Mini #71- Justice League Mafia OVER

[Gammie]

I really, REALLY need to bold as I type and not save it for last.

Vote: Gin

Gosh, I even previewed that, too

[Morpheus]

well, since 3 mafia are already dead i don't think theres more then 1 baddie left Gammie.

[gin]

Way to bandwagon me without a role claim

For what it's worth, I was Martian Manhunter - I could disguise myself each night with a certain possibility of it failing.

Hence the potted plant - I assume it was ment to be me in disguise.

but to be honest, you've let that day go by so quickly without gaining much it makes me sad

woe.

My analysis and vote still stands for what it's worth - willows_weep's room just seems suspicious without pointing to any justice leaguer.

G & T
- bandwagoned.

[Morpheus]

ok i won't unvote yet since i am waiting to see if scalbane objects

[Scalebane]

I am going to assume that it is actually 4 to lynch and since he already has three, I am going to hold off on voting until he roleclaims.

[gin]

I am going to assume that it is actually 4 to lynch and since he already has three, I am going to hold off on voting until he roleclaims.

erm, I have roleclaimed - I'm Martian Manhunter. I can camoflague myself to give my chance of avoiding death by night....

Here's hoping it's 4 to lynch,

G & T

[Scalebane]

I agree with the hoping it is 4 to lynch as well. I can't dispute your roleclaim, and as such, I am glad I didn't vote you. Not quite sure who to go for, though.

[gin]

Btw where would Ivy fit in if it all in this game? Or is that just a batman thing...I am asking because reading about the plant triggered my memory of the cartoon.

From a quick google it appears Poison Ivy only ever appeared in the comics, not the cartoon which I think we're based on? Though I could be wrong about that...

I agree with the hoping it is 4 to lynch as well. I can't dispute your roleclaim, and as such, I am glad I didn't vote you. Not quite sure who to go for, though.

This is really why I went for willows_weep, that was the most evidence I could see out of Clark Kent's post (which incidentally confirms we probably have superman somewhere methinks). But I don't really know now - I'm going to sleep on it and see if it's any clearer by morning

G & T

[Gammie]

From a quick google it appears Poison Ivy only ever appeared in the comics, not the cartoon which I think we're based on? Though I could be wrong about that...

No, Gin, Poison Ivy was in the cartoons...plenty of times.

[Gammie]

And yes, it's 4 to lynch...4 is the majority of 7. I wouldn't have lynched without a roleclaim, although you are very suspicious to me. Mods just made a mistake on that.

Just incase you may be innocent (I'm not saying I think you are) and mafia is around, I'll unvote so they can't pull crap.

Unvote: Gin
Huge FoS

for the timebeing on him though

[Scalebane]

Uh gammie, I beg to differ. I really beg to differ. I'll provide the link if people want, but we are based on Justice Leauge, and poison Ivy has yet to appear in the series. I am simply stunned that after all this time, you don't even know what the game is based upon.

[Gammie]

Scalebane, JL has Batman in it? Correct? Poison Ivy = One of Batman's enemies, just like Joker is/was.

Which made me think when everyone started talking about Poison Ivy, because she's associated with Batman, and Joker was already a role. I would think there wouldn't be another Batman-related bad guy.

[Gammie]

I've done some research on Gin's claim, Martian Manhunter meaning you are J'onn?

[Morpheus]

unvote: gin

I guess that claim is reasonable. And, I would like to say the last guy on my list is scalebane so

vote scalebane

[Morpheus]

ok i got an idea maybe now everyone should role claim so we can get the mafia. Anyone second that?

[bloojay]

sorry, that was a mod error.
and you forgot a baddie Gammie, Darkseid...

[Scalebane]

Actually, YOU are last on my last, Morpheus. I know this is probably going to come across as an OMGUS vote, but I think the town needs to know something about you if you are going to "lead" us to a victory.

Vote morpheus

[Morpheus]

ir right it does sound like an OMGUS vote

[Morpheus]

ir right it does sound like an OMGUS vote

I meant your right (Aim typing (ur) and fast typing i missed the u)

[willows_weep]

When I said the cartoon I hadn't meant jl. I was talking about batman's cartoon. I have only seen a few epi's of jl. Used to watch batman and superman regularly though.


And what did you mean, if anything by
Scalebane said:

Actually, YOU are last on my last, Morpheus. I know this is probably going to come across as an OMGUS vote, but I think the town needs to know something about you if you are going to "lead" us to a victory.

[willows_weep]

See gin...I really don't get why you are voting for me...first you said the pin ups...then my comment on Ivy (which you misunderstood it seems from what the qoute following these words say)...

Gin said:

willows_weep wrote:
Btw where would Ivy fit in if it all in this game? Or is that just a batman thing...I am asking because reading about the plant triggered my memory of the cartoon.


From a quick google it appears Poison Ivy only ever appeared in the comics, not the cartoon which I think we're based on? Though I could be wrong about that...

Scalebane wrote:
I agree with the hoping it is 4 to lynch as well. I can't dispute your roleclaim, and as such, I am glad I didn't vote you. Not quite sure who to go for, though.


This is really why I went for willows_weep, that was the most evidence I could see out of Clark Kent's post (which incidentally confirms we probably have superman somewhere methinks). But I don't really know now - I'm going to sleep on it and see if it's any clearer by morning

But I have already said that when I said " is that a batman thing"
I was talking about Ivy being on batman cartoon. Not about being on JL cartoon.

...someone mentioned an sk role? Where the sk just wants people dead? Mafia or not it doesn't care?
You really are putting me in a box with options here...and only sk to me is a role in a box with options...and so yea...I am FOS'ing you...because if there is an sk...(which I think scalebane first mentioned)
and they would vote for anyone then yea...I am not voting you because I don't know what the vote count is yet and because my answer to morpheus' idea is that:

(see next post It's so much...)

[willows_weep]

Continued from previous post:

It seems to me that an everyone roleclaim thing would be almost useless because most people have JL role claimed and havent been proven wrong, and the last newspaper hinted at and gave out more Roles...so I don't think it would be to hard for someone to claim a real JL role but not really be that person.

That's why I am wary of your idea Morpheus

But is there anyway a mass roleclaim can actually be of use?
My issue is that, if it's now easy to think of the most likely characters here( or a pretty good idea) , then one could easily pick one that can't easily be disputed, but a lie all the same.
Oh wait...special powers are also a good way of identifying? That is if there can only be like one Yggsdrasil(WW?)...who has the docs power of protecting right? And Gammie(GL?) with not being able to be killed at night?
Hey...Gin(MM?) so you can protect yourself by shape shifting and are you saying you did the PLANT morph just...cause...??( I am asking that question , not attempting an answer type question...hard to get that across with just typing..for me anyway)
Is there anything else claimed that I am missing?
(Oh the parenthesis by the players name contain the jl roles they have claimed )

For what it's worth, I was Martian Manhunter - I could disguise myself each night with a certain possibility of it failing.

Hence the potted plant - I assume it was ment to be me in disguise.

And well I will read and read the post some more after I post this...then go to bed. I will come check the thread around...7am, after my shower.


Oh and scalebane, when I asked what you meant about Morpheus I mean
is there something you know about Morpheus , or are you saying that in general Morpheus should give information( Just making sure I explain that a bit more just in case. I worry about the way I talk, people sometimes get lost because I leave words out, or have toooooo many words...convoluted sentences, incorrect parallel structure stuff like that...)

Oh yea...

FOS Gin

[Scalebane]

unvote: gin I guess that claim is reasonable. And, I would like to say the last guy on my list is scalebane so vote scalebane

That post by morpheus is the origin of the way I worded my post. And no, I have no special information about morpheus, it is just that he seems to want everybody else to roleclaim without wanting to do so himself.

[gin]

See gin...I really don't get why you are voting for me...first you said the pin ups...then my comment on Ivy (which you misunderstood it seems from what the qoute following these words say)...

Gin said:

willows_weep wrote:
Btw where would Ivy fit in if it all in this game? Or is that just a batman thing...I am asking because reading about the plant triggered my memory of the cartoon.


From a quick google it appears Poison Ivy only ever appeared in the comics, not the cartoon which I think we're based on? Though I could be wrong about that...

Scalebane wrote:
I agree with the hoping it is 4 to lynch as well. I can't dispute your roleclaim, and as such, I am glad I didn't vote you. Not quite sure who to go for, though.


This is really why I went for willows_weep, that was the most evidence I could see out of Clark Kent's post (which incidentally confirms we probably have superman somewhere methinks). But I don't really know now - I'm going to sleep on it and see if it's any clearer by morning

But I have already said that when I said " is that a batman thing"
I was talking about Ivy being on batman cartoon. Not about being on JL cartoon.

Sorry if this was misconstrewed - I was trying to reply to 2 people at once, they weren't ment to be taken together. Apologies if they were.

My meaning was: From a quick google Poison Ivy has never appeared in Justice League the TV cartoon - only in the comic (I believe the only Batman villain is the Joker)... I think we're based on the former, therefore unlikely to have Poison Ivy as a villain. I didn't however mean to link this comment to my continued voting, although you defensively seemed to think I did. I feel it's unlikely for her to appear as on one of the sites on the show there is an interview with the makers of the show, who specifically state they are trying to avoid using Batman villains because they are too well known and cliche. This was infact a site you also visited and apparently read through: http://jl.toonzone.net/ Though of course as I don't really watch the show I can't be sure she hasn't appeared.

The second paragraph was purely to explain why I chose to continue to vote for you in response to scalebane's post. With all mafia dead (probably) we only have the SK to catch. Who is unlikely to show any links with the mafia, and therefore is harder to catch - we're almost back to a day 1 situation in that respect...

Possibly the best way might be a mass role claim at this point, though it's hard to say if it would benefit us or the killer more. Hard to say, though it would be interesting to hear people's viewpoints on this...

...someone mentioned an sk role? Where the sk just wants people dead? Mafia or not it doesn't care?
You really are putting me in a box with options here...and only sk to me is a role in a box with options...and so yea...I am FOS'ing you...because if there is an sk...(which I think scalebane first mentioned)
and they would vote for anyone then yea...I am not voting you because I don't know what the vote count is yet and because my answer to morpheus' idea is that:

(see next post It's so much...)

The SK probably does just want people dead, and I admit that were I the SK I would vote for those without claims as that is the least suspicious way. However what worries me is the speed at which people bandwagoned me yesterday on the assumption I would be lynched after 3 - my bets are on that one of those people is either remaining mafiascum or remaining SK hoping for a quick lynch with little to come out of it.

I don't get all your talk about a role in a box. You seem to be playing the ignorance card a little to heavily there too, though that may just be my interpretation.

I'm sticking my vote - what I'm getting so far is fairly interesting... Plus I have noone better to vote for at the moment.

G & T

[gin]

But is there anyway a mass roleclaim can actually be of use? My issue is that, if it's now easy to think of the most likely characters here( or a pretty good idea) , then one could easily pick one that can't easily be disputed, but a lie all the same.

Well, it's easy enough to think of characters but it's hard to fake roleclaim a major role as you'll be disputed by the real one. And if you pick rare ones you're pretty silly - those who have were evidently scum before.

Unless there's an SK who's a member of the league... Mm.

Bugger.

Hey...Gin(MM?) so you can protect yourself by shape shifting and are you saying you did the PLANT morph just...cause...??( I am asking that question , not attempting an answer type question...hard to get that across with just typing..for me anyway)
Is there anything else claimed that I am missing?
(Oh the parenthesis by the players name contain the jl roles they have claimed )

No, my ability is passive - I don't have to choose to morph. The mod presumably chose a plant because it was green, as am I. Not very helpful to the snoop though

I hope it's clear that the Martian Manhunter (J’onn J’onzz) would be here, and that he would be pro town...

Thanks,

G & T