#93 High School Mafia - Day Five - GAME OVER

vIQleS · Post Post #225 (ISO) » Sat Apr 03, 2004 3:21 pm

Vote Count:

Jaguar 2 (Samadhi, thorred)
melchizedek 1 (BadAndie)

4 to lynch.

Uraj45 · Post Post #226 (ISO) » Sat Apr 03, 2004 3:51 pm

To help myself as much as anyone else, I'll do a quick summary of my suspions:
BadAndie- His jumping around all the time wiht votes raises a bit of a red flag with me, but he also was very important in lynching Vraak so i don't now. However the fact that i'm not dead is leading me to more suspicion because if I ended up dead there would be a lot of susupicion on BadAndie, making it a fairly good choice for scum unless BadAndie is the scum.
Jaguar- He has offered a lot of useful posts and i don't think he's too suspicious.
melchizedek - I'm kinda suspicious based on just minor behavior things i can't quite place. Also, I don't know for sure that his claim request was a mistake. I'm tempted to vote for him because i don't have anyone better to vote for.
Samadhi - I really don't know about him. Neutral mostly.
Talitha - I'm kinda neutral here too but i'm going to move that to suspicious becauses I've seen her fool everybody in other games and i can't quite trust her.
thorred - Another neutral here. I'm not quite sure.

BadAndie · Post Post #227 (ISO) » Sat Apr 03, 2004 5:26 pm

it's nothing big, but i am a she

thorred · Post Post #228 (ISO) » Mon Apr 05, 2004 8:03 am

No-one at school??
Not much has happened since my last post, and I have nothing to add. But where is everyone?

Talitha · Post Post #229 (ISO) » Mon Apr 05, 2004 8:36 am

Well we have 2 main suspects and neither of them are talking...

I'll

vote: melchizedek

to prod him because I think Jaguar might be away for another day or so.

Uraj45 · Post Post #230 (ISO) » Mon Apr 05, 2004 3:41 pm

Very sorry about that. The "Andie" in your username always messes me up.

Samadhi · Post Post #231 (ISO) » Mon Apr 05, 2004 7:03 pm

Talitha, I'll have no part of the Melchizedek vote until the Jaguar vote is concluded. Frankly, your decision to supercede the cautious third day band wagon makes me reconsider whether there is only one scum left.

Talitha · Post Post #232 (ISO) » Mon Apr 05, 2004 7:31 pm

What? I really don't understand what you're on about Samadhi. I have stated earlier that I am suspicious of melchizedek, and now I am voting for him. My vote is not set in stone but I would like to hear from Melchizedek as I feel he is being suspiciously quiet.

I'm not trying to convince you or anyone else how to vote. It was a prod. You're more than welcome to bandwagon whomever you find suspicious and I hope that you'll allow me to do the same.

Jaguar · Post Post #233 (ISO) » Tue Apr 06, 2004 2:51 am

Hello all. Back from my three-day weekend and managed to get my home computer almost internet worthy. Just need to reinstall the virus protector, fire wall and pop-up killer and pretty soon I'll be up and running from home again.

I see that I have two votes and that Melch has two votes. I will go back to

vote: Melchizedek

to put some additional pressure on him and at the same time I will try to explain why I think certain people are scum.

I am the sidekick. I hang out with all the cool people and stay out of the limelight. For now... The for now mean that I am the back-up cop and took over as gossip chick when Yaw got turned into a geek. I have received the results from Yaw's investigations, and so far all his results were that people were cool.

If you would like to know the cool results, you can judge for yourself why I have been building a case against certain people, however, I think you can figure it out for yourself. Yaw's last investigation was of me and apparently I am the coolest.

BadAndie · Post Post #234 (ISO) » Tue Apr 06, 2004 6:20 am

Very sorry about that. The "Andie" in your username always messes me up.

no biggie

am the sidekick. I hang out with all the cool people and stay out of the limelight. For now... The for now mean that I am the back-up cop and took over as gossip chick when Yaw got turned into a geek. I have received the results from Yaw's investigations, and so far all his results were that people were cool.

call me slow, but are you placing a vote on Melch as a result of your investigation?

Talitha, I'll have no part of the Melchizedek vote until the Jaguar vote is concluded. Frankly, your decision to supercede the cautious third day band wagon makes me reconsider whether there is only one scum left.

seems a bit scummy, makes me think if there are more than 1 mafia, or there is a trator among us. or maybe he is a townie who just doesn't want to lose the game. hmmmm

Jaguar · Post Post #235 (ISO) » Tue Apr 06, 2004 6:31 am

BadAndie, I did not yet get to investigate anyone as Yaw was only killed the last game night. I did however receive all of his investigative results and those so far were all cool. In essense, I am basing my vote on Melch on my own reasoning from before the weekend, even though he voted for both Vraak and Argoti, and the cool/innocent results of Yaw's investigations.

If Melch is innocent, there are only three other possibles that I've already pointed out somewhere I believe. Uraj, in my mind, tops that list.

I am still willing to change votes at this time and think that for now we should look at both Uraj and Melch. Uraj has claimed a killing role and although he doesn't have to kill according to his claim, there is a chance that he is in fact capable of killing, he is just not cool... A very convenient claim.

And Melch, well, Yaw was suspicious of him, although not enough to investigate him and for some reason he just seems scummy to me. Could just be a bad womanly instinct though...

Samadhi · Post Post #236 (ISO) » Tue Apr 06, 2004 6:58 am

Back up cop? In a game this small AND you get the dead cop's results?

Personally, I don't buy it, but I'd like to hear what other people say.

Talitha · Post Post #237 (ISO) » Tue Apr 06, 2004 11:01 am

unvote: melchizedek

I don't think he needs 3 votes on him right now while we're discussing Jag's claim.

I think we should probably hear Jaguar's investigation results because it will help us decide whether we think she's telling the truth. And if she is innocent she'll probably be killed tonight, assuming that she survives today's lynch. Her info will be most helpful after she's dead because we'll know whether or not we can trust it.

What do others think about hearing Jag's results? The only downside I can think of is that if she is innocent then it will expose other confirmed innocents... but at this stage of the game I think that's a good thing.

The other thing is, if Jaguar is the back up cop, then there is probably a back up doc too. I don't know why but it seems to be an unwritten rule of game setup, that if you have a backup cop, you also have a backup doc. If there is a doc still floating around, we probably do not want them to come forward, though.
Any thoughts on that?

BadAndie · Post Post #238 (ISO) » Tue Apr 06, 2004 11:17 am

ok so melch had 3 votes on him, and the geeks didn't jump on that?! could this be prof that melch is in fact a geek?

as for jag's claim i don't know if i buy it yet. to add to that i don't know about the doc thing yet either

Jaguar · Post Post #239 (ISO) » Tue Apr 06, 2004 11:34 am

Well, I am more than willing to reveal my results, but it will give the remaining geek (at least I assume there is only one left) some nice targets as confirmed innocents.

I would imagine that perhaps there is another sidekick? Or someone else with a back-up role?

I too reasoned like BadAndie did. With three votes on melch, why didn't the geek jump on that? Is it because Melch

is

the remaining geek?

BadAndie · Post Post #240 (ISO) » Tue Apr 06, 2004 11:38 am

if we lynch him, would we lose?

Uraj45 · Post Post #241 (ISO) » Tue Apr 06, 2004 4:00 pm

no smart mafia would ever finish mel off without ample justification. with only one mafia left, that person would almost certainly be targeted by me at night or lynched in the day.

BadAndie · Post Post #242 (ISO) » Wed Apr 07, 2004 6:06 am

no smart mafia would ever finish mel off without ample justification. with only one mafia left, that person would almost certainly be targeted by me at night or lynched in the day.

Not really uraj, he is pretty suspicious. He is really close to a lynch and has yet to respond. I say we lynch him, and if he isn't scum, then we go from there

Samadhi · Post Post #243 (ISO) » Wed Apr 07, 2004 7:40 am

Jaguar wrote:I too reasoned like BadAndie did. With three votes on melch, why didn't the geek jump on that? Is it because Melch is the remaining geek?

Or maybe the geek was already voting for Mel?

Jaguar · Post Post #244 (ISO) » Wed Apr 07, 2004 8:35 am

Samadhi wrote: Or maybe the geek was already voting for Mel?

That is of course possible and would make either BadAndie or Talitha suspect.

Hhmm. Melch hasn't posted since last Thursday. Why would Talitha unvote Melch? He hasn't put up a defence at all and nobody else was looking to change votes. Is it because she knowns he is innocent?

(Grasping at straws here, I only know three innocents, whereas the scum would know all)

BadAndie · Post Post #245 (ISO) » Wed Apr 07, 2004 9:50 am

100% townie here

I am basically the kid who is really into music, i don't care if i am cool or not, that is what makes me cool

If we lynch Melch, we still have a chance of winning. The only reason that i am saying this, is because he is the scummiest and has yet to come up with a defense. It's not down to a pick right situation or lose. So i think we should go 4 it

melchizedek · Post Post #246 (ISO) » Wed Apr 07, 2004 9:54 am

Sorry. I was grounded and unable to get to a computer since last Friday. I am a cheerleader. After hearing PBug's claim I assumed I was a back-up doc. I have not however, recieved any message to that effect. I am hoping that there is another cheerleader who took over as doc.

I am still suspicious of BadAndie and Talitha. IMO, the best plan is to get rid of them right away. I admit that myprevious plan had some flaws which need to be worked out. I still believe that BadAndie is very suspicious and will leave my vote where it is.

BadAndie · Post Post #247 (ISO) » Wed Apr 07, 2004 10:59 am

I still believe that BadAndie is very suspicious and will leave my vote where it is.

I am suspicious? OK this definitly confirms in my mind that u r scum! I have helped get rid of both geeks, and i am a geek?! if i didn't have a vote on u right now i'd place 1

Talitha · Post Post #248 (ISO) » Wed Apr 07, 2004 4:24 pm

Jaguar: Please lets hear your investigation results, since no-one has spoken against it.

Everyone else: Please stop roleclaiming uneccesarily. It only helps the scum. (Although I'm interested about what Samadhi thinks of Melchizedek's claim).

Jaguar · Post Post #249 (ISO) » Wed Apr 07, 2004 5:45 pm

Well, I didn't hear any objections from anyone either, so here goes. My innocents are thorred and Samadhi. And it looks like Yaw's last target was me.

Yes, I have been jumping around, but I don't know who the remaining scum is. I thought for sure it was Melch, but then Samadhi pointed out that he voted on both scum. Then I thought it was BadAndie, but I think she's pretty much in the clear, putting up good arguments for voting for Argoti and then pointing out that Vraak seemed to have been on the bandwagon late. So I am really in a toss up now and don't know where to go. I am not sure of Talitha, after all, she really appeared not to know that Vraak was away, however, a random first day vote on him could have been a tactic to make things look that way. And Uraj's claim is very convenient as well, although since we have a back-up cop, perhaps not too far off.

So, since we've heard Melch's claim (not quite sure I buy it), Uraj's claim and I have cool results on thorred and Samadhi, that leaves Talitha and BadAndie.

For now I will

unvote: melchizedek

and let's see what theories others can come up with.

Note my earlier post about people not voting for Vraak on day two and note that three out of the four not investigated did not vote for him, making it much harder to point fingers.