon]

Role distribution is always fun.

Sent: Tue Mar 03, 2015 11:50 am
From: Zaicon
To: Dechs Kaison

You have drawn the following cards:

• Underdog [Survivor; Adapts the alignment of the first death]
  
• Vanilla Townie [Town; No special abilities]
  
• Vanilla Townie [Town; No special abilities]

That means you can form the following role combinations:

• Underdog [Survivor; Adapts the alignment of the first death]
  
• Vanilla Townie [Town; No special abilities]
  
• Underdog
  (Duplicate)
  
• Vanilla Townie
  (Duplicate)
  
• Vanilla Townie
  (Duplicate)
  
• Vanilla Townie
  (Duplicate)

Please choose one of those options to take as your Role for this game.

Such choices!

To: KittyCupCake

That means you can form the following role combinations:

• Werewolf-Immune Werewolf [Werewolf; Will not die from a werewolf factional kill]
  
• Werewolf Innocent Child
  (Forbidden)
  
• Serial Killer Innocent Child
  (Forbidden)

Well, who wouldn't give up the chance not to be NK'd by their own faction? And one of these days, I'll let there be a SK Inno Child (or Werewolf Inno Child) in a marathon game.

To: NeedfulThings

That means you can form the following role combinations:

• Alien Conspiracy Theorist [Alien; Alien investigator; Investigates as 'Alien' to Alien investigators]

If being a Mafia Cop wasn't bad enough, being an Alien Conspiracy Theorist means you'll ALSO be investigated as your alignment (Alien)! How horrible!

To: Pirate Ika

That means you can form the following role combinations:

• Mafia Miller [Mafia; Investigates as 'Mafia' to Mafia investigators]

Same as Mafia Cop, but you won't know if your teammates are your teammates or not.

Well, there wasn't many "interesting" options this game. Oh, well.