NY 142: Rolling in the Deep, WAIT WAT? PARTY OVER?!

[Beck]

Cause I think he could be scum too

[Slandaar]

a read you'll find consistent throughout my iso.

This confirms pops is scum to me...

I mean really, who thinks about their ISO as town?

[Beck]

a read you'll find consistent throughout my iso.

This confirms pops is scum to me...

I mean really, who thinks about their ISO as town?

probably the same kind of person who claims they have had the most solid reads out of everyone in the game.

[Pine]

Nice not scummy at all vote Hiraki.

It isn't. Hiraki has been consistently wanting a Pops lynch.

His unvote and revote is scummy though.

Nothing else really significant happened over night except Slandaar's claim. You don't unvote someone claiming VT, nor someone self-voting. It's on page three and seven of the scum handbook, respectively, and those moves are designed to produce the uncertainty some of you are now feeling. I swear to god, half of this thread has unmedicated ADHD when it comes to their votes.

[Maxous]

^
*sigh*

Anyway if there is a feasible Screaming Hawk wagon I am game for it.

Anyways I am VT, you should lynch me today as im pretty confident my reads are good.

This is not an obv town-tell. I have seen scum do this before when they thought they were in trouble to get lynched.

no lynch me, there is no point lynching someone who has no reads, i am SURE pine and pops are scum, you need to lynch me to see this though.

And this makes double negative sense.

Btw if pine is actually scum, I'm gonna be really pissed I was right and told I was stupid.

Pine seems very town to me...but maybe I have'nt got to that part yet :S

P-Edit: Sigh was at Slaandar.. but you know what, add it for the Beck's above post too.

[chkflip]

Day One, Vote Count the Twentieth (srs, idk if I should be happy or cry -- 80 pages? ffffuuuuu)

Slandaar (6): ThAdmiral, popsofctown, Pine, vijay2vasandani, Sky, Slandaar
SodaSpirit17 (5): IAAUN, theamatuer, mastin2, Velzanath, Hiraki
vijay2vasandani (3): SodaSpirit17, ScreamingHawk, Shattered Viewpoint
Revenus (2): sorgster, bvoigt
Popsofctown (2): Zdenek, ZeL1nk
Hiraki (1): Revenus
Not Voting (2): Maxous, funkybike1

WITH TWENTY-TWO ALIVE, IT'S TWELVE TO LYNCH.
DEADLINE: NOVEMBER 3RD @ 11PM PACIFIC STANDARD TIME.

[Pine]

Anyways I am VT, you should lynch me today as im pretty confident my reads are good.

This is not an obv town-tell. I have seen scum do this before when they thought they were in trouble to get lynched.

I've not only seen it, I've pulled it off with some success, too.

[Beck]

Since soda has a bunch of votes, what is the case on him?

[Pine]

The case was somewhat reasonable, but not especially strong. What I'm baffled about is why people are still voting for him when he's replaced out. Almost as if they want to ignore his replacement.

[theamatuer]

This isn't the longest large normal out there.
Think we should try for the max?

[Beck]

Mod, I don't think IamUsername is voting Soda

[Maxous]

I assume the TL;DR of the soda spirit case is active lurking?

I would give the replacement a chance for Day 2 tbh.

[mastin2]

Oh, right.

Sorry. Forgot 'bout this game. Will come back a little later.

[popsofctown]

a read you'll find consistent throughout my iso.

This confirms pops is scum to me...

I mean really, who thinks about their ISO as town?

probably the same kind of person who claims they have had the most solid reads out of everyone in the game.

Or the kind of person who has just been told, "I'm about to read your iso right after you answer this question".

Slandaar is a scum PR or Hiraki buddy that very much wants to live. Moar Slandaar votes please.

pedit: yeah, sodaspirit's case is active lurking and a sheepy voting record. It's totally unreasonable not to evaluate his replacement.

[Slandaar]

probably the same kind of person who claims they have had the most solid reads out of everyone in the game.

This made me lol

I mean really, you completely misunderstood my meaning of solid reads...

[Revenus]

Yeah, Iam is not voting Soda and his case is not strong.

Slandaar looks terrible but I'm assuming he's town based on gut.

Hiraki is bad bad bad. Should be voting him.

[Beck]

ok here is what I can tell from looking at who is voting soda.

Iamusername - isn't voting soda, he hasn't voted since he returned and Farada was voting vijau
theamateur - for being inactive
mastin - compromise vote, switches over to slandaar but moves back
vela - for lack of scum hunting and because he jumped on the wagon
hiraki - cause amateur tells people to join one of the 3 main wagons, he unvotes to jump to poppy but goes back. Hiraki never mentions soda all game

Pine, can you show me where the somewhat reasonable case was made, because looking at when people voted for him, I don't see it

the fact that hiraki joins the wagon without even mentioning soda the entire game is extremely distrubing, just as disturbing as every single vote on the Soda wagon. Soda MAY be a good lynch, but nobody has really provided anything.

Hiraki and Vela look the worst with mastin being a strong 3rd for his willingness to compromise his vote instead of make a case for who he really thinks should be lynched.

Vote hiraki

[Pine]

Yeah, Iam is not voting Soda and his case is not strong.

Slandaar looks terrible but I'm assuming he's town based on gut.

Hiraki is bad bad bad. Should be voting him.

I don't know if this is the scummiest post of the game, but it definitely deserves consideration from the nomination committee.

[Pine]

@Beck - I was going based solely on recollection, I don't recall a specific, point-by-point case. I may be confusing cases made in [REDACTED]. If you say one hasn't been made here, I have no reason to doubt you.

[Revenus]

Yeah, Iam is not voting Soda and his case is not strong.

Slandaar looks terrible but I'm assuming he's town based on gut.

Hiraki is bad bad bad. Should be voting him.

I don't know if this is the scummiest post of the game, but it definitely deserves consideration from the nomination committee.

How the hell is it scummy Pine?

Your scumhunting has regressed to pointing at things I say and going "see? it's scummy"

[Beck]

If you say one hasn't been made here, I have no reason to doubt you

Why are you being nice to me all of a sudden?

[ZeL1nK]

How is it still D1 at 80 pages?

Oh, right...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9fEjJ4Ecy9Q

Let's not lynch Revenus or Slandaar. Any other viable lynch is fine, really.

See that thing hiding over there in the corner whimpering? That's D1. It wants to be put out of its misery.

[Beck]

Rabble rabble rabble rabble

God help me, but rev's comment wasn't nearly as scummy as pine made it out to be.

Unless someone can post a good case, I don't see soda bein today's lynch either, especially since soda replaced out.

[Maxous]

An iso of soda shows 19 posts in this nearly 2000 post behemoth. For sheer lack of scum hunting on his part, I'm jumping the wagon. Plus, it wouldn't be fair to anyone else to /replace in to the madness that is a majority of this thread.

Noob 1170 ftw

Come jump the Soda wagon with me bro.

VOTE: Soda

I suggest that all people only change their votes to the 3 main wagons. It'll be near impossible to start a new one

truth

Unvote, Vote: Soda

Well Soda is the second least poster that was an original (aka not flaked and replaced)
and Funky is the least >.<
Since I'm assuming nobody wants to lynch Funky.

vote: Soda

Seriously. I don't think you are that inactive in your other games.

And Mastin's reasoning is more unclear than usual...

Lol, no

[Pine]

Slandaar looks scummy-->Gonna call him Town
Hiraki is "bad bad bad"--->Not gonna vote for him

In fairness, the first time I read the quoted post it looked like you were saying that you would be voting Soda though the case was not strong. I attribute that confusion to the haste and increasing annoyance I feel when reading your posts.

@Beck: You've gotten tolerable lately, and I find you so Towny that if you say you've done the research and no cogent case exists, I have no reason to doubt it. Now, if a case had existed and you'd put a value judgment on said case, I'd make my own assessment.