With the knowledge that Lincolm, Scooby, and City are town, let's re-evaluate.
Dividizzle
: He asks Lincolm why we would random lynch, and asks Nekoko and Lincolm to not read too much into the CityElectric post about Scooby. Then votes Scooby as soon as his V/LA got over. 33 can be seen two ways - genuine concern from town or frustrated scum since Lincolm, a townie was defending Scooby, another townie. Div continues questioning Lincolm due about Scooby's V/LA. In 71, Dividizzle takes Nekoko's side going so far as to say that he agrees with Nekoko. I doubt scum would do that among partners. I think it is more likely they would want to distance between themselves. I can't see Div/Nekoko scumteam.
Scooby comes in and votes Div after which Div switches to Lincolm. I really dislike this switch in 76. Scooby had done absolutely nothing to seem town-ish except vote Div, yell at him and OMGUS him. City then is happy with Scooby's vote. Considering that City was considered town by most players, she was de-facto leading the town. City being happy with Scooby co-inciding with Div's vote is bad for Div - makes me feel like he knew Scooby wagon wasn't going anywhere and was trying to placate Scooby. In 76, he also says that Lincolm's actions look very suspicious due to Lincolm's interactions with me. Div, why is this so? Can you elaborate on what your thought process was at that time? So, we have Div voting Scooby, then voting Lincolm after FOSsing him for a while and seeing Lincolm defend Scooby. There seemed to be a certain natural progression in suspicion so I can see this coming from town-Div.
Div's 81 was wierd. He claims that it was bad that I voted him but didn't say that it was L-1. He then turns to Scooby and takes his side asking what Scooby thought about Lincolm staying on him and me putting him at L-1. I don't like that he said that the entire game was revolving around Scooby. He could have simply talked to the people that were online and waited for Scooby to come back. I dislike 92 where Div apparently is only going to give reads if he is about to be hammered. What I really dislike here is Div, instead of shooting off reads like any normal townie would, why do wait to see if someone is going to hammer before you provide your reads? I mean, reads are how we advance the game and there is benefit to providing reads even if you don't get hammered. Upon re-reading 110 was good. The only issue I had was that he leans town on me for stopping and reconsidering because he knows that I am the swing vote and he needs to persuade me. That could be opportunism but it could also be a genuine read.
Bv310
: I disagree with his push to lynch Scooby in 35 while simultaneously asking for a replacement. It is good to get a replacement but why also push for a lynch as opposed to simply waiting for the replacement to show up? In a seven player game, two mislynches could end the game so a "lynch all lurkers" policy lynch is a terrible idea. BV argues with Nekoko regarding the Scooby lynch in 46 and votes Lincolm in the next post. In 58, BV continues to argue the point with Nekoko about whether should be spared. I really don't like this line of thinking and in a 7P game, it is a bad idea. BV's 67 advances the same line of reasoning. If there is one thing to be said, he is consistent about it. Lincolm also correctly points out in 77 that bv didn't yet answer why he dislikes Lincolm's post.
BV seemed eager to hammer Div in 88. Can't tell if it is because Divi is his buddy or if he is trying to stall on hammering a mislynch. With BV town, I can see some lazyness on his part just choosing to hammer without really offering any concrete opinions so far. All his contribution has been "policy-lynch scooby" and after Scooby got to be active, switch around to Div and offer a deadline hammer. Why no reads BV? What do you think about the other players so far? When prodded into explaining why he finds Div suspicious, he just says that the last two posts were somewhat scummy in 90. Don't like the vagueness in this post. Bv, I'd like an explanation as to what exactly it was about the last two posts of Div you found scummy. BV says he need all the info we can get with this setup but there was no real effort so far as to getting any information.
I don't like BV's 108. He states intent to hammer after two other people have also expressed intent to hammer. Desire to place a vote on a buddy? This points towards DV/Div team. I could see BV/Div team after BV switched to Lincolm in 120 after I unvote Div and Scooby switches as well. This after he declared that he would hammer div in a conspicuous manner. It was a voting error but the intent was that he wanted to add his vote.
Nekoko
: Nekoko switches from BV to Div in 37. Says there is no reason to vote for inactives and is shocked by bv's comment regarding lynching Scooby. Nekoko's next switch is from div to BV310 in 56. He gives reasoning for voting after BV responded to his earlier FOS. At first glance, this interaction felt like it wasn't between buddies but looking again, it could potentially be manufactured argument knowing that the wagon isn't likely to reach a lynch. 60, however seems like a very good portrayal of the situation leading me to possibly scratch the manufactured argument theory. Nekoko looks at the big picture and tries to clarify his point with regard to Scooby.
I don't like Nekoko saying in 91 that 71 was a buddying attempt. It is possible he is distancing from his buddy. Scratch what I said about eliminating a Div/Nekoko scumteam because I don't like the distancing here. Perhaps Div made a mistake agreeing with Nekoko and Nekoko wanted to put enough distance between the two of them by accusing Div of buddying. That way, if Div flips scum, it will seem as though he was buddying to Nekoko, a townie. The unvote on Bv310 doesn't seem like scum-scum interaction. Div was going to likely get lynched. Bad move to unvote your buddy at that point. Would have been nice to keep pushing the distancing factor. Nekoko then turns to Dividizzle - can be interpreted as bussing. He defends Lincoln and says that Div looks bad. However, the thought process of figuring out Lincoln's exact motivations comes across as townish.
Nekoko also offers to hammer Dividizzle. Again, the 107 seemed somewhat unnecessary. Nekoko, why do you have a gut town read on BV when you think he is lurking? I don't understand it. Please explain.
Summary
I have been trying to find associative tells under every possible combination. As you can see, some tells are weak, some are strong. Overall, I am leaning towards a Bv/Div team but I am not certain in those reads. I'd like to see more posts coming in.
Key points: I don't like that Div had only interacted much with known townies until he was pressured. There wasn't much bv/div interaction except bv's offer to hammer. There are some things about Nekoko I didn't like either such as that quick admonishment of Div for buddying when all he did was agree with Nekoko. But overall, Nekoko seems to be that townie but we should all really get active and lynch scum. Inactivity favors the scum factions. I didn't have a lot of time to spare for this game but I do now and hopefully, this post will spark some discussion.
