Mini 1408: Playing with Fire - Game Over!

[mastin2]

Scum QT?

I'll let the mod release it. If the mod doesn't, then I will.

[orcinus_theoriginal]

What, but zar and qwints thought I was town

Bacde was the only SK read on me, but that was pretty shocking to be honest. I thought I would be lynched for sure.

[Bacde]

Good game guys

I'm getting better with every loss

[orcinus_theoriginal]

Bacde and fitz were excellent townies.

I was scared shitless of them both.

In any case, good game folks, see you guys around

[killerjester]

Roles:

1. qwints - VT
2. Bacde - Town Doctor
3. Zar/Kenman - VT
4. Ztife - Mafia Goon
5. AngryPidgeon/Om - Mafia Roleblocker
6. Vifam/absta101 - Town Innocent Child
7. ThAdmiral - VT
8. orcinus_theoriginal - Arsonist
9. mastin2/ZONEACE - Mafia Goon
10. Xisiqomelir/Deltabacon - VT
11. Rondar - Town Cop
12. Revenus - VT
13. havingfitz/Bitmap/Sibelius - VT

Spoiler: Night Actions

PREGAME
orcinus_theoriginal chooses 1 shot BP

NIGHT 1
Rondar investigates Bacde (Result: Innocent on Bacde)
Bacde protects absta101 (is Roleblocked)
AngryPidgeon roleblocks Bacde
mastin2 kills Revenus (Result: Revenus dies)
orcinus_theoriginal douses havingfitz (Result: Successful)
Players doused thus far: havingfitz

NIGHT 2
Bacde protects Vifam
AngryPidgeon roleblocks ThAdmiral
mastin2 kills Zar (Result: Zar dies)
orcinus_theoriginal douses AngryPidgeon (Result: Successful)
Players doused thus far: havingfitz, AngryPidgeon

NIGHT 3
Bacde protects Vifam
AngryPidgeon roleblocks orcinus_theoriginal
mastin2 kills qwints (Result: qwints dies)
orcinus_theoriginal burns doused players (Result: Unsuccessful, is Roleblocked)
Players doused thus far: havingfitz, AngryPidgeon

NIGHT 4
Bacde protects Vifam
AngryPidgeon roleblocks orcinus_theoriginal
mastin2 kills Bacde (Result: Bacde dies)
orcinus_theoriginal douses Vifam (Result: Unsuccessful, is Roleblocked)
Players doused thus far: havingfitz, AngryPidgeon

NIGHT 5
SCUM
AngryPidgeon roleblocks orcinus_theoriginal
mastin2 kills Xisiqomelir (Result: Xisiqomelir dies)
orcinus_theoriginal burns doused players (Result: Unsuccessful, is Roleblocked)
Players doused thus far: AngryPidgeon

Scum QT: http://www.quicktopic.com/48/H/2Rd93meD4uJ
Dead QT: http://www.quicktopic.com/49/H/XvH4WMi83RVZY

[mastin2]

It wasn't so much you-as-town/scum, so much as it was that almost-universally, Xisi was seen as town.
I, personally, had a legitimate scumread on him. (I wouldn't have tried to make a case on him if I was BS'ing. I seriously thought he was playing weird.) I, personally, thought he very well could be the SK.

But every single dead town player (except fitz) had him as town, and I thought there had to be a reason for that.
And fitz had you as his #1 scum read. Despite how we mislynched him, I wanted to trust that he wasn't *entirely* wrong this game, and that he *did* have something legitimate on you.

Hence, why it was really the dead-town which ensured we could catch you.

[Bacde]

Awesome, I felt bad about not protecting Revenus on N1 but looking at the QT it seems like he wouldn't have been protected anyway

[Bacde]

Also, lol @AngryPidgeon for not understanding when I was directly softing doctor

TO HIM

IN THREAD

[AngryPidgeon]

Fitz was super obvtown this game.

I was sweating bullets after I accidentally scum claimed and the game wasn't over. Mastin did the sensible thing and we went ahead with assuming Orcinus was our SK.

@Revenus: I wanted you dead. You were too active. I dont even remember your reads that much, but you were obviously town, never getting mislynched, and likely to lead wagons.

ok yeah AP is trying to compete with orc for dumbest townie award

Also, AngryPidgeon calling qwints/fitz both town makes my scumdar tingle.

No wait that's my idiotdar

Anyways, AP is probably scum then.

mwa ha ha.

[Bacde]

I wanna apologize to Having_Fitz

Sorry, Fitz

[AngryPidgeon]

Im shocked that Orcinus didn't push for mastin in mylo.

[Revenus]

Congratz to scum.

vifam, worst town player ever. blacklisted.

[orcinus_theoriginal]

Well, it wasn't actually mylo. But I was afraid of being seen as scum, especially since I tossed mastin a town read the day earlier. I didn't know that I was being RBd, and I figured that if I survived the day I would be able to end up in lylo if not win outright.

pedit hi revenus

[killerjester]

Criticism of one's play is fine. Let's keep the cussing and personal attacks out of it, ok?

[Revenus]

My bad


Vifam, you are really not a good player. Try and actually read the game next time.

[ThAdmiral]

Yeah Vifam hurt us. The rondar hammer was too soon and the xisi vote was too late. I think so played well enough to probably win anyway, short of being killed by the arson.

Btw mastin where was the self vote? Coward!
Yet another example of town losing because they didn't listen to me, lol.

[ThAdmiral]

For some reason my phone translated "ap" as "so".

[AngryPidgeon]

I really didn't know how to handle that mastin wagon that sprang up. I really really didn't want to lose the ability to rb and kill every night. I was really glad vifam thought he was town ultimately so I cpuld just ride that wave.

Also I totally nailed the setup spec.

[Revenus]

You should be more glad that Vifam early hammered town cop.

I found this particularly amusing

It was either

1. Lynch Rondar
2. Go into the night without a lynch

considering he allowed a NL to go through the next day while he was active.

[havingfitz]

Ah well....a very frustrating game. Scum deserved to win because town had their heads up their arses. Seriously...Vifam....the fact you were confirmed town and made it to the end of the game should tell you something about your play. And Xisi...your case on me which you were happy to just blindly tunnel me with was so incredibly bad....this:

orcinus and xisi...this only applies to you if you are town (which I suspect means it only applies to xisi)...you're idiots.

...truly does apply.

I wanted to trust that he wasn't *entirely* wrong this game

What *entirely* wrong do you speak of? The *entirely* wrong on being of the Arsonist the entire time I was in the game and on you the day ThAd died?

Aside from Vifam and Xisi I enjoyed playing with most everyone. I didn't enjoy playing with orcinus but since he was scum he gets a complete pass. Nice job. I can't believe town didn't see my case on you and even moreso...I can't believe scum didn't take the opportunity to piggyback on you. I guess if they had a clue you were the arsonist and could just keep on RBing you while we went back and forth it was to their benefit.

And congrats to AP....very good game. I had a niggling feeling you could be scum but you were far enough down my list that I never tried to make a case on you. And with this lineup of players it wouldn't have stood a chance anyway. The day I was lynched I did spend a good bit of time looking over the voting history and asked myself a few times wtf you couldn't be scum. Trouble was everyone else could be too. Nice job.

Really enjoyed the set up mod. Thanks for modding a fun (though frustrating) game.

[havingfitz]

Dyslexia correction BWOP:

"The *entirely* wrong on being of the Arsonist" should read "The *entirely* wrong of being on the Arsonist"

[Ztife]

Good game guys =D I just rode the win literally lol.

[mastin2]

Btw mastin where was the self vote? Coward!

I actually would have, if not for the fact that Xisi and Orc both voted fitz, and I had a shot of getting a mislynch to win the game right then and there.

Would have made a nice AtE.

I really didn't know how to handle that mastin wagon that sprang up. I really really didn't want to lose the ability to rb and kill every night. I was really glad vifam thought he was town ultimately so I cpuld just ride that wave.

Also I totally nailed the setup spec.

You handled it quite well, AP. And, yeah, you were dang-good at nailing what we did and didn't have, even if you were a bit off on who had it.

I can't believe town didn't see my case on you and even moreso...I can't believe scum didn't take the opportunity to piggyback on you.

Well, I didn't know Orc was the SK and I didn't know for certain you were town 'til after you'd been hammered. Butyeah. After you died, I wanted to trust your Orc read was well-founded, even if he was just the SK and not groupscum.

I never took advantage of the not-mafiaVnot-mafia because it was advantageous of us to delay it for as long as possible. If we made it to lylo rather than plain mylo, you two crossvoting would be an outright immediate scum win for us. As it was, keeping you both alive allowed for the quickhammer in mylo.

[Rondar]

Yeah no way I'm rereading what happened, but good game. Lol. Can't say I suspected AP much. GG and good job to both of you.

[Rondar]

All three of you, I guess =P