Mini Normal 2336 | Birds | Night 3

[Black]

additional note: do the pronouns below my username not show for anyone else? i use they, not she

I didn't see them until now, my apologies!

[HighPrincessErinys]

What about the Alyssa/Shinless situation?

anyway putting a pin in this because this one is honestly still kinda waking up, haven't been paying the most attention to that

[GreedyBanger]

UNVOTE:

Is there anything more to the alyssa wagon than what was just discussed on the rose one? Can someone run me down on why we are pushing for a claim there?

[HighPrincessErinys]

UNVOTE:

Is there anything more to the alyssa wagon than what was just discussed on the rose one? Can someone run me down on why we are pushing for a claim there?

Greedy.......................................................................................................

[GreedyBanger]

UNVOTE:

Is there anything more to the alyssa wagon than what was just discussed on the rose one? Can someone run me down on why we are pushing for a claim there?

Greedy.......................................................................................................

I read alyssa/shinless as early day 1 slapfighting.

[HighPrincessErinys]

Go on.

[GreedyBanger]

Go on.

I'll give a deeper read and find something constructive to say I guess. I was letting HT cook earlier and letting the whole thing simmer but the Alyssa wagon may be burnt.

[HighPrincessErinys]

Alrighty. It just rubbed me the wrong way with how you seem to be hopping on and off wagons without much thought.

[HighPrincessErinys]

But that doesn't quite seem to be the case, it should add.

[GreedyBanger]

Like, am I actually supposed to just vote Hu Tao for trolling at this point? I refuse to believe that this is a legitimate playstyle or, if it

is

considered legitimate here, that it's healthy for the game. I really hate dignifying it with a response but god it's frustrating.

This is the kind of indignation that i'd expect here from town. Fakeable? For sure. Fakeable for scum digging their heels in so much on the shinless thing when it clearly doesn't serve them to do so? What's the throughline there? Is she aware or isn't she?

[geraintm]

VOTE: Rose

Sorry to spoil the fun but I think I'd rather run this up to a claim

i doubt it's safe to claim D1, but since i'm VT i'm fluff for town anyways. /shrug

VOTE: rose
Again

You so need to die.

[Black]

ah, cripes. that makes at least seven scum-like slips i've done already. might as well hammer me now

I don't like this. Feels overly defensive, even as a joke

T3 thought i was town newbie for a similar reason, you may wish to reason with him on that as well.

I get the vibe that Rosen is trying to get geraintm off of their scent with this comment

true, i wanna know what she's thinking too.
IAMAKIWI and MickeyCop have also been lurking with no conversation, my vote's between these three

(not that it matters D1 anyways)

Rosen I would like to know what you meant by this, the blue part in particular

Hey Hu Tao, wanna contribute to the conversation?

No

Pretty please?

No you're scum

if she's scum, who d'you think she's scum with? surely you're not just tunneled on one player alone.

This feels like a busywork question. I don't think new!town actually asks this question with the intention to sort, especially so early in the game. I could be wrong about this though

as for Alyssa, post 80 seems... really strange? she highlights two statements and insists they're vastly different ("didn't really joke around" and "without saying anything") for a reason i can't decipher. i don't think she can decipher it either, since she pushes the responsibility for explaining it onto T3 instead of giving a response.

I couldn't help but skim a bit on my phone and Alyssa feels...stiff or something. Idk how to describe it but I'm down to pressure here

she definitely has a tendency to answer questions with other questions, and even if that's town that's a shite play (like what Hu Tao did earlier). that being said i'll side with you here

VOTE: Alyssa (E-1, Black's count was right)

And finally, I really didn't like this vote. I don't think Rosen's Alyssa scumread is strong enough to want to fade her

[geraintm]

I get exactly the same vibe from Rose. Scum who just can't help themselves, too excited.

[GreedyBanger]

199 is holding 90% of your case there I think black but it is pretty bad. I'd be a lot happier with Rose than Alyssa. Will commit vote when I get done with my reread.

[Black]

It's admittedly not a strong case, a lot of gut vibes and stuff, but it's a pretty solid feeling for page 10 imo

[GreedyBanger]

It's admittedly not a strong case, a lot of gut vibes and stuff, but it's a pretty solid feeling for page 10 imo

I meant 199 was bad not the case as far as things go, if that wasn't clear.

thing; you'll probably see some more "weird" behavior from me as the game goes on. not much i can do if you just think i have a strange vibe

Yikes.
This is the one part of the Rose patented small and innocent routine that I do actually read as negatively AI towards scum. Its SO self conscious that I don't think it matters if they are running game or not for me not to like it.

Reread reads list. I won't do these often, and never near the end of days, but no issue with me collecting my thoughts and sharing them now.

Town
1.
2.
3. Black,Val89
4. Alyssa, DArby, rabbitrhino(For what there is), geraintm, Erinys,
5. HT ZONE OF SHENANIGANARY feat. Shinless
6. T3
7.Rose, KJQ
8.
9.
10.
Scum

Pretty horribly clustered and inoffensive. For shame.

[GreedyBanger]

VOTE: Rose

[Rosenator]

ok! i'll take a look at all of this and see where it lies

ah, cripes. that makes at least seven scum-like slips i've done already. might as well hammer me now

I don't like this. Feels overly defensive, even as a joke

that's a vibes thing, i'm still feeling out where the boundaries are.

T3 thought i was town newbie for a similar reason, you may wish to reason with him on that as well.

I get the vibe that Rosen is trying to get geraintm off of their scent with this comment

true, i wanna know what she's thinking too.
IAMAKIWI and MickeyCop have also been lurking with no conversation, my vote's between these three

(not that it matters D1 anyways)

Rosen I would like to know what you meant by this, the blue part in particular

i wanted to hear from the other slots, since i didn't think they would be replaced. (but i am hearing from those slots now! hello!)
specifically for your emphasised part, i'd rather wait for more info but that's not something we'll get until D2 when cop gets info and someone flips. i'm not good with reads

Hey Hu Tao, wanna contribute to the conversation?

No

Pretty please?

No you're scum

if she's scum, who d'you think she's scum with? surely you're not just tunneled on one player alone.

This feels like a busywork question. I don't think new!town actually asks this question with the intention to sort, especially so early in the game. I could be wrong about this though

again, i'm still feeling out what i should be doing in a longer-term game (this is my first forum mafia game, but not first mafia game in general). while i didn't intend to sort, i've been told before in posts like 31 that it comes across as that - and I do see how sorting plus rushing (the eagerness others have mentioned) greatly helps scum. i should probably take a backseat like D'Arby and T3 have

as for Alyssa, post 80 seems... really strange? she highlights two statements and insists they're vastly different ("didn't really joke around" and "without saying anything") for a reason i can't decipher. i don't think she can decipher it either, since she pushes the responsibility for explaining it onto T3 instead of giving a response.

I couldn't help but skim a bit on my phone and Alyssa feels...stiff or something. Idk how to describe it but I'm down to pressure here

she definitely has a tendency to answer questions with other questions, and even if that's town that's a shite play (like what Hu Tao did earlier). that being said i'll side with you here

VOTE: Alyssa (E-1, Black's count was right)

And finally, I really didn't like this vote. I don't think Rosen's Alyssa scumread is strong enough to want to fade her

that's completely fair. i just think she's being elusive instead of providing concrete answers - which i suppose is hypocritical since nobody has concrete info D1.

UNVOTE:

[Rosenator]

also, if you ISO geraintm you'll see nothing from them but a tunnel based on a non-serious gut. truly a player who's swayed by their lunch rather than the crowd

[GreedyBanger]

I can feel the confirmation bias flooding through me. Like Popeye's spinach.

[Black]

Town
1.
2.
3. Black,Val89
4. Alyssa, DArby, rabbitrhino(For what there is), geraintm, Erinys,
5. HT ZONE OF SHENANIGANARY feat. Shinless
6. T3
7.Rose, KJQ
8.
9.
10.
Scum

There's something I really like about this list but I think it's beneficial for me to not talk about it quite yet. Just putting this here for later

[DArby]

Hmm. Maybe I was a bit biased with the noob claim for Rosen. I’d like to see more content from them before a potential lim tho.

@Rosen what do you mean seeing where it lies? What do you mean taking a back seat like me and T3?

[DArby]

@Rosen also you said “when cop gets info” in that post as well. Are you saying you know there’s a cop in the game ?

[GreedyBanger]

@Rosen also you said “when cop gets info” in that post as well. Are you saying you know there’s a cop in the game ?

Zoinks.

I dunno about that question scoob

[DArby]

@Rosen also you said “when cop gets info” in that post as well. Are you saying you know there’s a cop in the game ?

Zoinks.

I dunno about that question scoob

I know where I’m going with this question, Shaggy.