Mini 692: Boost Mafia (Game Over!)

Raging Rabbit · Fri Apr 17, 2009 5:33 am

Finished rereading. Today definitely changes things.

TDC - why did you spent the entire period I was away arguing with eldarad on one single point, instead of trying to come up with a case to explain your "lean" towards me?

eld - Since I appeared much more likely to vote for you than for TDC yesterday, why do you think TDC-scum chose to start today expressing a lean on me?

Raging Rabbit · Fri Apr 17, 2009 5:36 am

TDC wrote:But it tells you whether there are people that could potentially qualify for her statement, and would allow you to test the claim.

But you didn't say anything about boosting said vanillas, you were questioning their existence.

It's obviously a double standard, makes no sense and fits right into what else was part of his crap case.

So you think his plan was to get you lynched/vigged and have both him and eld survive the day/night cycle?

Raging Rabbit · Fri Apr 17, 2009 7:26 am

Alright, I believe you've answered me to the best of your ability. Now I'm just waiting for eldarad to answer my questions (eld, a one post summary of why TDC's scum and you're town would also be nice if you feel like it), then I'll meta you properly. That should give me all the info I need to finish this.

Raging Rabbit · Fri Apr 17, 2009 2:27 pm

TDC, I can't find any scum games of yours dated less than a year ago (the two latest appear to be newbie 591 and mini 584). Do any such games exist?

Raging Rabbit · Sun Apr 19, 2009 4:07 pm

So what's up with the answers, eld?

Raging Rabbit · Wed Apr 22, 2009 5:21 pm

No use going into my reasoning at this point, really...

Vote TDC

.

*crosses fingers*

Raging Rabbit · Thu Apr 23, 2009 1:06 am

What a relief. Definitely the most unnerving endgame I've ever been a part of.

eldarad- on the one hand, there was TDC making some good calls and looking almost exactly like his townie self for the entire game (I think all 3 scum played really well), while some of your arguments I strongly disagreed with. On the other, everything that happened today pointed towards you being town and TDC scum (first and foremost, there's the choice to go after TDC rather than myself, which would be a huge and pretty unnecassary gambit for scum-you). Then on taking a closer look in my reread, some of TDC's actions started looking too calculated while you felt somtimes misguided but genuine town. The answers you gave me strenghtened that feeling. TDC softclaiming non-vanilla sealed the deal.

Xtoxm - of course I'm to blame as well. I'm fully aware that my strongest weakness in this game is telling the difference between bad play and scummy play. That doesn't make said bad play any less annoying, though.

Great game, Patrick, I had a blast. Thanks to elmo for running the day show as well.

Raging Rabbit · Thu Apr 23, 2009 11:19 am

One thing I'm still wondering about, TDC, is exactly why you chose to bus Jahudo D1?

Raging Rabbit · Wed Apr 29, 2009 8:47 pm

TDC wrote:
eldarad wrote:I'm also well impressed with how we managed to lynch Xtoxm, lol.
Yeah, neither GC nor me really pushed that one, it was a genuine town effort :p

And I still think it made genuine sense. Given his PM, it's still completely beyond me what was Xtoxm thinking in that "I've already said, it's just the boost..." post.