Mini 114 Spongebob Mafia Game Over

[TBuG]

I'm fine with that. All that's left are Oswin, Fuldu, and vIQleS.

Me: Mr. Krabs, Townie
JDTAY: Gary, Townie
Morpheus: Wormy, somewhat of a Cop

[vIQleS]

Ok, I did read that, but I didn't write it down in my sheet.

UNVOTE: Morph

(Even though I don't really believe that...)

Role claims do seem to be the order of the day...

Can we do it in order of suspiciousness? Actually never mind - oswin and fuldu are almost equal...

I will role claim now even tho I'm not suspicious - no one's going to claim my role:

I am Plankton (the Townie). I know, I know, evil right? Actually I'm not. I've given up trying to steal krabby patties, but I was told that my status could change overnight. I am guessing that if the computer targetted me that we would become a mafia, but she's dead, so: Townie for life...

[Morpheus]

Hmm. Interesting role. Believeable as Flying Dutchman was a townie. Next...

[TBuG]

Erm, vIQleS, if you're talking about my claim (reading but not writing down), I claimed a while back.

Sticking with Oswin.

[Oswin]

Fine...I think my role claim is in order...I am...

Patrick Star! The Hall Monitor Sidekick! (In essence a back-up cop)

There! That is my role....

[Oswin]

And I forgot to add that I investigated Fuldu and got a scummy answer....

[vIQleS]

No, I meant morpheus...

Well unless Fuldu has anything to say...

[Fuldu]

Well, I can say "Nyeah, nyeah, I told you so."

unvote: Morpheus; revote: Oswin

.

First of all, his result is wrong, and I'd be interested to hear what his other results were. Secondly, why did he wait until after everyone had claimed in order to deliver this guilty result? We've been stalled all day and he never bothered to vote for me. In fact, he still hasn't voted for me. Third, didn't he say he had no idea why bloojay might have "known" PopsicleStix was scum. If he's a backup cop, it seems like he would have had a decent idea what the reason might be.

[TBuG]

Well, claiming Backup Cop right off the bat would have been a death wish. And no-one is proving it wrong, and Patrick is a quite obvious role.

Unvote: Oswin, Vote: Fuldu

Fuldu, of course you're gonna say that his result is wrong. He's saying you're scum!

[JDTAY]

Well, I do think we have to lynch correctly today or the mafia will win, so a gambit like claiming cop is possible. I want to hear Fuldu's role though, he's the only player who has yet to claim.

[Fuldu]

Well, I do think we have to lynch correctly today or the mafia will win, so a gambit like claiming cop is possible. I want to hear Fuldu's role though, he's the only player who has yet to claim.

Yeah, I think the reasons I gave in my previous post, especially the second and third are sufficient. There's no reason that Oswin wouldn't have voted for me earlier in the day if he'd had a guilty result. But, I'll add to the list of reasons the one that I had in the last post and then removed.

Fourth, Oswin was the one who brought up this stupid full claim notion, even though he supposedly had information about who was guilty. Push for a bandwagon on me and try to get me to claim; why risk outing another important role with a mass claim when you have useful information to go on? The whole claim is completely inconsistent with his behavior today.

PBuG, I'm not saying he should have claimed and given his result, but he could have at least tried to get me lynched at some point during the day. The best he has is a comment about having a reason to believe I'm scum that looked enough like a joke that I didn't take it seriously (nor did anyone else). At no point did he vote for me, and, even after coming out, he still didn't. When I'm a cop with a guilty result, I just itch to find the right way to get that vote out there and see what I can do with it. Oswin has done nothing of the sort.

So it puts me in the unenviable position of a) being the only one not to claim, which looks suspicious (especially to PBuG, apparently), b) lying about my role to the town, which, quite frankly, I don't like to do, but I did consider, or c) letting scum know that I'm Old Man Jenkins, the backup doc and (being the only valuable role left) getting killed tonight. So you can see why I was trying to avoid claiming and why I think the mass claim was stupid.

[JDTAY]

Well, I have to admit, I find Fuldu's role unlikely, but I find Morpheus' role to be even more unlikely. With at least two mafia left, you'd think they'd be working together, and it seems like Morpheus and Oswin could be, even if Oswin is likely to be Patrick. There's nothing that says Patrick, or really anyone can't be mafia.

My vote remains on Morpheus.

[Morpheus]

Maybe Patrick is too obvious. I mean.... He might be telling the truth. I mean although that would seem like three cops but since I am not a cop just find out results, the other two seem to make a little sense. But still, a back-up doc seems pretty likely to me.

vote oswin

[JDTAY]

Okay, it's more obvious to me than ever that Oswin and Morpheus are in cahoots. I hope that the rest of the town recognizes such.

[Oswin]

I didnt vote earlier and claim earlier because I wanted to make sure that there was only 2 scum left....and why are you so suspicious of me not claiming when you have yet to claim? So...

VOTE: Fuldu

...and if I said I knew how bloo knew Pop was SK then I was practically role claiming right there!

But remeber people...a lynch of me is a win for the scum!

[TBuG]

Unvote: Fuldu, Vote: Oswin

*prays he is right* Two backup docs isn't logical. It's getting WAY too obvious that Oswin and Morpheus are trying to save thier big ol' scummy butts. I've been fairly certain of Mopheus's scumminess until his claim, but now I'm sure of him and Oswin.

[JDTAY]

Well, we should get one of them lynched, and noone else is voting for Morpheus.

unvote: Morpheus
vote: Oswin

[Oswin]

What are you talking about? I said I was a back-up COP not doc! But remember.....if you lynch me scum wins....

[JDTAY]

Well, I just made the fourth, lynching vote, so let's hope you're lying.

[Oswin]

You poor fool....you just let the scum win....poor, poor fool....

[JDTAY]

I just checked the vacation thread and blackhawk said we won't be back until at least the 8th. This is going to a looooong twilight. But hey, as long as the scum are eventually lynched, I'm fine.

[JDTAY]

*he, not we

[Oswin]

You might as well stop playing because you just lynched me...and I am the back-up COP!...So basically....scum won and town lost...

[TBuG]

*whacks self on head*

[JDTAY]

Oh bah, PBuG, he's bluffing.