Unstable Mafia - Game Over

[rosterfoster]

DT's role is eh, but even with just the cop pair I would expect a really strong scum role to compensate the Rabbi thing and PT watcher fits the bill.

[Vedith]

It's a bastard game. It could easily make sense that Stefan could the VT into Scum and Stefan still be town.

[Vedith]

So I guess working out balance is worthless here

[rosterfoster]

I have no incentive to lie about this as either alignment, so you can check this if you want, but in my PT's it was:

N1 with DT: 0 mentions
N2 with Vedith: 2 mentions
N3 with Stefan: 1 mention
N4 with Lich: 2 mentions

[rosterfoster]

N1 Creature number suggests he miscounted. Also possible he couldn't see the PT N1.

[Vedith]

I believe your mentions and agree no reason to lie.
I'm saying that Creature saying 4 doesn't make sense if he can see other PTs

[Creature]

I got four mentions N1. Three were likely from scum (including pignash I think), dunno about the other one.

[rosterfoster]

Like maybe he has to choose somebody to view their PT's.

4 makes even less sense if he's a schizophrenic no? Much more likely he miscounted/couldn't see N1 so thought we said twice, then accounting for puppet made it 4.

[Vedith]

I dont think Creature struggles to count to 4 here.
And I don't think the viewing PT would be after N1 if it existed.

It's not a decider on alignments but I doubt the PT viewing theory

[Creature]

Pretty sure I would doublecheck or even triplecheck as scum.

[rosterfoster]

But there's me and Lich who have PT's so maybe he can choose a person and view all their PT's for the night. That might be most plausible, and he didn't choose me N1 so didn't know how many mentions when I claimed.

[rosterfoster]

Yeah OK I agree miscounting is unlikely. Choosing somebody is more possible.

[Vedith]

Hmmm actually that's possible.

[Vedith]

I think I want to talk to Stefan.

[rosterfoster]

Vedith how can he explain 4 mentions as Schizophrenic? I'm pretty sure he said mod confirmed it was only mentions in PTs and even if it wasn't nobody has ever visited him.

[Creature]

gotta admit rosterfoster has a great creativity.

[rosterfoster]

I'll go to bed now and let you talk to Stefan. I'm pretty sure mechanically Creature is lying about N1 mentions though.

[Creature]

though, why tf would my role be named Schizophrenic then?

[Vedith]

Vedith how can he explain 4 mentions as Schizophrenic? I'm pretty sure he said mod confirmed it was only mentions in PTs and even if it wasn't nobody has ever visited him.

I'm saying it's a good chance he just lied over it.
It's also a chance that dead PT/mod PT is included and even the mod counts with the name.

[rosterfoster]

Maybe you just have great creativity? <3

Pedit: N1 Lich said that nothing was said in dead PT I think.

[Creature]

thought my role specified players.

[rosterfoster]

During N1 I should add

[Creature]

I wonder if him or you missed a mention, like "him".

[Vedith]

Can you double check?

[rosterfoster]

Didn't you say it has to be the same name? Because then you-know-who's would count also.

N1 we didn't discuss you at all. I'm pretty sure it would have come up during claiming if we did btw so you should believe that.